3. What did Ahmad specifically claim when he claimed to be the Promised Messiah (as)?
Question-and-answer session, 12 August 1984
Automatic transcript of the audio recording, checked against the recording and corrected with AI. Please check the wording in the recording.
Question: What did Ahmad specifically claim when he claimed to be the Promised Messiah?
What he claimed was, he is the same person who was... whose coming was predicted by Aan Huzoor (saw) and whom Aan Huzoor (saw) himself had addressed as a prophet. This was his claim. So, if that claim is repeated by anyone in future, it would be his duty to prove that Aan Huzoor (saw) has also referred to another one as a prophet, giving him a title. If he proves it, most welcome! The people of his time would willy-nilly believe in him, Allah would force them to make... to accept him.
"Man yuti'illaha", that particular points out that there will be Nabiyyin... No, no, it doesn't. It doesn't at all. Because when you say *minan-nabiyyina*, it does not mean plural would come. It's a way of expression. It's a language. You should understand first the grammar of Arabic to translate this word. *Minan-nabiyyina* means from among the prophets. And it refers to the previous prophets, because it are they who are mentioned. You must first understand the full text of this verse. Only then the confusion in your mind would be removed.
The claim is, *Man yuti'illaha war-rasula*—whoever believes, obeys Allah and the Prophet, Hazrat Muhammad Mustafa (saw). Now this "whoever" is a plural as well as a singular. The number is not mentioned. A possibility is opened. That has to be kept in mind. A possibility is opened that whoever obeys Allah and follows His Prophet Muhammad, peace be upon him (saw), would be counted among those who appeared before them, who would be treated like those—we can also translate it like this—who appeared before them and who were well rewarded by Allah, such as *minan-nabiyyina*, or those who were from among the prophets, and among those. So the plural is referred to the prophets of the past, and the promise says that you could also reach the status which was given to the prophets of earlier ages. That is the true meaning.
The number who would attain that status is not mentioned. If they are more, they would be more of such. If they are less, they would be less of such. Even those ulama who claim and try to deceive other Muslims by pointing out to the plural *Nabiyyin*—they say if that argument is correct, there should be many prophets—believe that there is only one Siddiq in the Ummah.
That is Hazrat Abu Bakr Siddiq. And if you say if there is another Siddiq, they would be after you. Why? Because the other Siddiqs, those who are Sunnis, they don't believe in Imamat like Shias, they claim that there was just one Siddiq. Well, this verse says *Siddiqina*, that is also plural. So, anybody who truly understands the Arabic and the diction of this verse would fully understand that here the style is this: that only those would be given, rewarded by Allah who follow Allah and Muhammad Mustafa (saw), and they could be one of those. *Ula'ika ma'alladhina an'amallahu 'alayhim*—such people would be counted among them. Now they are four, now together. So the plural, they are a plural in themselves, four all together under one bracket.
It does not mention, this verse, that how many of such people would rise to what status. Even if one rises to that status, to a single status, that promise is fulfilled. It doesn't say that Nabiyyin would come. This is where you are wrong. It says that Nabiyyin are those who were rewarded before them, Siddiqin are those who were rewarded before them, Salihin are those who were rewarded before them, and Shahidin—Shahidin is first—are those who were rewarded before them. This, the whole verse which follows, is an explanation of who were those who were rewarded before them.
After that, since 1953, when my father, may God bless his soul, pointed out to me whenever I was confronted with, out of Jamaat, when I ask this question, I always argued with them, that if there could be Shahid, Salihin, Siddiq in this time, why can't be there a Nabi? I had always been arguing like this. But thanks very much for clarifying that point, because you obviously open a new venue altogether.
Yes, the point is, the style is this: that when it is said they could... they would also be rewarded, then the verse begins to explain who were those who were rewarded. And the plural tenses are referring to the past people, and they were of course Nabiyyin and Siddiqin and Shahidin and Sulaha, they were all in the plural. So this verse is referred to them. So anybody who follows could be one of those. This is the meaning of the verse. And the number of how many would follow, that is not mentioned.
But apart from that, I believe that when Aan Hazrat (saw) says that *‘Ulama’u ummati ka-anbiya’i Bani Isra’il*, they are also covered with this verse; they are among those who are like Nabiyyin before them. This is exactly what is said. So the question of plural does not arise in any way. I mean, they are in plural, in fact.
Hazrat Masih Maud (as) is one of the subordinate prophets, that is what we can say. And the number of subordinate prophets is much larger than you can conceive, because there are two types of subordinate prophets: one whom Aan Hazrat (saw) gave the title himself by saying he would be Nabi, and in between him and myself there would be no one with the title of Nubuwwat. That is what Huzoor-e-Akram (saw) has said so, in so many words. Yet he says that there will be so many of my ulama who would be like the prophets of the old. And this verse is also referring to the prophets of the old: *Man yuti‘illaha war-rasula fa-ula’ika ma‘alladhina an‘amallahu ‘alayhim*—people of the past on which Allah Ta'ala appeared with grace and mercy and rewarded them. So they would be counted among those, and this is what he is saying, that *‘Ulama’u ummati* would be like the prophets of the old.
So there are so many. This is what I have been trying to explain to him, that don't underestimate the status of even those who are not entitled prophet in Ummah, because according to Aan Hazrat (saw) and according to this promise of *Man yuti‘illaha*, they are no less than prophets. By the standards which we observe before the era of Aan Hazrat (saw), they are definitely not less than prophets. By the standard which was observed by us after the era of Aan Hazrat (saw), or at the appearance of Aan Hazrat (saw), they can't be called prophets because that standard had risen... risen now. So, because this verse only promises prophethood according to the past standards, referring to those, so it is true. There is so many.