4. Are we allowed to invest in banks that say they return profit on your investment as opposed to a fixed interest rate?

Question-and-answer session, 16 September 1984

Automatic transcript of the audio recording, checked against the recording and corrected with AI. Please check the wording in the recording.

Question: Are we allowed to invest in banks that say they return profit on your investment as opposed to a fixed interest rate?

So, it is not the change of nomenclature, it is the change of practice, which is significant and which has to be studied. If, for instance, all banks are compelled by the banking laws of various countries to to deposit the banks' money or a certain share, proportion of banks' money into government banks with fixed rates, so their profit, whatever name they give it, would be at least partly interest. So when they give somebody something in the name of profit, that interest which they would have received from the government, under compulsion of course, that would be a part of that profit. So if it is understood that that money which comes as interest is not to be treated as profit, and it is to be diverted to other sources, which are permissible in Islam, then there is no objection. Otherwise it would be still objectionable, because if you mix even a drop of filth in milk, of course the whole milk milk becomes filthy. Next.

10 of 10 left today