3. If somebody is murdered, what are the Islamic teachings concerning forgiveness?

Question-and-answer session, 25 July 1984

Automatic transcript of the audio recording, checked against the recording and corrected with AI. Please check the wording in the recording.

Question: If somebody is murdered, what are the Islamic teachings concerning forgiveness?

The question is that if somebody is murdered, what is the Islamic teachings about it in reference to the possibility of forgiveness? If the questioner has asked, if the near relatives do not agree to forgiveness, then what is the teaching in the Holy Qur’an about it?

The Holy Qur’an does not give this the right to forgive a murderer to the state, but it gives that right to those who have been wronged at his hands. The one person who is murdered, he is no longer here, he doesn't belong to this earth, but the closest of relatives who would have inherited him, they have the right to decide if the murderer is to be forgiven or not.

In case of forgiveness, some—what is it called? Fidyah ke... Ransom money? Nahin, ransom money to aur cheez hoti hai... Blood money. Blood money. Ransom money is different, that is for the prisoners. Blood money. Blood money is agreed upon and then it's permitted.

Why did this question come to your mind?

Huzoor, mera sawal abhi complete...

Haan, so make it complete, please.

Agar lawahiqeen maaf na karna chahein, main dil se maaf nahi karna chahta, aur meri rasai qanoon tak bhi nahi hai—

Qanoon tak?

Uss surat mein, ya insaaf tak meri rasai nahi hai.

Toh phir toh question hi koi nahi hai. Uss surat mein badla... You can't take law into your own hands, if that is what you mean. You can't.

Lekin Qur’an-e-Karim mein toh aaya hai ke Allah Ta'ala momin par farz karta hai ke woh badla le.

Nahin, yeh nahin kahin bhi. Qur’an-e-Karim jahan aap refer kar rahe hain, hargiz wahan yeh nahi likha. Mukhtalif situations mein yeh subject discuss hua hai, baaz jagah qisas hai. Qisas aur cheez hai. It is not an individual murder at all.

At times they are nations which are at war with each other, or even if not at war, they have certain agreements and somebody from one nation kills another person, and there is an agreement that in such case the offender nation would be responsible and will have to produce either the murderer or the blood money for that. That is called qisas.

So, Allah Ta'ala says that it is a must for momineen, that in this case, that you must take qisas:

وَلَكُمْ فِي الْقِصَاصِ حَيَاةٌ يَا أُولِي الْأَلْبَابِ

There is life for you, that is the national life. There you do not forgive because then it will teach irresponsibility to other nations. They must be held responsible for such crimes of transgression against their border nations.

So it does not apply to the individual murder at all. It is not mentioned.

Huzoor, iska matlab yeh hua ke you are forced to forgive.

The Holy Qur’an says it The Holy Qur’an says it in so many words. But the word forgiveness does not apply to the situation which you have in mind. So you are not forced to forgive at all. You are helpless.

Iss surat mein helpless.

Helpless man can't do a thing. What does helplessness mean? You can't do a thing. Even The Holy Qur’an also presents another picture of helplessness. The Holy Qur’an tells us that if a fly takes away something from your food or from your body or something, just a little bit, tiny little bit, you are so helpless you can't take it back. So what could you do there to get that back from the fly?

The only thing is that you should pray to Allah and ask Him for vengeance or retribution, if you are in such a mood as you cannot forgive and you cannot rest in peace. This is what you mean. Still, you are not permitted to take the law in your hand.

And there are there are also possibilities that somebody, even if he wanted to, he could not take the law in his own hands. There are despots, nations, there are despot kings and usurpers of power who are cruel in wide scale, and sometimes they commit murders in large numbers, sometimes they imprison people in large numbers, and the people of that country live in a stage of agony and they can't do a thing. So what would you suggest they should do?

The point is, there are situations where somebody is found to be helpless, and if he believes in God, the only recourse open to him is to seek refuge in prayer.

Jahan tak huzoor yeh law haath mein lene ka sawal hai, yeh to uss waqt tak hai jab law prevail kar raha ho. Agar law prevail hi nahi kar raha...

Toh phir why then you why do you ask question about legality of the thing when there is no law? You are asking me a question about the legality of a situation. Where there is no law, there is no legality to be asked about.

Wohi mera maqsad tha ke insaaf tak rasai na ho...

When you say that there is no law, then why are you bothering about the legal aspects of a situation where there is no law?

By no law I mean that practically it's not prevailed.

Haan, so practically So by no legality I mean practically no legality.

Lekin mera zehen iss sawal ki taraf usi aayat ke parhne par gaya tha ke insaan badla khud le sakta hai, lekin woh Huzoor ne...

Nahin nahin, haan it's just so. That's also the nation which decides, not an individual. There, that is a national issue.

Where individual murders are mentioned, individual transgression is mentioned, the Holy Qur’an says it in so many words, and this verse is applicable to all such situations:

وَمَنْ عَفَا وَأَصْلَحَ فَأَجْرُهُ عَلَى اللَّهِ

That if somebody decides to forgive, provided that his forgiveness would not encourage evil, but would cause reformation, in that case his reward will be with his Lord Allah.

So, Islam promotes forgiveness everywhere, except in certain situations, where some of them are mentioned in this verse itself. If you tend to forgive while you know that your forgiveness is going to cause greater trouble, and the culprit will be encouraged rather than discouraged by the act of forgiveness, then Allah does not permit you to forgive.

There is a condition: man ‘afa wa-aslaha—it's bracketed. If somebody forgives, causing thereby to be a reformation in the ways of the guilty, that is the meaning, then Allah would be very happy with you and would reward you. Otherwise you just take your revenge, and just that much as you have been wronged before.

10 of 10 left today