5. Is it permissible to observe Eid on a Saturday if it actually falls on a Friday?

Question-and-answer session, 5 September 1984

Automatic transcript of the audio recording, checked against the recording and corrected with AI. Please check the wording in the recording.

Question: Is it permissible to observe Eid on a Saturday if it actually falls on a Friday?

The fact is that some people say that Eid and Jumma cannot fall on the single day. Yes. We are not talking of that at all. That is the opinion of the South Circuit. Ah, I know, but this is different. Yes, right. We are not discussing this situation at all. That's right. Agreed that Eid and Jumma can fall on the same day, then what would be the position? This is the question, independently.

Some say, no, not all. Not at all. According to the positive traditions of the Holy Prophet (saw), these two things are established: that sometimes Jummah and Eid both can be performed independently from each other, and sometimes Jummah can be brought earlier, and Khutbah Jummah and Khutbah Eid are welded into one, with the result that at Zuhr time you just say the prayer and not Jumma. This was said by the Holy Prophet (saw) in so many words, permitted. Whoever wants to do it is permitted to do that. That is agreed.

I thought he had the third possibility in mind which had happened once in Rabwah and which became very controversial according to some. The majority of Ahmadis, they submitted; they said the Imam knows better, so no question of discussing this. But there were a few people who took it as an excuse for discussing things and sow the seed of dissension among Ahmadis and create a sort of fitna.

So when he asked this question, I thought he might have heard of this and he wanted to find out what my position was. My position was that of submission, of course. Nothing else. Even our Jama'at here also perform independently Eid. Most often than not, both these things have happened in the time of Hazrat Musleh Maud (ra). Mostly it was, whenever it happened, it was independent Khutbah Jummah and independent Eid. Or a merger of Khutbah Jummah with Eid, and an independent Zuhr prayer.

10 of 10 left today