1. What is your opinion of the distribution of land between Ali and Muawiya?
Question-and-answer session, 12 September 1984
Automatic transcript of the audio recording, checked against the recording and corrected with AI. Please check the wording in the recording.
Question: What is your opinion of the distribution of land between Ali and Muawiya?
This is a this is a fact of history. They came to a compromise dividing the Muslim Empire into two, into two parts: one to be held by Hazrat Ali and the other to be held by Hazrat Muawiyah.
Now, this compromise was not, had nothing to do with the question of Khilafah. Such a compromise could be reached between a Khalifa and a non-Muslim emperor as well, if that is what you have in mind. This compromise is not regarding the right of Hazrat Ali to be called the rightful Khalifa of Momineen or Khalifa of An-Hazrat (saw) or Amirul Momineen. So there is no compromise on that issue at all. Never did Hazrat Ali make a compromise on this.
This is an understanding, political understanding. Why should two states, which had emerged as independent states now, go on fighting with each other while the population of both the states was Muslim, a majority population? That was the issue at hand. And they decided that we should come to an understanding and divide the borders, and clarify, demarcate the borders so that no future feuds remain. It's all very clear and simple and understandable as it is, and there is no question which arises from this situation.
Huzoor, regarding the wording... So, no, no, wording is that of that that writer. It's not my wording. The point is, what what is it that is agitating your mind? Clarify it, otherwise I'll not be able to answer this question.
Because this agitating in my mind is is... بات آئی اس سلسلے میں کہ حضرت علی رضی اللہ تعالیٰ عنہ کو اور امیر معاویہ رضی اللہ تعالیٰ عنہ نے سن چالیس ہجری میں صلح کر لی۔ These are the words.
That's right, yes.
Sulah mean, they came to some understanding...
Compromise. Peace was declared between the two warring factions.
The fact was that Islam should be now observed by you in two parts: one regarding the religious office of Khilafat, one regarding many Muslim states emerging with a Muslim majority population, so you could call those states as Muslim states.
The time when that happened, that agreement was reached at, at that time already, in reality, two Muslim states had come into being: one governed or ruled by Hazrat Muawiyah, and the other was ruled by Hazrat Ali, Karamallahu Wajhahu. And there he had his two positions: one that of representing Islam, which was not shared by anyone else on earth, and the other being also the temporal head of that state.
So, when these two states came into being, there were fightings and misunderstandings, and both the factions kept on warring against each other for territories, for other issues which may have revolved here and there.
Now, that was a state of restlessness and a state of disorder, bad-amni. Hazrat Ali decided that instead of this situation being tolerated on both sides at the cost of Muslim blood, why shouldn't we reach a conclusion, an understanding between each other? And he offered Hazrat Muawiyah to come to an understanding, and a boundary, clear boundary was demarcated between the two states. That is all that happened. So to my mind no question arises from this. This is why I am repeating that if still there is a question in your mind regarding this situation, clarify that question. Otherwise I will not be able to answer that.
No Huzoor, the wording...
The wording is that of the author, I have nothing to do with it.
Might be. Now since Huzoor has cleared the position, so... I had discussed with other Ulama, which does not agree that they, there was some sort of sulah.
Why don't they, they disagree? As I told you very clearly, it is a matter of statecraft. It has nothing to do with religion. And an agreement can be reached between a Muslim state even and also a non-Muslim state. So why not between the two Muslim brothers?
And the Holy Qur’an positively declares that it is not a must for Islam that the entire Muslims of the world should be united under one kingdom. Islam clearly lays down that if there is misunderstanding or fighting between two Muslim states, then the rest of the Muslim states should join hands together and try to bring about a compromise and understanding between the two states. If they do it and one state still does not cooperate, then they are permitted by Islam to join their forces against that that state which does not cooperate with that decision, with the majority decision, and force it to accept the decision. And the Holy Qur’an further lays down that even if that state misbehaved and did not accept the decision without compulsion, you have no right to transgress against his rights, against that state's rights, with the result that justice must be done even after that misbehavior. No punishment should be meted out to such a state, just a compulsion and that's enough. This has been laid down in so many words in the Holy Qur’an.
So if the concept of Muslim state was a singular, indivisible concept, such verses had no place in the Holy Qur’an. That shows—and obviously this this is the factual position—a single Muslim state cannot be conceived, because it's a religion of propagation. It is possible that, for instance, suppose there was just Saudi Arabia to begin with, forget about the rest of the Muslim states at present, and through propagation of Islam, Saudi, Ghana accepts Ahmadiyyat, Islam—that is Ahmadiyyat, of course—and then China accepts Islam, how could they merge into one state? It's not possible, and against the wishes of the people. And who would be the ruler then? There is no Khilafat. Even if there were Khilafat, it's not always possible for a newly converted, I mean, for for a people who have just got converted to Islam to accept the yoke of another state under the name, in the name of Islam—what happened in Bangladesh in recent history.
So Islam is a religion of reality. It's not just an ideological religion which cannot be practiced. I think you have been deceived by the concept of one single Muslim state under one caliph. This is wrong. Islam never dictates that the caliph must always be the temporal head as well. This is why Hazrat Khalifatul Masih Sani (ra) made it very clear that if at at my time or at any other time Ahmadis gain power in in any country and were the rulers of that country, Khilafat would remain separate from the statecraft. It would never merge together again, because it has done damage in the past, and we do not want that damage to be done to Islam. So Khalifa has absolutely no desire to become the ruler of a state.
This is why Hazrat Masih Maud (as) laid it down very clearly:
Mujhko kya mulkon se? Mera mulk hai sab se juda
Mujhko kya tajon se? Mera taj hai Rizwan-e-Yar
So that is the message for every Khalifa to come. Remember that Khalifa will never be a temporal head. If he has a true regard for Islam and its values, he would be a religious head. So that concept is wrong to begin with.