11. [Someone writes:] When Allah the Almighty had also created the angels for worship, what wisdom was there in also engaging Muslims in worship, the five daily prayers, voluntary prayers etc.? That is, the angels were not enough? Allah’s desire for worship is apparently not being fulfilled. The angels were already worshipping, and on top of that He also put the Muslims to it. [The questioner says:] We achieved nothing through worship; through worship we got beaten. The more prayers we offered, the more humiliated and wretched we became; the prayers we made [led to helplessness]. We were taught the prayer: ‘O Allah, help … and help us against the disbelieving people.’ And the result: when Muslims fought, they were beaten. Therefore we do not understand the purpose of worship: God’s desire is not being fulfilled, and on top of that those who obeyed were killed. So let go of this matter; what is the use of sitting here?

Urdu question-and-answer session, 13 February 1984

AI-translated (from Urdu)

Question: [Someone writes:] When Allah the Almighty had also created the angels for worship, what wisdom was there in also engaging Muslims in worship, the five daily prayers, voluntary prayers etc.? That is, the angels were not enough? Allah’s desire for worship is apparently not being fulfilled. The angels were already worshipping, and on top of that He also put the Muslims to it. [The questioner says:] We achieved nothing through worship; through worship we got beaten. The more prayers we offered, the more humiliated and wretched we became; the prayers we made [led to helplessness]. We were taught the prayer: ‘O Allah, help … and help us against the disbelieving people.’ And the result: when Muslims fought, they were beaten. Therefore we do not understand the purpose of worship: God’s desire is not being fulfilled, and on top of that those who obeyed were killed. So let go of this matter; what is the use of sitting here?

A very interesting question; he has presented it nicely. And I think in Sindh there is a need for answers to such questions, because in view of the particular circumstances of Sindh, the political unrest and discontent found here, certain big powers are trying to convert it into atheism and to alienate Ahmadis [uncertain: people] from religion. And in contrast, an extremely foolish attempt is being made to impose politics in the name of religion. People who are disgusted with politics are becoming disgusted with religion too. [Persian: ‘I died, and it became even worse.’] Subhanallah! Outsiders were already trying, and now our own people have started helping them. Therefore I am very worried about the faith of the generations here, that against these poor innocent people, our students studying here, not only are foreign powers at work to create mischief in their thinking, but our own people are helping the outsiders. As a result such questions arise. A very valid question. Let us answer it, even if it takes a bit more time; I think you want to hear it fully. When Allah the Almighty originally created [man] for worship, there are alongside other verses and sayings of the Holy Prophet (saw) that shed light on this subject of what the purpose of worship is. [The assumption is that] Allah has a craving to be worshipped that is not being fulfilled. Allah the Almighty says elsewhere that if not a single being among you worships God, it makes no difference to Him. Allah the Almighty says: ‘I have not created the jinn and men except that they may worship Me.’ I have not created any creation for any other purpose. It follows that when the Holy Qur’an claims that [man] was created for worship, the benefit of that worship does not reach Allah; if it reaches anyone, it reaches you. That is definite. And the question is what worship actually is; until you understand this, the subject of the benefit of worship cannot become clear. ‘Ibadat’ comes from the word ‘Abd’, meaning slave, and the essence of a slave is that nothing belongs to him; everything belongs to his master. And Ibadat, when used in Arabic [of a path]: ‘a road was made smooth’ — when one walks on a path so that it gets beaten, walks on it in such a way that furrows form and marks are established, that is, with great effort and labour treads a regular path. When it is said ‘Worship Allah’, it means: submit to the will of God, therein lies your benefit; adopt the colour in which Allah wants to dye you. Another meaning of Ibadat is that a slave does not go ahead of his master but follows him and tries to become like him. [God says:] If you adopt My attributes, you will attain paradise in this world. He has explained these attributes in detail. The prayer that strips man of these attributes — God the Almighty Himself curses that worship; and the worship from which mankind gains no benefit — for God says: not for My benefit but for your benefit — the Holy Qur’an curses that worship. [unclear] He says about such worshippers: ‘So woe to those who pray, who are unmindful of their prayer.’ Ruin upon those who pray but forget their prayers. Meaning: they are well versed in the rituals of worship, they bang their foreheads in mosques, [unclear], they are present too, but of the spirit of worship they are unaware. He says why: two things arise in them. First, show — they worship to be seen, to appear pious and to be called saintly in people’s eyes, and their entire life’s effort is spent on displaying saintliness. Allah the Almighty in the Holy Qur’an [condemns] this worship which [unclear]; such worship will not make you God’s beloved but will bring a curse upon you, so that whole nations are destroyed. When such hypocrites become leaders of a nation, they destroy it. The second attribute He described: if you worship but do not care for the poor and do not respect their rights, then this worship too will bring a curse upon you. He said: what kind of worshippers of Mine are these? On one hand they show off, and on the other, when the poor need small ordinary things, [they abandon them]; they withhold even trifles from them and do not fulfil even their smallest needs. He said: this worship is not acceptable to Me; if a nation performs such worship, it will draw a curse upon itself. So this question confirms the teaching of the Holy Qur’an. The worship that Hazrat Muhammad Mustafa (saw) demonstrated and on which his Companions (ra) stood firm — at that time there was not the picture being shown today. At that time, through the blessing of that very worship, the ignorant, insignificant people of Arabia, who had no weight between the world’s two great powers — in the East there was one great power and in the West another, on one side Chosroes (Kisra), on the other Caesar (Qaisar) — who cared about Arabia? They [the great powers] did as they pleased, [unclear]; with small forces they had them punished. Once [they captured] seventy thousand Arabs and strung them with rings, that is, iron rings; a long ring from one side, a ring from the other, and with hands tied behind their backs threaded into this ring, and let them go: ‘You are an example of warning; if ever you cast an evil eye on our country, we will do this to you.’ When they performed the worship God wanted, in which no admixture of self was included, which was full of sympathy for mankind and in which the poor were cared for, that worship bore such fruits that in no time the empire of Chosroes was subjugated and the empire of Caesar too was shattered to pieces. Then worship changed its colour, until it took on the colour it has today. So the present humiliation of Muslims, and the humiliation of Muslims for [some] hundred years, testifies: the Holy Qur’an is true, you are false. If you were performing the worship of the Holy Qur’an, God the Almighty would not treat you this way. Instead of blaming Islam, look at your own character, look into your hearts. [unclear: idolatry/selfishness] has crept in, and Taqwa no longer remains. Society is filthy, full of discord, lies, bad character. Whether it sounds bitter or sweet, there is no other reality at present. They fight for the sake of their egos, sow discord among themselves, issue verdicts against one another, set one another against each other, declare each other disbelievers, order killing, order [unclear], and then they say they are worshipping. The Holy Qur’an does not give these as signs of worship; how then will their worship be accepted?

10 of 10 left today