2. Are the Promised Messiah and the Imam Mahdi one and the same person, or two different persons?

Urdu question-and-answer session, 15 February 1984

AI-translated (from Urdu), recording partly hard to hear, some parts rendered by sense

Question: Are the Promised Messiah and the Imam Mahdi one and the same person, or two different persons?

They are two names of one and the same person. This is a fundamental difference between us and other Muslims. They believe the Imam Mahdi is a separate person and Jesus son of Mary another, holding both distinct: one descends from heaven, the other is born on earth as Imam Mahdi. We say: in Ibn Maja it is written 'La Mahdi illa Isa' – there is no Mahdi except Isa. The Mahdi's name is Isa and Isa's name is Mahdi. They are not two great Messiahs; rather one person receives two titles from Allah.

[Partly unintelligible.] The Holy Prophet (saw) said Mujaddids (reformers) will come at the head of every century until the Messiah comes. No objection applies to us, as we believe the Messiah has come. It applies to those who say neither the Messiah nor the Mahdi nor any Mujaddid has come. All Muslims believe a Mujaddid came at the head of each century – that of the second millennium being Mujaddid Alf-e-Thani, Shaikh Ahmad Sirhindi; Hadhrat Sayyid Ahmad (Barelwi) is also mentioned. People expected the Imam Mahdi at the head of the fourteenth century and placed many hopes on it. At the head of that century only one came, whom the Maulawis call a liar; then show us the true one! It was said the Imam would come at the century's head; then in the years 30, 34; then around 1320; then that the century was not yet over – until it passed, the fifteenth century began and was celebrated. They said an Imam Mahdi or Mujaddid at its head was not even necessary. So Imam and Mujaddid failed to come, and the fourteenth and fifteenth centuries passed. [Remainder up to line 439 largely unintelligible; it concerns those who believe neither Mujaddid nor Messiah has come.]

10 of 10 left today