8. Can a parallel between drawn between the dispersion of the Jews from Israel and the dispersion of the Arabs from Palestine?
Question-and-answer session, 12 July 1984
Automatic transcript of the audio recording, checked against the recording and corrected with AI. Please check the wording in the recording.
Question: Can a parallel be drawn between the dispersion of the Jews from Israel and the dispersion of the Arabs from Palestine?
These are just, as they call it, *dhawqī*, you know. Some people can think, and you cannot say you are totally wrong, because anything which has not been defined finally and clearly, it is left open to those who interpret these things. And the principle laid down by the Holy Qur’an in such situations is that it is for those alone who are given light from Allah to interpret such things clearly and correctly.
And again, in another place, the Holy Qur’an tells us: *Lā yamassuhū illal-muṭahharūn*. Here again, *ṭāhir* is not used, the word *ṭāhir*; *muṭahhar* is used, which means the one who is purified by Allah, by someone else—not himself, not a purifier of himself or not a pure person alone, but someone who has been purified. Like al-Mahdi, this is, what you call, *ism-e-maf‘ūl*. What is the translation of *ism-e-maf‘ūl* in English? Sheikh Sahib? Any grammarian? No, no, *ism-e-maf‘ūl*. Anyway, let us forget it for the time being. I have explained the meaning anyway.
So, it is used passively here. *Muṭahhar* is used passively. So, that shows that if those—for example, *ma‘mūrīn* or their Caliphs, or people, the ulema of a community which are God-fearing and who are in communion with Allah—when they interpret such verses under the guidance of Allah, then the meaning can be acceptable to all, should be acceptable to all. Otherwise, it is just an individual game. You can try your hand at it, and you may not be right, and you may be true either, and I as well.