10. [Beginning of the question missing in the recording] … it has come to light that in the book Bihar al-Anwar of the Shias it is recorded that the Messenger of God (saw) placed his hand on the shoulders of Hazrat Salman Farsi (ra) and indicated that the Imam Mahdi would be from the people of Persia. According to the beliefs of the Ahmadiyya Muslim Jamaat, the lineage of Mirza Ghulam Ahmad (as) goes back to the people of Persia. But Bihar al-Anwar also mentions that the Imam Mahdi will stand by the wall of the Ka‘bah and announce: ‘I am the Imam Mahdi.’ Did Mirza Ghulam Ahmad (as) stand by the wall of the Ka‘bah and make this announcement? If so, provide authentic proofs. – Ashiq Hussain Sabir.
Urdu question-and-answer session, 13 February 1984
AI-translated (from Urdu), recording partly hard to hear, some parts rendered by sense
Question: [Beginning of the question missing in the recording] … it has come to light that in the book Bihar al-Anwar of the Shias it is recorded that the Messenger of God (saw) placed his hand on the shoulders of Hazrat Salman Farsi (ra) and indicated that the Imam Mahdi would be from the people of Persia. According to the beliefs of the Ahmadiyya Muslim Jamaat, the lineage of Mirza Ghulam Ahmad (as) goes back to the people of Persia. But Bihar al-Anwar also mentions that the Imam Mahdi will stand by the wall of the Ka‘bah and announce: ‘I am the Imam Mahdi.’ Did Mirza Ghulam Ahmad (as) stand by the wall of the Ka‘bah and make this announcement? If so, provide authentic proofs. – Ashiq Hussain Sabir.
I have already explained this clearly earlier in answer to another question, that there is a great deal of contradiction in the Ahadith concerning the Imam Mahdi. There are several Ahadith which, if accepted in full, make others appear unfulfilled. Therefore, if you base your case on all those Ahadith that relate to incidental events, this dispute can never be settled until the Day of Judgement. Hear the matter of the wall of the Ka‘bah: if in the questioner’s view this was a necessary condition and not an incidental event, and it is not to be interpreted otherwise, then the claimant to being Imam Mahdi who rose from the House of the Ka‘bah at the end of the [fourteenth] century presented a Hadith in his support, and that Hadith was printed in the newspapers of Pakistan. The Hadith was that when the Imam Mahdi appears, he will appear with an armed group, he will kiss the Black Stone, then he will stand against the wall of the Ka‘bah and announce that he is the Imam Mahdi, and he will be the true Imam Mahdi. All the conditions were fulfilled in this person — someone who was dealt with and disposed of within a few days. One should look for proofs in which incidental happenings play no part; proofs of such a nature that, like a monument, they carry the testimony of their truth within themselves and endure. Such proofs are above the person. Look at the earlier claimants: every claimant to Mahdi-hood who announced that Allah had made him Imam — not one whom people made so later, but who said, ‘At God’s bidding I have stood up, I make this claim’ — how did God deal with them, and how with this one? Do you see no difference? Monumental proofs are like a procession that moves on, whose size grows century after century. Thus all the claimants to being Imam Mahdi who claimed that Allah had made them Imam — you will find them mentioned in books, but in the world of facts no trace of them remains; neither do their movements continue, nor do they have any support in the world, nor do nations treat them the way opponents have always treated God’s true people. There is only one, Hazrat Mirza Sahib (as); apart from him there is none who stands at this station. [unclear] For one, that supporting Hadith which the followers of Fiqh-e-Jafariyya themselves have presented — most of whose contents are accepted as true; in any case it is a fact that it happened this way. Everyone knows that sometimes narrators added something, sometimes someone did not understand the meaning correctly, often there is an inner meaning and [the outward] is not fulfilled. Fulfilling every single narration and every Hadith is simply not possible. Therefore we have to seek such things in which a strong probability becomes visible, where indications show that this can be. After that one must turn to those testimonies which are the testimonies of nations and relate to the Sunnah of Allah. So the real truth of the Imam Mahdi will be shown by this: just as the earlier truthful ones were opposed, he will be opposed too; and just as the earlier truthful ones, despite being weak, kept prevailing day by day, so the world will not be able to wipe out the movement of the Imam Mahdi; despite [weakness] and despite all opposition, it will advance. This is the standard of truthfulness that the Holy Qur’an presents, and in this standard you will never see any change. Where is the justice in abandoning standards that are above the person and running after doubtful narrations? See whether this grand testimony has ever been fulfilled in favour of any other claimant to Mahdi-hood — you will never see it fulfilled. As I said, [unclear] the claimant who came just recently, [unclear] two or three years have passed, and what remains of him? After a few days people will not even know of him; he remains preserved only in books. And now [regarding Ahmadiyya]: how much opposition you have mounted, how many homes you have burned, how many Ahmadis you have martyred, how many shops you have looted, how many mosques you have set on fire, how many callers to prayer you have killed — saying, ‘Who are you to call the Adhan?’ How many children you have orphaned, how many women widowed! The opposition you cannot deny, but neither can you deny that despite all opposition this movement has grown, not shrunk. This is the factual proof that moves like a procession. Just as a river flows and with every stretch, every stage, begins to grow, so it is with divine communities: no obstacle of opposition, no rock can stop them. [unclear] This is a proof for everyone, young and old, unlettered and educated. Look at these things.