7. Is one allowed to borrow money from their family and then give them the interest that one would have given to a bank?

Question-and-answer session, 16 September 1984

Automatic transcript of the audio recording, checked against the recording and corrected with AI. Please check the wording in the recording.

Question: Is one allowed to borrow money from their family and then give them the interest that one would have given to a bank?

No interest can be given by you of volition. They are two different things altogether. In bank, you are compelled. It is sometimes a matter of survival. A survival is not always individual. It is also a survival for a class or for a group, a survival in trade, in business. They are very important things. So for that, some things could be permitted.

But when you can you have a choice, of volition you cannot give interest to any individual. That is totally forbidden. That is out of question. I have spoken on this subject at length in one of my sermons and told people that this is really practicing usury.

In fact, it is the individual relationship more which is hit by the Holy Qur’an in those injunctions. And for that, Allah has given you a—I mean, Allah has provided you with a way out. Why don't you adopt that?

An-Hazrat (saw) encouraged this, and it is based on the Holy Qur’an, this injunction of An-Hazrat (saw), that if you borrow money from someone, it is always good and appreciated that without condition, when you pay back, you pay back more than what you borrowed. And this was this was a consistent habit of An-Hazrat (saw). He always gave the lender more money than he had lent. But it was not binding upon him.

So if you want to give your sister or your father or your mother any money out of of of your own free will, you're most welcome, but it should not be conditional.

Give them as you please, but without condition. If you make a condition, then you are practicing usury. This is Islam.

Who says that? What what you are saying is not logical to me. The point is, who prevents you from giving money to your sister? Nobody does! But for you to borrow money from someone who is also a Muslim, and encourage usury into this relationship, if you permit this, the whole society would turn into a into a society of usury! There will be no end to it! Then you will defeat the entire purpose of the Holy Qur’an completely!

This is why it is also discouraged to borrow money from the bank. It is not encouraged at all. If if possible, you must avoid all situations where you must borrow money with inter- with and by with the condition that you have to pay interest.

Now condition- the question is not whether you should pay more to your to your friends or relatives or not, that is not the question! The question is whether you are bound to pay or not. Suppose you borrow money, and your money is lost. You run into business difficulties and troubles, and ultimately you land up in a very difficult situation. So now con- converse, conceive the converse of this. Then does it satisfy your conscience that you borrowed it borrowed money from your parents or your sister, and you are suffering heavily, so that you have lost almost all your capital, and still you have to pay more than the capital back to them? Does that situation satisfy your conscience?

Of course, that is that is why I said that banking is not within your control. I started with this! Banking is not within your control, within your power. It is the international monetary system which has not been created by you. But when you permit individual transactions on usury, that is of your own creation! They're two different things altogether.

For instance, to eat pork when you are dying, it is different. But to say that when I am permitted to eat pork in that situation, why shouldn't I eat pork when I'm invited by friends? That is is more likely situation for me to enjoy pork. Why am I not permitted that? So it's not you- the question of your enjoyment, it is a question of principle! There it is a compulsion. In the system of bank, there is a compulsion and the banking system is not of your making.

If it is possible for the Ahmadiyya Community anywhere to enforce its monetary system of its own, it will not be a system of banking based on usury, that I assure you! But when the entire monetary system is completely out of your control, you are not responsible for what they do. But when you promote these things within individual dealings, then you are responsible for what you do.

10 of 10 left today