6. What should one do if one comes to the mosque and all the rows are full?

Question-and-answer session, 13 September 1984

Automatic transcript of the audio recording, checked against the recording and corrected with AI. Please check the wording in the recording.

Question: What should one do if one comes to the mosque and all the rows are full?

It is said that a single person cannot make a line, that is saff. And the Jama'at prayer cannot be said singly. So, some Fuqaha, inferring from this, have gone too far. And sometimes very, you know, very absurd situations arise out of this. They, they say that if somebody walks into the mosque and they are saying a prayer and the mosque is full in every line, so what they should do... In Qadian, I have observed myself in Masjid Aqsa when somebody would run to the one end and pull a man out of the saff, and he would try to keep his face in the direction of Ka'bah, just walk back that side. That was so funny that I remember I couldn't stop myself laughing while it was time for prayer, and the whole sanctity would be upset. I can't agree with such a teaching. It is impossible for An-Hazrat (saw) to have taught us this, while he went for the sanctity of concentration of prayer so much that if somebody crosses your line, he was very angry about it. He said, no, even if you have to wait for days together, don't cross the line of one's sajdah, because you are disturbing a man who is saying prayer.

So how has anybody a right to pull men someone, someone from while he is concentrating and already engaged in prayer from one side and drag him to his position to come to the middle and, you know, just to make a saff? That is extending it far too far. So the alternative which I used to invent in those days was that to pull the man from the middle. But then again, the whole saff was disturbed, because you are not permitted to stand while there are gaps between your shoulders. So everyone of the saff had to, you know, get together to fill the gap, and I personally don't like it at all. I must have it investigated unless it has a very positive, solid authority of An-Hazrat (saw). Just by making inferences from something, one must not hit the fundamentals.

The fundamental is that your concentration in the prayer must be honoured by others, must be respected by others, must be preserved by others, and no interference should be made in your prayer. That, according to me, is fundamental. The saff is just a secondary thing as compared to this. And why not one man who is behind, who is standing behind, is in fact in the congregation, he is following the Imam. As long as someone else comes and joins him, according to Allah, his prayer would be a congregational prayer.

And for that, I have an authority from An-Hazrat (saw). In one instance, when a man who was a shepherd asked him a question about saying prayers in congregation—this is a long tradition, but ultimately he said, suppose even if I say Azan and say Takbir and still no one comes to join me, still will that will that prayer would be a prayer of congregation? An-Hazrat (saw) said, yes. Allah would send His angels from the heaven who would stand by you and you would not be alone. So, if for the sake of Allah, someone comes to the mosque and joins the prayer, why should he disturb the servants of Allah? Angels, why can't angels be sent to him to stand by him and make it a prayer in congregation? That is, I mean, you may not take it too literally, because whatever happens, whatever whatever the phenomena of angels be, this is one certain hundred percent, that a man standing alone, singly in a desert, can be accepted by God as having said his prayer in congregation, not alone. So with this Grand Prophet, with that Grand God, why should we indulge in such absurdities and childish play?

Personally, I don't approve of it, but further investigation to be made. And jot it down and write to, first of all, to Maulana Fazal-ur-Rahman sahib. While already he is not with anything else. But now it's time.

"Only one point, it's very important, sir."

"Very important. We are most important."

"Up till now, we have not succeeded in making the lines straight."

"No, but you are standing in the wrong place. Here, this is not the microphone."

"We have been, again and again, a hundred times, a thousand times we have reminded, that the lines should be straight."

"That's correct."

"Secondly, that we should, like bunyanun marsoos, shoulder to shoulder. We see that some people join on this side, some people join on this side, there's a gap. Very dangerous."

"Is that so?"

"Yes, there are some, even today, every time. So can you please..."

"Why didn't you tell me before that important thing?"

"Well sir, is it, please, we should join in the middle? Is that right? How to do it?"

"That I agree. But you, you considered it a matter of such urgency that it had to be said tonight. But what about the previous nights when all these people... you know, I wouldn't say disobeyed, but ignored the injunctions of An-Hazrat (saw), and you didn't bring it to my notice."

"I have been doing myself. All should be shoulder to shoulder, come to the center. If you go that side, wrong; that side is wrong; all must come to the center line. Only that will succeed. Is that right, sir?"

"That's correct. The point is, if there are gaps, this is a way of filling the gap. If you move in any direction, the gaps will never be filled. The direction of movement has to be from the periphery to the center, from the sides to the center. So, this is a very acceptable and correct way of filling the gaps, and we should keep it in mind. He says that some people start shifting to the next man on the right side, for instance, if they are, although on the right of the middle, and they start shifting to the man next on the right, they would create another gap. Instead of filling the gap, they would be creating another gap at the same time. And if the next man also moves, then up to the middle, another gap would be, would continue to to be. So, and some make a different movement altogether on the other side. This is why people have to be told. I hope and you are"

10 of 10 left today