2. Is it accurate to make the argument that God must exist because there has to be something that preceded us?

Question-and-answer session, 30 July 1984

Automatic transcript of the audio recording, checked against the recording and corrected with AI. Please check the wording in the recording.

Question: Is it accurate to make the argument that God must exist because there has to be something that preceded us?

When you say that there has to be a God because there should be some something before you, I told this boy who faced opposition from his school children on this issue, that this attitude is wrong. There is no proof. Because if everything has to be preceded by something else, then God has to be preceded by something else too. So this has never been our argument, the true argument, I mean.

The most important thing is to start with the concept of eternity. Eternity is something which can never be gainsaid in any way. It is the most positive thing that one finds: eternity. You can't run away from it. So there has to be eternity. That is our common platform on which we start. And however strange eternity may appear to us, yet it is a proven fact. You can't conceive of a situation without eternity in both directions, in the past as well as in future.

Now there are two possibilities. Either this universe which we find today, and this life and everything, is eternal, or there is some other being eternal. If this is considered eternal, then consciousness is not eternal, because it is evolved out of death. You follow this point?

Now the issue would be now, because eternity has to be there, now there are two possibilities: either the inanimate was eternal, or a conscious being was eternal. And on either of the two you can't have any logical objection. You escape from one, you have to fall into the lap of the other, and both are equal possibilities. If inanimate thing can be eternal, an animate and conscious being could also be eternal. Why not? They're equally situated and equally possible.

But if we observe in this universe that there is a hand of consciousness playing upon it, then we can positively prove that this is not eternal, the conscious being was eternal. The influence of a conscious being, if it is observed on the universe which we find, then it is proved that the conscious being has to precede the unconscious. And because eternity has to be accepted in any way, the question who produced that conscious being would not arise at all. Only there are two possibilities: either this is eternal or that is eternal.

So always start your journey from eternity and present a position, a situation to your adversary that there is only two choices: either a conscious being is eternal or an unconscious world is eternal. And on neither of the two you can object, because what is there is obvious, it has to be there, but the issue is which is possibly eternal.

Now when we look at the things which we observe, we see evolution. And it was there that I mentioned DNA and RNA, exactly. You see evolution, and we find through observation of evolution that it is a guided evolution. It is not an unguided evolution which could occur through chance. So if you can prove this point, that the evolution in itself is not a blind evolution, which could occur in any direction and it so happened that it took this direction in which we find ourselves today, then guided evolution means a conscious being before it. Otherwise it could not be guided—a being outside.

So to prove this point, I started with RNA, DNA. But even otherwise, this can be proved differently. This is one scientific accepted principle, that for something to be born, there has to be the fundamental requirements of that thing already in existence. So this is an accepted principle of science, that life cannot be born out of death. There has to be a seed of life.

So how this process ultimately began, they are even now puzzled. They try to justify their theories, but once the principle is accepted that life cannot be born out of death, they find themselves in very difficult mess when they reach the early stages of life and try to explain how it evolved. But even there, I quoted that RNA and DNA, their existence, proves that all their efforts will always fail to justify the appearance of life from death automatically. This is the issue.

So because I told you, told the boy that if you study the internal structure of RNA and DNA. Now DNA is the basic brick of life. The very earliest form of life has the basic unit which is called DNA. DNA means that unit of life which has highly codified information.

It's a sort of minutest possible computer in which everything is codified: how the life should behave, how it should generate, how it should survive, how it should react under in pressures of adversity, how it should flourish at the time of—you know, this situations which are helpful—and abundance, in the time of abundance, etc. So everything, every situation is encoded in that basic cell of life, which is called the first brick of life.

For one single cell, DNA is enough, because it is DNA or the cell, one and the same thing. But if there is a colony of various cells and a new animal is evolved out of the DNA, collection of DNAs, then RNA is also essential, because RNA is the unit of life which carries messages from DNA to another DNA. It decodifies a message in the DNA and gives it a different chemical shape, then reaches another point where it is destined to reach, and then in the same codification of the first DNA, it gives that message to the other DNA. This messenger system is called RNA.

Now these two basic fundamental units of life are the most preliminary ones. Between them and sheer death, there is very little time, no distance in fact. How they evolved, these most highly complicated things? And what are the innumerable stages between their existence and death? This is a question which no scientist can answer, because he can't accept the existence of God, talking of science, and he can't solve this question anyway. So here they have to become dumb.

