5. Is it permissible to recite any verse in the Holy Qur’an while in prostration?
Question-and-answer session, 20 August 1984
Automatic transcript of the audio recording, checked against the recording and corrected with AI. Please check the wording in the recording.
Question: Is it permissible to recite any verse in the Holy Qur’an while in prostration?
The recitation of the Holy Qur’an in itself has a loftiness about it as such, and during the extreme state of prostration you are humble, but the Holy Qur’an is not humble. I mean that is some people say that, but against that there are certain other arguments. Some say that if Holy Qur’an is lofty book, there is no doubt, but Allah is loftier, which made the revelation lofty. So why do you say Subhana Rabbiyal A'la then? So that is also an argument on the other side. So we don't know in fact, in reality, we can only surmise or conjecture as to what may have been the reason, but the real reason is not mentioned. All that is mentioned is that you should praise Allah and extol Him, and do not recite the Holy Qur’an in, during your prostration. So let's leave it at that. You know, this is why Hazrat Musleh Maud, in the beginning, through his own argument reached the conclusion that this, he didn't know that Anhazrat (saw) had positively said it. So, he was of the opinion that these Maulvis perhaps say that and I don't agree, and one can say, recites. But when he came across this tradition, then he changed his view and said, although I couldn't understand, but I accept it. Anhazrat (saw) was better judge. When he says, so it's not necessary that we understand everything what he says. Sometimes he doesn't mention the hikma behind it, so accept it at the face value, whatever it is said, whatever is said, we accept it. That's that. Well, did you want to say something else on something? Sir, that was, sir, rejoinder to that Susan Mitra's article was sent in the beginning of this month to U.S. Mitra's article? A rejoinder to it was sent. Achha, you, you have sent it. Thank you. Jazakallah. In the beginning of this month it was. But now you have raised this point, I'll think over it, this sajda and and the Holy Qur’an. Yes, sir. I'll try to reconcile my own views on this.