2. What is Islam's concept of destiny?
Question-and-answer session, 14 September 1984
Automatic transcript of the audio recording, checked against the recording and corrected with AI. Please check the wording in the recording.
Question: What is Islam's concept of destiny?
I think I've spoken on this subject at length in one of the earlier question-answer sessions here, and while you were preparing the catalogue, couldn't you find out where it was?
It didn't yet come up to me, sir.
Okay. So would you like me to...
Yes, sir, so that this gentleman could be... the cassette could be sent, sir.
All right.
I've tried to explain it once before that destiny or predestination can be categorized into different forms, different spheres. And without that categorization, you will not be able to understand what destiny is. The fact is that the entire plan of things by Allah is destiny. Not only destiny, but predestiny in the sense that before anything was created, the blueprint was prepared. This is why it put some scholars in great difficulty, early scholars of Islam, and they went into very severe debates about the creation of the Holy Qur’an or otherwise. So much so that people went on killing each other. During Mamun Rashid's regime, who believed that the Holy Qur’an was created, those who did not believe in the creation of the Holy Qur’an were put to death and tortured and most inhumanely treated. So this is the difference which they could not understand. There is creation, the act of creation, when substance and form is given to something, that is a different thing. Apart from that, everything is predestined, because the blueprint has to be there in the knowledge of Allah. So if that is the blueprint for everything, the Holy Qur’an has become a part of the general scheme, not as distinct from others. Because otherwise, you have to believe that there are sections which were not in the knowledge of Allah before the creation.
So, in one sense, everything is predestined. Before everything is given form or shape, it is in the knowledge of Allah. And not only in the knowledge of Allah, in the scheme of things. That there are two different things, I will come to differentiate between the two things later on. Everything which was to be born ultimately had all the necessary prerequisites created much before that particular thing or being was created. For instance, before man was created, all the requirements for a man, human beings, were already provided in nature, in every form, in the form of vested laws, in the form of provisions, hidden provisions as well as provisions on the surface of earth. And for the whole future development of mankind, whatever material was required by him, that material was also created, and in the same proportion as it could be required. And there is no age where a man can say that I have advanced beyond my requirements, I have thought of something, very clever thought, but unfortunately I don't have enough material to meet that requirement and my, the provisions have been left behind me.
No stage has ever come in history of man where this relationship can be established, that man has advanced beyond the provisions. One store of provision ends, and another opens up. Like in relay race, it goes on. Before one is finished, the other is ready in front, and there is no no man's land in between, no gap in between. So this is all a destiny, or, as I said, you can call it predestination.
Now, under these rules and regulations, things are in a way compelled to move in a certain way and a certain direction, and they cannot have their own choice. As far as the creation of consciousness is concerned, that is of later time, I'll come to that later on. But just before the time that consciousness was created, what we observe is a complete helplessness of everything which is born. They are governed by certain laws and rules, and none can deviate from that. It's like the life of angels, which cannot deviate from the set path Allah has set for them.
Now comes another factor, that of the creation of consciousness. This begins very, very slowly with the creation of life. With the creation of kingdom of plants, the early creation, in fact it was common between zoological life and botanical life, but later on a division was made. And to begin with, let's see that life was created in the form of vegetation to begin with. And vegetation was spread all over the surface of earth, and that was also destined and planned and well-timed, because the animals which were to be created later on, they required that vegetation for their survival. So by the time dinosaurs were created, the whole of the surface of earth was full of verdure and greenery and there was so much food already present for these dinosaurs that, until the time that they were destined to be removed from earth forever,
They were well-fed and well-provided. That's just one single example. But if you study the ecology, then you'll come to understand that it's an ocean of creation which cannot be comprehended entirely by any man, or even generation after generation of man cannot comprehend completely the beauty and the perfection of the scheme of things, if only you look at the ecology, not at the other angles. So all this tells us of predestination and a helpless state, state of helplessness, except in the animal kingdom.
