4. How should Muslims perform their prayers while on a journey?

Question-and-answer session, 12 September 1984

Automatic transcript of the audio recording, checked against the recording and corrected with AI. Please check the wording in the recording.

Question: How should Muslims perform their prayers while on a journey?

According to the standard Fuqaha, accepted Fuqaha, the jurists, the scholars of jurisprudence, they are at variance in some minor things. They have differences between them. Some say the journey is is one manzil. Now, manzil again is a variable factor. By manzil, they mean just, say, one stop. So they say that if your next stop, when you are taking a long journey, decides whether it is a journey which should be considered justifiable for halving the number of rak'aat or not.

So, some say it is 19 miles, some say it is 14 miles, some say it is 12 miles. Now, it all depends on how you take the journey. For instance, if you are travelling on foot, you may stop at 12 miles. And some scholars who said it is 12 miles, they thought that they would dictate the terms who walk on foot, and their journey would be taken as the indicative or representative journey. Some journeyed on camel backs, and they even made a hop of 40 miles. So that is the 40 miles, perhaps.

He says a 48 miles, sir. Han, well, he must have been riding a very strong camel, because others, I know, some, many scholars have mentioned 40 miles. The 48 is the first time I am hearing. Safar ka takhmina 48 miles ... Angrezi he has added, you know, from himself, without rhyme or reason.

The fact is that the mile was a different mile. When we talk of miles, according to the terms of Islamic jurisprudence, those miles were measured in farsakh, and for 1,000 farsakh it was one mile, and a farsakh was about a yard and a half. So the rough idea of a mile, as jurisprudent scholars spoke of a mile, was about 1,500 yards, definitely less than an English mile.

So according to them, it was either 12 miles, or some say 18 miles, some say 20 miles. And some do not agree with that at all. They say the Holy Qur’an says a journey, and you should leave it at that. Leave it for individual decision. If a person considers himself to be on journey, let him make that decision. Why do you make it, I mean, make it in hard and fast rule when the Holy Qur’an has just mentioned a principle?

I know that, but why do you keep referring to him repeatedly again? I have understood what he says, but I don't believe in him. I'm not meant to follow him. I'm just talking of the Islamic jurisprudence now, according to the principles laid down by Islam, and as understood by the earlier renowned scholars of Islam. So this is a variable factor. No decision has ever reached on this. So the best thing is to find out what has been the practice of Hazrat Masih Maud (as) and the Khulafa-e-Masih Maud (as). For us, that is quite enough. And they never went into a detailed discussion about the mileage. It was never mentioned. They left it open to a person. If somebody was undertaking a journey and it was not just a short hop of a trip or a picnic, then it was left to him to act accordingly. We know, for instance, when we used to go to Rajpura, there in Rajpura, Rajpura was from Darul Anwar about ten and a half miles or eleven miles, I suppose, you know, about that. So though Hazrat Musleh Maud owned that area, that piece of land, so it was like a home to him. So it was his decision that he, along with his family members, his children, would say the prayer in house... No, not say... they would not say the prayer in house, they would say the prayer as if they were not on journey, because it was their own home. But those who accompanied him, if they were not saying their prayers behind him, then they were permitted to halve the prayer, because even that was considered as journey. I am telling you something in addition to what you have asked, and that is a very interesting decision of Hazrat Musleh Maud, which should be of some avail to you. He decided, it was his view on this issue, that if father is accompanied by children, and he goes on journey, and reaches a place which is owned by him, although the distance between the two spots can be treated as a journey if it's a long distance, but once they have reached the destination, which is the property of the father, while the father is also there, the children would say the full namaz without halving it.

But if the father is not there, then they would be considered to be on journey. And he made it very clear to us. Once I asked this question to him, and he said, the point is that according to Islamic law, in the lifetime of a father, the children do not share the property. It is only after the death of the father that the property is distributed to them. So in the lifetime, they have no share, with the result that the proprietary rights are entirely and singly enjoyed by the parent. So when they go there alone, that is not their home. But when they are in their father's home, that is their home, in that sense. So that was his decision regarding this. So don't bother about the details of mileage. It will lead you into nothingness, only to further confusion. You see? Why to travel from a confusion, make a journey from a confusion to another deeper confusion? And about the other things... sunnat or nawafil? That you know, you have been born into this, you already know. The Ahmadiyya practice, that we do not consider Sunnahs as compulsory while you are on a journey. So it's already known by every Ahmadi. Can we say sunnat if we like? No, when you are permitted not to, it is like asking, can we say the prayer in full? Why don't you ask that question instead of the sunnat? What about the nawafil and...? What is permitted should be accepted like that, and this is the philosophy of obedience which has been taught to us in refinement by Hazrat Masih Maud (as). It's a very deep message, in fact. Hazrat Masih Maud (as) said that when Allah permits you, not to avail of that permission is not goodness. How about the other... other Muslims...? Just a minute, nahi nahi, I'm talking... You don't accept their decision, they may not accept your decision, what is wrong? Let them not. The point is that we will stick to our jurisprudence as we understand. Hazrat Masih Maud (as) threw light on this aspect, and it's a very interesting, I mean, fundamental point to be noted and to be understood. The fundamental point is this: it is, in fact, it relates to the philosophy of obedience, and philosophy of goodness, I should say.