But some scientists have taken up the cudgel in favor of religion on this point, and now more and more are joining their line and file. They openly challenge now the possibility of blind—not only evolution, but the blind creation of life from death, automatic, spontaneous creation of life from death. Well, I shouldn't say spontaneous, because much larger time is involved, but between the first death, the first shape of death and the first shape of life, there has to be a barrier. Wherever that barrier is placed, the difference between this stage and that stage is so big that it cannot be traversed through a huge jump which is apparently impossible,

unless somebody picked it up from here and put it there. That means a foreign, conscious influence.

So some scientists who have started analyzing this situation have worked out mathematically the impossibility of such a happening. They said this is an impossible supposition; it could not have occurred. So I quoted one—I think it was Hoyle, Hoyle and Singer. They have written a book, yes. Mr. Hoyle and Singer is an American scientist. He has written a book on this subject, although his theories are unacceptable, because after rejecting this, he says life must have come from another planet. And he has a wrong theory, and then he goes astray completely. So he gives chance to the other scientists to attack him on this theory. But none has attacked his mathematics. And it is the mathematics to which I am pointing out; this is more important to us, not his theory.

The mathematics tells us that for the DNA to come into creation, there has to be a chain of innumerable chances, because it is so perfectly ordered organization. First of all, enzymes are created, they are put in definite order, and a chain is created. For the creation of each enzyme, there has to be a chain of other possibilities behind it. So mathematically putting it together, he says the chance of the possibility of DNA having appeared by chance is as remote as the possibility of 1 over 1, 40,000 zeros on the right-hand side—a figure which only the scientists can imagine how huge and tall this figure is, because all the atoms of the entire universe are much less in number than this figure.

That means that the possibility through chance would be that if all the atoms are subdivided into sub-particles, and the whole universe is then mixed together, but you have to pick just one single sub-particle, one particular sub-particle which is tagged, and you put your hand in that mass and just reach that particle—if that is possible, then all this is possible. That is what he wants to say. But much more, because this universe does not have enough sub-particles to meet the requirement of that number.

So this is what I said proves positively that chance does not explain anything at all.

If a man accepts what he sees, and this is true scientific approach, he should accept his defeat. He must say that the net result of the investigation is this: that up till now we have been following chance and attributing everything to it. But this false god has proved to be too false now. And now these things cannot be attributed to chance, positively not. So there has to be something else. If you are agnostic, you can say, "We don't know what something is, that something is." But those who are religious, they can draw their own conclusion then, that after all they were right. The eternity there is, but in the form of a conscious being, not in the form of an unconscious being.

"Do these two terms, DNA and RNA, stand for something, or is it just a..."

Yes, they stand for something. Ribonucleic acid.

"Ah, yes. It stands for Ribonucleic acid."

This is, the name is just a chemical name, but it is not just an acid. It's form, it is found in a regular organization and chain. That is DNA.

"Dinucleic acid?"

Ribonucleic acid.

"Di?"

No, I am talking of DNA.

Deoxy. Deoxy, exactly. That's, that's correct. This is a technical name, chemical name.

"In a book, evidence in which 30 scientists published by their experiments, some of them Nobel laureates, this theory, Sir, that a conscious being must be there, and that God does exist, and this whole universe cannot have existed, created, but by a conscious being. That book is beautiful, published by a Christian society. The Evidence, in which the articles of 30 scientists are there."

I see. But when I read those articles—not in this book, I mean generally, whenever I read those articles—I find that they present our case very weakly, defectively, because they want to justify the evidence they find with their concept of Christianity, which they cannot do. So they have to take some stupid attitudes, unacceptable stances, which are rejected by the true scientists. So they, in fact, work against this case.

That material which they use, if it is employed by Ahmadis, then that material would be in the safest hands, because our corollaries would be correct, our inferences would be right, while they are in a very difficult position to justify what Christianity says while armed with the facts of life—it is not possible. So, it is helpful to us, no doubt, because we must concentrate on the data contained in such books, but not in the logic or the inferences they are drawing. They are always defective.

"But in this connection, I didn't find anything, they were quite logical."

Well, if they just remain confined to the concept of one Creator, then it will remain logical. But the moment they try to reconcile it with Genesis or Christian thoughts, Biblical views, it is there that they make mistakes.

"They have steered clear of it. They didn't bring in Trinity in that."

They didn't? Then it's all right. Correct. Yes.

10 of 10 left today