When the animal kingdom comes into being, we notice that they can do things and avoid doing things. Yet, there are subtle instincts which control their actions, and they are not punished in the sense of morality, yet they are punished in the sense of mistakes, and the mistakes they commit are punished immediately by the natural laws. So they are given two courses open to them: either to adopt this or to adopt that. And it is the survival of the fittest in the sense that the more intelligent, more conscious a being is, ultimately, it breaks down to consciousness.
I mean, intelligence, as we study in the context of the early life, is synonymous with consciousness. So when I say intelligence, I mean consciousness, and when I say consciousness, I mean intelligence. So their conscious, the level of their consciousness is the determining factor for certain actions they take, for certain movements they make, and if the decision is wrong, they are punished.
With the result that more conscious a being is, greater ability it has for the survival. Not applicable in every aspect of human, of development of life, of course, there are so many other factors as well. But this is one of the prominent ones which I want to develop further to answer this question. This is why I am just choosing consciousness and its role in the evolution. So this has become a preferred state, consciousness, which ultimately grows into wisdom with the storage of memory, with interrelationship of that stored memory, and so on and so forth. And then we realize that more, the wiser an animal is, greater its, its capacity, if other factors are constant, to survive and overcome the difficulties in its way of survival.
So we are taught from that time that if you commit a mistake, you will be punished. If you do not commit a mistake, you will be rewarded. Although still it is comparatively unconscious decision as compared to, as compared to human decisions, and there is no morality involved, yet, for billions of years, we are taught, and these things go into our genetic codes. And they have become inseparable with our development.
Reward and punishment: these are the two ultimate goals towards which life is being pushed on, until the stage of humanity is reached. And for a long time human beings are also trained without addition of any moral system. In the same way, they are further evolved in the same lines: reward and punishment, responsibility for one's actions, and ultimate achievement is subject to your effort, that effort you put in, plus the rightness of direction of that effort. If the direction of that effort is correct and right, that where it goes up, amount of effort you have put in, plus the manner you go about it, all these factors make you a sort of your, of your own god, in a limited sense. Now you are getting free from a sort of predestination. Although all things around us are still predestined, the whole plan of your being is predestined, yet within that predestination you are, being given an elbow, room for elbowing.
And more and more option is being given to you until a stage comes where suddenly it dawns upon you that there are two paths, not only of this worldly life, but of life to come. And it is there that the morality enters and religion begins.
And before that moment dawns upon humanity, that is the early prophethood, everything is well-prepared and that man, and man is fully equipped with all the necessary prerequisites for making his own decisions in important matters, and realizing fully that there can be a supernatural being, a God, and there can be a system of morality as applicable to us as a system of material pursuits was applicable to us before this, and we will be rewarded and punished exactly in the same manner as we have experienced before. When that stage reached, then a new destination dawned, or predestination dawned upon man, and that was pertaining to his life after death. And the rule, the first rule was: man shā'a falyu'min wa man shā'a falyakfur. Because at, by this stage, he was, the man was fully capable of taking decisions, and he was given total freedom with regard to his decision in one direction or another.
So that is, despite the fact that the whole platform is predestined, within that platform you are given room to move about. Like you can move in, in, in a plane in opposite direction to which plane is moving, the whole thing is without, outside your control. Yet within that, there is some space available to it. Look at this earth. It is predestined to move in a certain direction, and nobody can change a jot of its direction. Yet you are free to move about as if nothing is moving along with you. You are free to do whatever you please. So within the predestination, there are spheres of destination controlled by you yourself. And that is where punishment and reward appear in the scheme of things, and you are made responsible for your own actions.
So these two things are not contradictory and paradoxical to each other. They fit perfectly well within each other. Comparative to each other, they are in full accord.
But there are so many other aspects. For instance, of disadvantageous births, advantageous positions in life, happiness and fall, to be born with a silver spoon and to be born with nothing, to be born in a wicked house, to be born in a noble family, and the comparative actions which are apparently out of control of a person who is born, born in a certain circumstances, all these factors plus the religious factors, some are born in Christianity, some in Hinduism, some, some in Confucianism, and all this adds to the confusion of this destiny within predestination. We appear to be free, we appear to be responsible our own actions, yet we appear to be totally helpless. Within the sphere of our own decisions and freedom of our, our decisions, when you look at all these factors, one feels disgusted and totally despaired. What he sees is apparently a, a, a freedom, yet that freedom is checked from all sides and one has, enjoys no freedom.
