2. You have referred to the mercy for the worlds, the conduct and noble character of the Holy Prophet (saw); there is not the slightest room for doubt in that. But I find a Sura in the Holy Qur’an in which it says: 'Bismillahir-Rahmanir-Rahim. 'Abasa wa tawalla, an ja'ahul-a'ma'. In its commentary most commentators of Islam have written incidents which [reflect a flaw] in character. Please shed light on this.
Urdu question-and-answer session, 1 March 1984
AI-translated (from Urdu), recording partly hard to hear, some parts rendered by sense
Question: You have referred to the mercy for the worlds, the conduct and noble character of the Holy Prophet (saw); there is not the slightest room for doubt in that. But I find a Sura in the Holy Qur’an in which it says: 'Bismillahir-Rahmanir-Rahim. 'Abasa wa tawalla, an ja'ahul-a'ma'. In its commentary most commentators of Islam have written incidents which [reflect a flaw] in character. Please shed light on this.
Very good, JazakAllah. You have asked a very lovely question; I am pleased because you have studied with a fine eye. Otherwise this question cannot even come to mind unless one studies the Holy Qur’an with a deep eye and checks whether every statement satisfies; otherwise this question cannot arise. He means: there is a Sura in the Holy Qur’an [in which] it is stated about the Holy Prophet Muhammad Mustafa (saw), and the heading of this Sura says: Muhammad Mustafa (saw) frowned and turned away, 'an ja'ahul-a'ma', because a blind man came to him. And then the Holy Prophet (saw) is addressed: 'Wa ma yudrika la'allahu yazzakka, aw yadhdhakkaru fatanfa'ahudh-dhikra'—he is blind and outwardly an insignificant person, but how do you know that he is not closer to guidance and was about to receive purification or admonition from you? And then He says: how did you become sure that the other person, whom you were addressing and to whom you were giving more attention, is not among those who turn their backs? The commentators write that, God forbid, a moral shortcoming of the Holy Prophet (saw) is mentioned, and for this reason God as it were scolded him: what is this you have done? But the fact is that this is not correct. The concept of morals changes with the standard. The higher the standard of morals, the more the definition of shortcoming changes. And something that by ordinary worldly standards is a very high morality, if it appears in an exalted being, does not appear, relatively speaking, as [perfect] morality. Allah wants to see the morals of the Holy Prophet (saw) at such a high standard that is absolute, that rises above these relativities, and on which relativity can cast no reflection in any situation. This incident in itself is not an incident of bad character at all. I will now tell you what happened; by no standard of the world can you call it bad character. The Holy Prophet (saw) was busy with tabligh. His wish was that the man who was the chief of a people, with a tribe behind him, who had come, would listen attentively and find guidance; a whole people would follow him. The chief of a people had come. At that time a blind man came who did not know what was going on, and he began to disturb the Holy Prophet (saw) again and again. Now, under ordinary circumstances, had he even gently told him verbally, 'don't do that', he might perhaps have been hurt or perhaps not; but if one speaks with care, it cannot be called bad character. But the Holy Prophet (saw) did not utter a single word and only very slightly showed on his face that he was feeling burdened by this. One who could see [would have] seen that expression, and the blind man was not hurt. The commentators narrate this with such exaggeration that it seems, God forbid, the Holy Prophet (saw) committed an act of bad character. That is completely wrong. By no worldly standard, indeed even by the highest human standard, is there any bad character in it. And the purpose was [different]: on this Allah told him: you are so dear to Me that the standard I want to see in you, I want to see even higher. And make this your aim from now on: if someone is eager, pay more attention to him; if someone is not eager, he is comparatively less deserving of attention. This is a lesson that was given, and through this incident the Holy Prophet (saw) was made aware that guidance is found by the one who desires guidance, and the one who flees from guidance—you wish that he find guidance, and having this wish is not bad character, but Allah sees into hearts—He tells you that those who flee do not find, and those who desire find more, so pay more attention to them. In this incident I see no bad character at all, God forbid, with any aspect of reprimand. Rather, in a very subtle manner the beautiful character of the Holy Prophet was also expressed, and to take him to even higher stations God gave him a piece of advice to which people usually pay no attention.