3. [First an apology] We are often asked by atheists: if one looks at the history of mankind, the most killings in human history have taken place in the name of religion, and as much human blood as has been shed in the name of religion has not been shed in any other way, because when killing someone in religion the killer does not consider himself a killer; he has a justification for his killing. Yet religion came in world history in order to promote humanity and give peace; instead, history is witness, the pages of history testify, that religion brought destruction to people.
Urdu question-and-answer session, 1 March 1984
AI-translated (from Urdu)
Question: [First an apology] We are often asked by atheists: if one looks at the history of mankind, the most killings in human history have taken place in the name of religion, and as much human blood as has been shed in the name of religion has not been shed in any other way, because when killing someone in religion the killer does not consider himself a killer; he has a justification for his killing. Yet religion came in world history in order to promote humanity and give peace; instead, history is witness, the pages of history testify, that religion brought destruction to people.
I feel that history does not bear witness to this at all. The history I have studied does not testify to this; it presents an entirely opposite picture. The slaughter and plunder carried out by Hannibal, by Alexander the Great, by Hulagu Khan, or by Genghis, or by Timur, or by the Western nations in the First World War or the Second World War—where was religion in that? And each one of these incidents of slaughter is so dreadful that the evidence of slaughter found in all the religions of the world is less than them. So what history does not testify to at all, what answer should I give to it? Secondly, even in what history does testify to there is a distortion of vision. The historian looks without making a distinction and attributes it to religion. Religion has two eras: first, when it appeared, and second, when it became corrupted. It is an accepted fact that religion was close to its sources and also went far from its sources. The history of every religion, without exception, is that when it was close to its sources, people persecuted its followers; and when it moved away from its sources, then whatever they did was not religion at all; it is a form of worldliness. The real point is that when man moves away from religion he becomes a wrongdoer, and when he becomes a wrongdoer, then whether he finds a political pretext, or a religious one, or some other, he is bound to commit wrong. The wrongs have occurred as a result of distance from religious values, even if they occurred in the name of religion; because when religious values were established, religion never committed wrong. This is such an accepted, agreed testimony of history that no historian can reject it.