This is why one of, one of latest poets, Urdu, describes this situation: Yāñ ke siyāh-o-safaid meñ apnā daḳhl jo hai so itnā hai, rāt ko ro ro subḥ kiyā aur subḥ ko jyuñ tyuñ shām kiyā. Yāñ ke siyāh-o-safaid, you know siyāh-o-safaid means destination, and rāt is siyāh and din is white, safaid. So how beautifully he has played pun on this siyāh-o-safaid. He says, yāñ ke siyāh-o-safaid meñ apnā daḳhl jo hai so itnā hai, rāt ko ro ro subḥ kiyā aur subḥ ko jyuñ tyuñ shām kiyā.
Nāhaq ham majbūroñ par ye tohmat hai mukhtārī kī,
chāheñ haiñ so āp kareñ haiñ, ham ko 'abas badnām kiyā.
It's a difficult couplet to be translated, but it's a most beautiful couplet in this, in the context of this question, so I shall attempt to translate it. He says that in the scheme of things in this world, our part is only this much, that willy-nilly we turn the night into day, crying and wailing for our helplessness, that's the stage in which we find, but despite these protestations we can't help anything. So, somehow the night turned into the morning as if we have played a part in it, while our part was only that of wailing and crying, and somehow the days are turned again into nights as if we were responsible, while the responsibility was only this much, that it was very difficult to pass that heavy day, but somehow we did. So that is our part in the scheme of things, O Lord, which You have created.
Yāñ ke siyāh-o-safaid meñ apnā, what's the next verse? Nāhaq ham majbūroñ par ye tohmat hai mukhtārī kī.
It is a completely unfounded allegation upon us, helpless people, and we can't even help that. You are the King and the Emperor and the Creator of things, the Master of destiny, do whatever You please. So You have alleged that we are responsible for our actions. What actions? What responsibility? What freedom? We know none. Everything is predestined by You, and only the allegation is for us to share, and so that we can be punished ultimately. This is a very serious, I should, we could say protestation to Allah for all this. But when you really consider further and closely watch what is happening and compare the various situations in which man is told to have played no part, and is suggested that he is completely helpless, then you will observe, by a closer study of the situations and again by a closer study of the Holy Qur’an and a better understanding of destination and our freedom as within that destination, then you will understand that all this beautiful poetry is just hocus-pocus. It has no foundation, no substance.
Allah is right. We have a freedom of action, and we are responsible for our actions, rightly and justifiably. The most beautiful rule laid down by the Holy Qur’an is this: Lā yukallifullāhu nafsan illā wus‘ahā. Lahā mā kasabat wa ‘alaihā maktasabat. Lā yukallifullāhu nafsan, God will not force anything upon any being. He will not be expected to perform things beyond his given capacity. Within that given capacity, whatever that be, if he consciously does some misdeed, then he will be punished to the extent that he has committed that misdeed; but even if he unconsciously does some good acts, he will be rewarded for this.
The distinction between the verbs used for earning good or earning bad is a beautiful distinction. Allah Ta'ala says: Lahā mā kasabat. Kasaba means just earning, whether you put in a conscious effort or not, anything which came into your hand, you, you went somewhere and on the way you found something which did not belong to anybody else, and you owned that, that would be yours. You caught a bird, it came your way, that would be yours. So anything which you earn, whether you really do it with consciousness and plan and you put in a lot of effort for it or not, that does not make any difference. You will be the proprietor, according to Allah, of anything that you earn consciously or unconsciously, rightly or sometimes wrongfully as well. But as far as the law of punishment is concerned, the Holy Qur’an uses the word iktasaba. Kasaba and iktasaba, though, or though they have the same root, but according to the Arabic grammar, when a, a root is put into bāb-e-ifti‘āl, then a new meaning are added to that. Kasaba is to earn; iktasaba means to earn consciously, consciously with full responsibility, knowing everything, and then doing it.