Hazrat Masih Maud (as) said that nothing in itself is good or bad. It is only the obedience or submission to the will of Allah which makes something either good, or if you do not submit, it makes it bad. This is the philosophy of goodness. Otherwise, we cannot define goodness in any way without running into difficulties. Because if that be true, then if Allah permits you, then not to avail of that opportunity is not the true behavior of obedience which Allah expects of you.

Hazrat Masih Maud (as) made it clear that if you are kind to your children and permit them to do this and they do not, you will not like it. If you permit them out of condescension, I mean say, how to say, out of courtesy or showing them a favor and they say, "No, no, no, we don't like it," or you offer somebody something and he says, "No, I don't want it," you will not be pleased. So although you may not punish such a child—that is different—the true pleasure would lie in another direction, when the child accepts your offer with good grace and is grateful to you for that. So that is the behavior to Allah which is taught to us by Hazrat Masih Maud (as), so do not behave in any other manner. Don't ask questions. You cannot please Allah perforce.

And this message which Hazrat Masih Maud (as) has given us has been learned by him from Huzoor-e-Aqdas sallallahu alaihi wa sallam himself. He made it manifestly clear to his companions that you cannot force Allah by doing goodnesses. However hard, however much hardship you exercise, Allah will not be pleased. This is the verdict of Aanhazoor (saw). Allah does not want you to be put to difficulties. Allah is pleased if you are put at ease. This is again Aanhazoor (saw)'s words.

So, all this Shariah is not to add difficulties to your life; it is to put you at ease. This is the philosophy. Now, if Allah decides that this is the way to put you at ease, and you say, "No, we shall please You by going it the hard way," this is, in fact, a way of disobedience. So, don't do that.

Now, we were born in Ahmadi family and we have been practicing up to now...

Up to now. But now you have decided to deviate.

No, I'm not, I'm not. When it came to light from the other person that there is a certain book written like that, I argued...

I tried to make you understand this point.

No, I'm clear, Huzoor.

No, no, no. What I am talking of is a different thing. During the last session, when you mentioned this book...

This is another book, Huzoor.

All right, a book like it.

Like it, yes.

Of the same quality. I told you repeatedly. I said, these are unreliable books.

Yes, I told him.

They quote no authority. They cannot quote an authority in tradition or the verses of the Holy Qur’an. So the best way to argue with your opponents is to ask for the foundation of that...

Yes, Huzoor, I did that...

And they quoted this book?

No, Huzoor, when I discussed with him this morning, allow me to...

Please, please, please go on.

I asked him that whenever in our books, in namaz or in tafseer, always we quote the reference. But in this book there is no reference, so this has got no base. I argued with him.

So?

So he said, "You take this book, and I have read in other books also the same..."

So why are you pursuing that question further, then? You took the right stance. What are you asking me about, then? It should have been left at that. If somebody is guided and he does not wish to draw benefit from that guidance, how can you force it upon him? You should have left it at that.

No, I always...

And also, don't waste your time on those small things. Discuss fundamentals.

He's working with me for a long period, and I always go to find a way to Tabligh, for Tabligh...

This is no Tabligh! Don't, I mean, discuss... don't waste your time on these things. Discuss the fundamentals with him. Once he accepts the fundamentals, then he will chuck these books away himself.

The fundamental to be discussed is whether Hazrat Masih Maud (as) draws his authority from Allah or not, whether he is Imam Mahdi or not. If he is accepted by anyone to be the rightful Imam Mahdi, then he would never look twice on such a book, on which you are looking so many...

These are not guidance for us, Huzoor, in any way, we know that. But what I am saying is guidance for you! You don't pay attention to this, that's the problem!

I am telling you not to waste your time on these minor things when you preach a non-Ahmadi friend, because your time is precious. So you say this is useless. There's so many schools of jurisprudence in Islam, they go on fighting their battle between each other, what? We don't pay much value to these things.

The fundamental, according to us, is whether the man who was to be appointed by Allah has arrived or not yet, whether such a man has appeared or not. If that fundamental is solved, all these minor things will be meaningless.

10 of 10 left today