3. Is the claim in the Holy Qur’an that man was created from a clot of blood scientifically correct?

Question-and-answer session, 4 September 1984

Automatic transcript of the audio recording, checked against the recording and corrected with AI. Please check the wording in the recording.

Question: Is the claim in the Holy Qur’an that man was created from a clot of blood scientifically correct?

Is that the only thing which has been said of the origin of man, or are there other things as well?

There are other things, but…

Why do you leave them out and choose this particular bit?

No, I am not saying that er that this is the only thing that man has been created.

I know you are not saying that, but why have you chosen this as against all other references to the origin of life?

Because I feel that that this particular statement is incorrect scientifically.

But when you take the whole of the statement and treat it as as one unit, then you will understand that either everything is incorrect or nothing is incorrect. To take singly one statement out of a set of statements is not the correct way of approaching the problem.

The fact is that the Holy Qur’an also tells us that man was created from dust, that man was created from um um water, that man was created from um kneaded earth mixed with water, that man was created from decaying mud, that man was created from um um the vegetable life, that man was created from human sperm, that man was created from *'alaqah*.

That is a is a a a state of—let me—how would you translate *'alaqah*, Maulvi Sahib?

Not clot of blood. Ha, a a thing which stickies. Exactly, this is what I'm saying, that that particular verse does not state Listen a minute. It says, it doesn't say clot of blood; it says something which is sticky, *'alaqah*.

Could it be mucus?

Hunh?

Mucus, like, you know, like in...

Oh, no. Mucus is just one thing. Anything which is sticky and thick and and has a certain viscosity, viscidity or whatever...

Viscosity. Viscosity, viscosity, hunh? That is, hunh? Viscous. Which is viscous, yes. But whatever the appropriate word be, the fundamental of this *'alaqah* is which has a quality of adhesion, adhesive and sticking.

So it also says man is created from um a state of molluscs—you know, the sea life in which there are molluscs found; they are neither meat nor bone, but something in between the two things. And also it says the man was created from a mixed affair of blood and all these things. So all these statements put together are correct.

Sir, that particular They are stages. Sir, that particular wrong translation is incorrect, because if you use adhesion, then it would be correct, that man has been

No, but blood also comes into it.

Without blood, man not man cannot be created.

Not from er as a clot.

Clot, maybe the translation of clot is um not acceptable to you, but sometimes it looks like a clot. At one stage of embryo, the thing exactly looks like a clot. Those girls who have miscarriage, those ladies who have miscarriage at early stage, what they throw out, to the apparent eye, it is exactly like a clot. So why do you say this is miscorrect it is incorrect? Well, this is It is not incorrect.

No stage which has been mentioned in the Holy Qur’an uh vis-à-vis the question of development of man into its final shape is incorrect, individually or collectively.

No, I'm I'm just simply referring to that particular one statement where it is translated that it is from a clot of blood.

I say even if the translator is translation is wrong, still to say that clot comes into picture at one stage is is not incorrect. You go and er find out from any lady doctor. She would tell you that it it is exactly true. At one stage the embryo looks like a clot, and a clot of blood for that matter.

10 of 10 left today