8. If a man joins a prayer in the middle and the Imam has made a mistake but finished the prayer and then the man continues finishing what he has missed but then the Imam offers two corrective prostrations, should man who is still completing his missed prayers also perform the corrective prostrations?

Question-and-answer session, 20 August 1984

Automatic transcript of the audio recording, checked against the recording and corrected with AI. Please check the wording in the recording.

Question: If a man joins a prayer in the middle and the Imam has made a mistake but finished the prayer, and then the man continues finishing what he has missed, but then the Imam offers two corrective prostrations, should the man who is still completing his missed prayers also perform the corrective prostrations?

Yes, even if you have started your own prayer independently, if the Imam prostrates in Sajdah Sahw, you should also prostrate with him without breaking your prayer. And when the Imam has finished and released you, then you go back to the same position where the Sajdah Sahw started and continue with your prayer in the normal fashion.

— Then what shall he do? He should offer one rak'at or he should offer two rak'ats?

— So which? I'm not with you here. What do you mean?

— The Imam offered three rak'ats in the second second salah...

— First of all, tell me, is it Maghrib prayer or morning prayer?

— Zuhr prayer.

— Zuhr prayer. He said instead of four rak'ats, he said two rak'ats only...

— That's right. The man joined in the second part of the...

— In total, he said one rak'at in excess.

— He offered two rak'ats with the Imam, but the Imam offered three rak'ats instead of two. So that was an extra rak'at.

— That means five.

— Yes, five. That's right.

— And so he will say two rak'ats more. He will fulfill his two rak'ats more, not one rak'at, if that is what you mean. What is wrong with the Imam is wrong with the follower. He can't invent his own Namaz other than the Imam's. So, if the Imam has committed a mistake, all the followers must commit that mistake. So, if a Muqtadi came later on, out of the three rak'ats which he said behind the Imam, his real rak'ats were two. One was an additional rak'at which was not to be counted. So, because that rak'at was not counted in the Imam's account, it could not be counted in his account either. So, he will have to say two rak'ats more instead of one rak'at. This is what you wanted to know?

— Yes, that's right. Jazakallah.

10 of 10 left today