4. (The question is not contained in the recording. From the answer it appears it concerned how, in a society lacking the example of the Holy Prophet (saw) and dominated by fear, one can spread the truth and bring about reform.)

Urdu question-and-answer session, 1 March 1984

AI-translated (from Urdu)

Question: (The question is not contained in the recording. From the answer it appears it concerned how, in a society lacking the example of the Holy Prophet (saw) and dominated by fear, one can spread the truth and bring about reform.)

[The answer begins mid-sentence:] ... cannot be lifted. And that example is to raise the voice of truth, whatever befalls one. That example is no longer present among us. When capital is lacking, how are you to invest? That is the real problem that has arisen. In our society the majority are decent people, the majority are people who have love and esteem for decency in their hearts, and the majority are also cowards. Decency and cowardice have entered into such a marriage that this union cannot be broken. And those who are far from the Prophet's example are bolder. This is called brazenness, and it is not a good quality. They are brazen in their words and loud, and one lacks the courage to answer them. And if someone does find the courage, those people do not leave him alone in the least. Therefore fear is multiplying; the experiences that occur keep multiplying it. So this is such a dilemma that there is now no remedy but to begin the good admonition that the Holy Qur’an mentions, and to try, man to man, to widen the circle of the example of Muhammad Mustafa (saw). The Holy Qur’an has already answered your question – when a disease reaches that stage. It says: [recitation not captured]. The word patience (sabr) has opened up this subject: the section of society that has the strength to strive against evils has become so limited that injustice will be done to them too, and without patience there is no way out. The meaning is this: Allah the Exalted says, We call to witness that age which as a whole will be heading into loss; when man, despite his numbers, his knowledge and his outward superiority, will in the ultimate analysis, in the final bargain, be at a loss. The loss will become so widespread that one could say the whole of mankind is in loss. Allah says: No, not all men, there are exceptions – “except those who believe and do good works.” The exception is that some believe and do good works, but do not keep good works to themselves; they do not think: We have to say our prayers, that is enough, what need do we have of any jihad? Only then will their good works bear fruit – this is what the next part of the verse states: “and exhort one another to truth,” they keep on exhorting to the truth. In “bil-Haqq” there are two meanings, one as a means ... both are included: speak the truth and speak it in a truthful manner. That is, to bring in the truth one must not adopt an illegitimate method. One must not say: Unless we raise the stick you will not come to the truth, so we will bring you to the truth by force. That is not “bil-Haqq,” because “bil-Haqq” means: speak the truth and speak it in a truthful way. The end does not justify your wrong means – that is the meaning. And the next part: When you do this, Allah says, I know that this is a very difficult path; outwardly it appears very weak – that the truth should be spoken, and spoken in a truthful way; who will accept it? Therefore patience is necessary. Sabr has several meanings. One of them is that in response you will be made to suffer; and if you have risen with the resolve of admonishing, then be ready to bear suffering, otherwise your claim is imaginary. Here too the Prophet's example is the reference for us: from the very first day he was the picture of “exhorting one another to truth and exhorting one another to patience.” The next meaning of “bis-Sabr” is that one should also urge patience – not only be patient oneself but also urge others to be patient, because until others too become messengers and helpers this system cannot spread. Work with patience and urge patience. And another meaning of sabr, which the Holy Prophet Muhammad Mustafa (saw) stated, is: true patience is that whatever virtue you take hold of, you hold on to it and do not let it go again. Temporary virtues are not patience; the virtues that remain and become part of one's being are called sabr. So it will also mean: when you admonish to good things, the opponents will strive against you so much that they will try to uproot you from your virtues; instead of accepting your truth, they will try to destroy the goodness within you. And this happens, for example: a man says, be patient and speak good things; in return he is showered with abuse. For a while he says, very well. Then he says, all right, if you talk like that, I will talk to you the same way. There the hem of patience slipped from his hand, and the virtue he was teaching vanished from within him. Sometimes the one who tries to uproot is himself uprooted, if the other is stronger. Keeping this reality in view, the Holy Qur’an has given a perfect admonition: hold fast to virtues with patience and do not let them slip from your hands, lest while correcting others you yourselves are uprooted. These are the matters of a losing age, which is what our age is now. Therefore this is the only way, and impatience has no way at all. The concept of a shortcut to reform is utterly ignorant, and sabr negates it: if you claim to be reformers, it will come about through the path of patience; there is no short cut to reformation. If this is true, then the example of the Holy Prophet (saw) should confirm it – and it confirms exactly this. He (saw) never used a shortcut in any reform; he continued on the path of patience, and as a result a revolution