6. [Question heavily garbled:] What existed before ... then Moses/Jesus (as) came ... then Hazrat Muhammad (saw) came ... What does the perfection (of religion) mean, or how is the difference between the earlier teachings and the teaching of Islam to be explained?
Urdu question-and-answer session, 1 March 1984
AI-translated (from Urdu)
Question: [Question heavily garbled:] What existed before ... then Moses/Jesus (as) came ... then Hazrat Muhammad (saw) came ... What does the perfection (of religion) mean, or how is the difference between the earlier teachings and the teaching of Islam to be explained?
I think we will leave it at these two questions – one from you and one from them. This question is very important for those who do Tabligh among other nations. One method of Tabligh is to attack the other's religion like this: our religion is perfect and yours is imperfect and full of defects, so leave that religion and come over here. This attack is extremely unwise and imprudent, because the next attack then falls on God Himself: why did Allah give an imperfect teaching to the earlier people, a teaching full of defects? How did defects emerge from a perfect Being? And the philosophers then do not let you go. It is an extremely imprudent method to shield oneself from one side of the attack and expose one's back on the other side. Therefore an answer is needed that is based on facts and that, while warding off the attack on Islam, does not invite an attack on God. When I spoke abroad – at various times I have lived in Europe and also travelled there – my method was, and this is also my belief, that Allah is a limitless Being and His perfection is measured with reference to man. It is shirk to say that God has given us everything with His full perfection. God gave man, according to his developed capacities, the degree of perfection that man deserved. This is the unchangeable truth, in which you will see no change and against which no objection can ever be raised. So I used to tell the Jews and also the Christians: your religion was so perfect for its time that no human could change it and make it better. For example, when it was revealed to the Jews that you must take retribution, and must certainly take it, the time was such, nationally, that they had been so ground down under the oppressions of Pharaoh that their human character had been destroyed. In the name of forgiveness they displayed their cowardice; they had no strength to resist. Had such a degraded nation been told, forgive if you wish, take revenge if you wish, they would have forgiven; the question of retribution would not have arisen at all. And this decision of God was proven one hundred percent by their later conduct, because when the time of jihad came, they said: “Go you and your Lord and fight, we will sit here.” – Moses, you and your God go and fight, we will sit here. That character could not be reformed by that teaching. So God made them follow that teaching for a long period, until the pendulum swung to the other extreme – a pendulum does not stop in the middle; it went to the other side, and they became so cruel that they were prepared to commit the most horrific injustice against the most innocent person in the world of their time. When Hazrat Jesus (as) came, the Holy Qur’an describes in many places the state of their hardness of heart, and there are very cruel pictures of how they committed injustices and were hard-hearted. Had they been told, you may forgive and you may also take retribution, they would never have forgiven; they would only have taken revenge. In this context, at this historical juncture, only that teaching can be called perfect which, keeping human nature in view, gives a decision suitable for its reform, and that decision is temporary, not forever. So Jesus too was a messenger for his time, and Moses too was a messenger for his time. Jesus (as) received the teaching: now teach them that you are not to take retribution at all; if someone strikes you on one cheek, turn the other. And they were compelled to pass through this state, until man, passing through different swings of the pendulum, learns lessons; through various experiences he has become mature, and after becoming mature he should receive a mature teaching that is perfect with reference to him. When we say “most perfect,” it means that at the level of consciousness man has reached with his capacities, God manifested Himself most perfectly in that respect. Yet God will still not be limited; man's degree of capacity will decide what he receives. When I explained this, the Jews were pleased and the Christians were pleased that this man had not been unjust to us; he is stating the exact truth. And if at the outset you give the impression that you are unjust, who will listen to you? Then they are ready to hear the next step, that is, they are ready to see the beauty of the Holy Prophet (saw). I would tell them: now I will explain the teaching of the Holy Qur’an. The Holy Qur’an says that if wrong is done to someone, he has the right to take retribution, but only as much retribution as the wrong done to him, and he should not add to it. And if he forgives – on the condition that his forgiveness results in reform of the situation and does not embolden crime – then such a person will receive his reward from his Lord. I said: this is the teaching of which we say it is the manifestation of “This day have I perfected your religion for you.” So you see, if we first present the argument that is usually presented, they would then object: now thirteen hundred, fourteen hundred years have passed over this too, so it too should change. Then I would tell them: the fact is, now it has become timeless. Change it now and show me; let your great intellectuals make some improvement in it, then I will accept that yes, it too should change. Speak with argument. To this day I have not received an answer; you too can try it. So the perfection of religion means that the teaching has been made so perfect that the changing circumstances of man cannot lay hands on it. And not only this – in other subjects too, when you reflect on the teachings of religions, it is a most magnificent subject, but not such that it could be explained in detail in this small gathering. I have just given you one example.