13. [Someone] says: Tell us something about halal and haram. For example, pork and alcohol are forbidden for Muslims. Other nations of the world eat pork and drink alcohol. What is the punishment for this in Islam?

Urdu question-and-answer session, 13 February 1984

AI-translated (from Urdu)

Question: [Someone] says: Tell us something about halal and haram. For example, pork and alcohol are forbidden for Muslims. Other nations of the world eat pork and drink alcohol. What is the punishment for this in Islam?

[unclear] The orientation [of the question] has been twisted. It seems that Islam is being presented as a representative of punishments; its image has been hidden behind punishments as though it were nothing else. Yet it is the mercy of Islam that it [prescribes punishments] only for a few minor offences, and even then only in special circumstances and in a special society. Since punishments have been mentioned, I will also tell you this: [Islamic punishments] cannot be imposed in a [non-Islamic] society, even if it calls itself Muslim — forget that. However great the power may be, it is not capable of imposing Islamic punishments in a non-Islamic society. Take a small example: whatever punishment for adultery you lay down, whether flogging or stoning, that is not the point. It cannot be imposed in a society that is non-Islamic, even if its name is Muslim; in a society where it is so prevalent that liars are found in such abundance that for fifty rupees one can have testimony given against another’s life, [for some money] testimony given against another’s life; where dishonesty is increasing to such an extent — let any government enforce the punishment for adultery in that society! To find [four witnesses] you need two hundred rupees; in that society they will stand up and testify that they saw that person doing this with their own eyes. Then even the few honest people who remain will be killed; this majority society will devour them in the name of Islam. So show me a way in which Islamic punishments can be enforced in a non-Islamic society — impossible. So what cannot happen [leave it]; worry about how an Islamic society can be established. Mercy and punishment come afterwards. Now I will shed light only on the philosophy; one minute remains, I can say it within that. The Holy Qur’an is the only book that has not described anything as absolute evil. It has explained the philosophy of halal and haram thus: that their benefit is less than their harm, that is, their harm is greater than their benefit. When the balance of a thing turns out such that it has benefits but the harms are greater, the Holy Qur’an has forbidden it. Only after so long [since then] are doctors beginning to learn what terrible diseases are taking root in our society as a result. Some diseases they know, the outward diseases the materialists [know], for example the coagulation of blood, and the [cysts] that form in the blood and in the flesh and paralyse [a person]; the diseases from these worms — scientific research says they are caused by pork. [There is] no other meat as coagulating and as high in cholesterol as pork. That is what the outward eye sees; but there are also inner defects that arise from meat, i.e. food, and appear as a result of the food: human inclination, its [revulsion], filth — whether one accepts filth or abhors it. This is inward, which is in God’s sight; the eye of this world has not yet reached there. In the case of alcohol it has become fully manifest; it has become as clear as daylight. Those societies that used to criticise Muslims for forbidding alcohol, even though it gives so much pleasure and enjoyment — their governments are now running campaigns against alcohol. There have been periods when governments made the country ‘dry’ and said it is a most deadly thing that has destroyed everything; in America too many states made it dry, and people would go to other states to drink alcohol. And now their magazines, their newspapers, their researchers are running a large-scale campaign against alcohol. So Allah the Almighty says: when I forbid something, it does not mean that there is no benefit in it at all, that it is devoid of benefit. We say Our sight is on the fact that for your society, for your welfare, there are some things in which there is benefit but the harm is greater; where greater harm results, there Allah the Almighty has forbidden it. This is the philosophy of halal and haram that Islam has, and this is also a uniqueness of Islam. In the scripture of no other religion in the world is this philosophy of halal and haram presented. Followers of other religions who are present may well search and see; I have researched very thoroughly — not even by way of allusion is this grand philosophy found in any other religion. So this question convinces a person all the more of Islam, rather than taking him away from Islam.

10 of 10 left today