began. The Holy Qur’an mentions this revolution in another place: “Repel with that which is best.” That is, why is patience needed in this jihad, what will happen? He says: when they oppose you, when you give good admonitions – “repel with that which is best” – remember never to choose an evil weapon in response. If they do evil, present goodness in response to every evil. After this He says: “And lo, he between whom and you there was enmity will become as though he were a warm friend.” If you walk this path you will be turning enmities into love, not turning love into enmity, and day by day some enemy will begin to love you. This is the path of true reform – not that even those who were friends before turn away repelled. This event, this miracle, is seen in the life of the Holy Prophet (saw) from the first day to the last. A Companion bears witness to precisely this. After the demise of the Holy Prophet (saw) someone asked him: Tell us, what did the Holy Prophet look like? – this was an expression of love among people; in gatherings they would ask those who had seen him themselves: tell us what you saw. He began to weep, so much that he sobbed. When he fell silent, the questioner said: I did not ask anything that should hurt you, what is the matter? He said: No, you do not know why I wept. Only two phases have come in my life. In one, my hatred of Hazrat Muhammad Mustafa (saw) was so intense that out of hatred I would not look at that face. Then there was such a turnaround that out of overflowing love my eyes could not be raised. By God, if anyone asks me today what that face was like, I cannot tell. He is a Companion who spent many years in his company. This is what is meant by: “He between whom and you there was enmity will become as though he were a warm friend.” When with patience you keep meeting evils with goodness, inevitably that revolution will come which is the revolution of Muhammad Mustafa: that you will turn every hatred into love. What a magnificent outcome! But along with it He gave a warning: “And none is granted it except those who are patient.” This is not the path for the impatient at all. If you have no patience, then do not choose this path; you have other paths. If reform could come by a shortcut or by force, what would this patience mean – patience has been included everywhere. “And none is granted it except those who are patient” – it will be granted only to those who possess the quality of patience within them. “And none is granted it except one who has a great share (hazzin azim).” And this great blessing belongs to that being who was given the great share, namely Hazrat Muhammad Mustafa (saw). Hazz-e-Azim means the greatest share; the one who received the greatest share of the attributes of Allah is Hazrat Muhammad Mustafa (saw). So He made the matter brief: this long subject of what patience is and what it demands – these are long matters, We put it briefly: look at Muhammad Mustafa (saw) and you will make no mistake. Whatever he did in a situation, keep doing that, and that is the clear path. That is the path of patience – a path on which beside him you do not see people throwing stones from their laps. You do not see him boycotting towns, and you do not see him urging the Companions: go after so-and-so, drive them before you. Something else is seen: the people are doing this. When the Meccans did it, he began going to other settlements. When other settlements did it, he went to Ta’if. And in Ta’if we see the scene that “dhu hazzin azim” depicts – the picture of the Sunnah is the picture of the one with the great share. The picture is: he went to Ta’if, and its chiefs said: you come forcibly into our town and preach to us; your punishment is that you be sent off in such a way that boys pelt you with stones and ruffians hurl abuse at you as well. They organised it, and the Holy Prophet's (saw) departure from that town was such that stones were continuously rained on him and ruffians hurled abuse. The narration says that his own blood was flowing and filled his shoes, and because of the slipperiness even walking became difficult for him. Yet, like a mountain of dignity, he departed with great patience and steadfastness and kept walking until, at someone's garden, he sat down at its edge in its shade. At that time, the narration says, when the wounds were fresh and the pain was beyond measure, God sent angels, and the angels gave the message: Allah is so angry at the conduct of this town that if you wish it today, God will destroy them. Some narrations say these angels had control over two mountains – the system that controls the hidden powers of God is called the angels of Allah. They said: we will bring these mountains together and the trace of this town will be wiped out. The answer the Holy Prophet (saw) gave is astonishing. This is called patience: be patient when the pain is fresh; and when evil has just been shown, then show goodness – this is called showing goodness and changing evil with goodness. He made a plea, and his plea was most heartfelt, and said: O Allah, I have not come to destroy, give them guidance. And that town found guidance. So it is not human effort alone that plays a part. The one with the great share has taught us that when, after this, prayers rise from wounded hearts, then the ordinary law of the world no longer applies alone; a higher law takes over, then the divine angels begin to bring about changes, and miraculous events occur. But these miracles are shown to the one with the great share. A man who does nothing for the sake of God, who is content with the world and considers it sufficient, will not be shown them. So all of Ta’if then turned into devoted lovers – history bears this out. Do this work; it is hard, but if you have patience, do it. It is a very long path.

10 of 10 left today