So this is why, when the sin of Adam is described in, in the Holy Qur’an, the Holy Qur’an says: Wa lam najid lahū ‘azmā. We didn't punish him, because there was no conscious effort on his part. He just made a mistake, but ‘azm, that intention, full intention of committing a crime, that was lacking. So this is the definition of sin provided by the Holy Qur’an.
Now look back at every situation which was presented to you by me with regard to the determination of our role. If somebody is born among Hindus, and he has not heard of the Holy Qur’an or the coming of the Holy Prophet, or he has heard of them, but has no capability of judging whether they are right or wrong, according to the Holy Qur’an, man āmana billāh, whoever has faith in God and does good deeds, he will be rewarded. Not even the faith of a prophet, upon any prophet, is mentioned in this regard. There are verses of the Holy Qur’an where even prophets have been omitted totally, because there are situations applying to certain people where they have no rightful means
to judge the truth of a prophet, sometimes they have never heard the name of a prophet. So how will they be judged? According to the Holy Qur’an, according to their own concept of goodness and evil. If they are true to themselves, what they think is right, they do accordingly, what they think is wrong, they abstain from doing it, the Holy Qur’an gives them the glad tidings of the heaven. They will go to heaven, according to this verse, and there are other verses and directions in the Holy Qur’an on this subject.
So, the Holy Qur’an tells us that even those before us, who were given the Book of Moses, for instance Jews, and those who followed them, for instance Christians, if they act according to their own teachings rightfully and honestly, and they do good deeds, if they have no means of judging Hazrat Muhammad Mustafa (saw)'s truth, then they would not be denied of heaven, and their good deeds would be rewarded amply.
So, Lā yukallifullāhu nafsan illā wus‘ahā is translated in all these verses, in different forms, in different situations. If a man is born amongst thieves, he has been provided with a smaller capacity for goodness. So Allah says: Lā yukallifullāhu nafsan illā wus‘ahā. If he abstains within that small capacity from stealing once for the sake of Allah, his act in the eyes of Allah may be much greater than a boy born in a saintly family who steals a small needle, while he was provided all the goodness and all the strength to abstain from committing evil.
So when the rule for judging and rewarding is the capacity of each individual being, and the knowledge, the full knowledge of that capacity is with Allah, and every individual will be judged according to that particular capacity and given circumstances, then who can say that everything is predestined? Those circumstances are predestined, but each man is individually treated freely, according to his own actions, and where only punishment is justifiably to be punished, only rewarded when an occasion for reward can be found.
And no one can say, because we were born in evil circumstances, so we should not be held responsible for our actions, because even in those circumstances each one knows that he is free.
Once a professor, highly educated and experienced man in academics, came to see me in Hyderabad, Sindh, and he was one of those, you know, who keep on thinking, pondering on these questions and go to meet various religious and other scholars, and some questions goes on agitating their minds and they don't find answers satisfying to themselves. And sometimes they begin to take pride and begin to talk among friends that, look here, we went to so and so and so and so, and we studied this and that, and still this question is a question which could not be solved. So this was one of the questions he had in mind, and he used to talk about it in company. So one of the Ahmadis heard it and said, why not come to the head of the Ahmadiyya Community who is visiting here and try your luck? So he came to me, and with all the introduction, he ultimately disclosed this secret question.
So I told him, I said, “You have, you have been born in a circumstances, in certain circumstances which you could not help. Of course I understand that.”
He said, “Yes.”
I said, “But each day, right from the morning till the evening, you go on making decisions. And within your own sphere, you know better than anybody else that you are given option each day, many a time, where you took a right decision or wrong decision according to your own standard of judgment. And when you take a wrong decision, sometimes you feel that your heart is adversely influenced by that decision, and you are not happy with yourself. And you take actions when, which, those actions ennoble you in your own eyes. Is that not correct?”
So he pondered for a while. He said, “That is correct, and also it is correct that I have got the answer to my question.” No further question.
So that shows that he was a sensible man, an honest person; he was a true searcher after truth.
So the best judge of one's choice is each individual himself. Apply this situation to yourself every day, and you know better than anybody else that although your circumstances are predestined, each action that you take and the decision preceding that action, in, in that action and that decision, you are free. Most of them are free.