3. Did Muhammad (saw) sentence adulterers to death by stoning after the revelation of the verse in the Holy Qur’an prescribing flogging as the punishment (24:3)?
Question-and-answer session, 19 August 1984
Automatic transcript of the audio recording, checked against the recording and corrected with AI. Please check the wording in the recording.
Question: Did Muhammad sentence adulterers to death by stoning after the revelation of the verse in the Holy Qur’an prescribing flogging as the punishment (24:3)?
The fact is that only, I think, about a year and a half ago, I asked Hafiz Muzaffar Sahib and Malik Saif-ur-Rahman Sahib to collect, to work on this, and they collected quite a few traditions, relevant, and Hafiz Muzaffar Ahmad Sahib wrote a very good paper on this. So you tell him to send that paper; that should be translated and published in Review.
So, it is positively proved that after the revelation of this verse, there is not a single incident where Aa-Hazrat (saw) ordered anybody, ordered anybody to be stoned. The fact is that it was his general practice, and he always stuck to this principle, that as long as Allah had not revealed directly to him on something, he would follow the previous religion. And again, even after the revelation of something in the Holy Qur’an, if people from other faiths would come to him, he would judge them according to their faith and their books. That was the most magnanimous behavior of Aa-Hazrat (saw). He would not impose the Holy Qur’an upon them, but would decide their cases according to their faith and religion.
So, according to Aa-Hazrat (saw)'s traditions and Uswa Hasana, Ahmadis should have been asked by these so-called Muslims: "What is your faith and what is your book?" The answer would be: "Islam is our faith and the Holy Qur’an is our book." So if they were to follow Aa-Hazrat (saw)'s traditions, they would have to judge us according to the Holy Qur’an and the tradition, as we believe in that. But they themselves have left and abandoned the spirit of Islam, so how could we expect such a thing from them?
And they also attributed this act, this sort of punishment to Hazrat Umar in one instance. But that is neither here nor there. The Holy Qur’an was revealed to Hazrat Muhammad Mustafa (saw), peace be upon him. In his day it was demonstrated. For some other reason, if a punishment is given, that is not to be attributed to the Holy Qur’an, which does not say that. Even that has been investigated. In fact, we deeply went into all the possible incidents which may throw some light on this incident and make, confuse the issue, and we came to the conclusion ultimately that all the punishment which was meted out was not just for adultery or fornication.
The Holy Qur’an has given a right to a ruler to punish in heinous crimes by cutting the hands from different directions or stoning to death, and these things are very clearly mentioned in the Holy Qur’an. But the crime must demand, demand such a harsh treatment. So wherever Hazrat Umar or somebody else is found to have punished somebody, that was against a very heinous type of rape. It was not just adultery or something like, you know, like a normal phenomenon of a mutual crime, but it was a very criminal and extremely cruel incident of rape. So it was punishment, additional punishment for that, which he prescribed