1. What is meaning of the verses in the Holy Qur’an 41 : 50, 52 — one verse says that men turn aside naimath and pray only in despair and while another says they give up praying when in despair?
Question-and-answer session, 12 July 1984
Automatic transcript of the audio recording, checked against the recording and corrected with AI. Please check the wording in the recording.
Question: What is meaning of the verses in the Holy Qur’an 41:50, 52 — one verse says that men turn aside Ni'mat and pray only in despair, while another says they give up praying when in despair?
No, here *Ni'mat* is quite a different thing from what you are conceiving it to be. Here *Ni'mat* is a term of the Holy Qur’an which means *Nabuwwat*, and *In'am* is *Nabuwwat*. That is the culmination of *In'am*. The last stage of *Ni'mat*, according to the Holy Qur’an, is *Nabuwwat*. So whenever it says *Itmam-e-Ni'mat*, it always means *Nabuwwat*, nothing else. So, here by *Ni'mat*, it is *Nabuwwat* which is meant.
Allah says that whenever We reveal prophethood, or We send prophets—we can say it in other words—then the man turns away and does not listen to them. But when he stands in his own needs, then he returns to Allah and starts praying whenever he is in difficulty. Now this is the true meaning of this verse.
In another place, this is also repeated—the first part—and the second part is different: *Wa idha an'amna 'alal-insani a'rada wa na'a bi-janibih, wa idha massahush-sharru kana ya'oosa*. So it is *Nabuwwat* what is meant here.
Sir, and again, in the first verse, the second part, he despairs, giving up all hopes. And in the second verse says, but when evil touches him, he starts offering long prayers.
There is no, in fact, contradiction. What happens is that from situation to situation, the behavior of man is different.
Now, number one, even if you are despaired, even at the point of extreme despair, you may pray to God. And it so happens, while the boat is sinking, and you have lost all hope, you don't have at all any hope at all, yet to turn to God is so natural that it comes to man at times of peril. Even the atheists begin to pray to God. While they are despaired of—I mean, worldly speaking, they are despaired totally and completely, and they don't believe in God either—yet they pray because it is in man to find out some ways, means of escape, some props to help him at the time of difficulty. This is quite natural to man. So, prayer and extreme despondency and hopelessness and despair, they are not contradictory things, in the first place.
In the second place, two different types of men or people could have been described in these verses. They are pious people, God-fearing, those who believe in Allah.
They may offer prayer, or also another type of people may offer prayer when they reject the office of prophethood, and then, when calamity takes them over, that is the time for them. Among men there are some who turn to Allah and say, "Forgive us and save us, and now we will believe."
This phenomenon has been very clearly demonstrated in the Holy Qur’an in the case of Pharaoh's reaction to Hazrat Moses and his people's reaction. When he warned them of calamities from Allah, sign after sign of punishment came as he had predicted, and previously they were completely turning deaf ears to him. But the Holy Qur’an tells us that when they were overtaken by punishment, then they turned in all humility to Moses and asked him to pray to Allah. Despite—why? Because they had despaired. So prayer is sometimes the natural result of despair; it is not contradictory.
And they repeatedly did it. One sign after another, the Holy Qur’an tells us, they went on changing their stance and turning to Musa in all humility and saying, "Now pray for us, and once this crisis is over, then we will believe." And that habit of Pharaoh persisted so much that at the death moments, the moments of death, he did exactly the same thing. But then Allah turned all the tables against him. He said, "Okay, I'll save you, because all the time you're after your body, not after your soul. Had you been after your soul—I mean you had thought of your soul—then you should have repented after the first sign, or second, or third. But nine signs have passed by and you are not careful, you are not mindful of your soul at all. So that means you are after your body alone. So We'll save your body."
So that was an irony of fate so beautifully turned against Moses, against Pharaoh that, in the one instance, it demonstrated the fact that that habit of man does not change. It is so deeply born in him, it is innate in his nature, that right from the start till the end he goes on repeating the same thing all over, over and over again. And secondly, that Allah knew that ultimately he will be caught and fixed. So He was not befooled when He left them alone; He knew ultimately they would come to Him and He would teach them a lesson.
Now you understand this? There's no contradiction here. Yes.