6. Why is giving charity in the name of deceased person encouraged while reciting the Holy Qur’an for their sake is not?

Question-and-answer session, 9 July 1984

Automatic transcript of the audio recording, checked against the recording and corrected with AI. Please check the wording in the recording.

Question: Why is giving charity in the name of deceased person encouraged while reciting the Holy Qur’an for their sake is not?

The fact is that there are two types of acts of goodness. One type relates to the relationship of man with Allah and his obligations to his Lord, his Creator, that is Allah. And the other division pertains to man's responsibilities to his human fellow beings and to other beings other than Allah.

So in the first instance, in the first category, that responsibility can be discharged only by the person himself, because it has direct bearing on the development of his soul, and if he dies, then anybody else's performance of that duty does not add to anything of Allah's pleasure and does not serve any purpose. It's meaningless.

But those acts which pertain to the service to mankind or other creation, if they are performed, or even if they are performed after the death of a person, they don't lose meaning. They still are meaningful and they serve a purpose, and a good purpose for that matter. So they are not, neither, not only they are not forbidden, they are encouraged.

So this is why we don't find a single instance in traditions of the Holy Prophet, peace be upon him, where he ever asked or admonished anyone to start saying Holy Qur’an, reciting Holy Qur’an or saying prayers for the sake of the dead people, his dead relatives or friends. But this is on record, that more than once,

for example, once a companion of Hazrat Muhammad Mustafa (saw) came to him and said, "My mother was very generous and very service-minded. She used to spend on the poor. Now that is, that she is dead, I want to continue to do that service to mankind on her behalf. Will that be all right?"

Aan-Hazrat (saw) said, "Yes, do it. And Allah conveys certain acts of people here to the souls of those who have passed away."

So there are so many other references to the same subject in various ways. So that is established. And the reason is because Allah's creation will get benefit out of that. But that is a meaningless thing. The person who was in fact to draw the benefit is no longer there. So the direction of benefit is completely different.

In the first instance, the benefit was to flow from Allah to that person, person, who was to be the performer of a good deed, and to him alone. In the second instance, the benefit flows not from Allah directly, but from one of His servants to the rest of His servants. So the recipients of benefits are there all right.

10 of 10 left today