5. You have shown one aspect, namely that it contains all love, forgiveness and patience ... But can I also include within the theme of “Repel with that which is best” the other aspect, in which in all the battles – the Battle of Badr, the Battle of Uhud – action was taken against the opponents, and the places in the Holy Qur’an dealing with opponents and enemies?

Urdu question-and-answer session, 1 March 1984

AI-translated (from Urdu), recording partly hard to hear, some parts rendered by sense

Question: You have shown one aspect, namely that it contains all love, forgiveness and patience ... But can I also include within the theme of “Repel with that which is best” the other aspect, in which in all the battles – the Battle of Badr, the Battle of Uhud – action was taken against the opponents, and the places in the Holy Qur’an dealing with opponents and enemies?

You can include all of them, because when I said that he (saw) is a manifestation of the attributes of Allah, I stressed one point: that he is a balanced manifestation and perfect balance is found in him. If Allah were only Rahman (the Gracious), then from such a servant there should never, on any occasion, be any expression of anger, of resistance or of punishment. And if God is something else besides Rahman, it would be a very incomplete being, a manifestation of God in which the other attributes do not appear. Allah is also the Avenger, and in Allah's retribution there is no emotional anger; rather it is a calculated system of punishment which the Holy Qur’an itself explains, and the Holy Prophet (saw) never stepped outside the bounds of this system of punishment. What is that system? Allah says: “But whoever forgives and thereby reforms, his reward is with Allah.” Forgiveness is a very good thing, but with one condition: you are permitted to forgive only if your forgiveness brings reform; then your reward is with Allah. He has made forgiveness conditional on reform. If forgiveness is a name for cowardice, if forgiveness emboldens crime, then – since it is conditional – you are not permitted to forgive at all. Then the first part of the verse comes into operation: as much wrong as has been done to you, that much retribution you are permitted, no more. The entire life of the Holy Prophet Muhammad Mustafa (saw) remained within this circle; not once did he transgress these limits. And as the Holy Qur’an says, “My mercy encompasses all things” – even in those wars, even at the time of those battles, his mercy remained predominant. For example, you mentioned the Battle of Badr. In the Battle of Badr the number of his Companions was three hundred and thirteen, among them crippled and lame; some had broken swords, and there were wooden swords too. Their clothing was so poor that when, after the martyrdom of some, they tried to cover them in their own clothes, covering them above left them bare below, and covering them below left them bare above. In this state of poverty they faced a thousand of the young warriors of Arabia, of the highest calibre, and with them were women reciting war poetry, camel riders and horsemen. In such a situation the Holy Prophet (saw) gained an advantage, namely that he took control of the mouth of the spring where water was found. No general in the world could even conceive, in such a state of weakness, of [allowing] the enemy ... at that spring. When the enemy felt that they would die of thirst because the Muslims had taken the spring, they sent men, some as envoys. The Companions ran to stop them. The Prophet (saw) said: No, they will not be kept from the water; give them the right to drink water, and then they may fight however they will. This is what is called “My mercy encompasses all things”: in the person of the Holy Prophet (saw), even at the time of retribution, mercy was manifest. This is a very long subject, but if you go into detail you will find no contradiction between the person of the Holy Prophet (saw) and the attributes of God.

10 of 10 left today