9. Is it permissible to accept bribes in certain situations?

Question-and-answer session, 16 September 1984

Automatic transcript of the audio recording, checked against the recording and corrected with AI. Please check the wording in the recording.

Question: Is it permissible to accept bribes in certain situations?

This is why I say when a system has enveloped the whole society or whole system, then it's impossible for you, for someone, to remain completely, you know, safe from the influence. You can't protect yourself at times. For instance, to pinch it down, I understand, there was once an Ahmadi station master in Sindh, near Larkana, not Larkana, near Jacobabad. I remember, it was Sultankot, I remember the name of the station. So I was making a tour on Waqf-e-Jadid tour, going to the villages where we had established our centers and also to other Jamaats as well. So I was told that there is an Ahmadi station master, sub-station master, and he accepts bribes. I was deeply hurt. I went to him and after discussing a few things, I said, "I hope you do, you don't tell lies."

He said, "No, even if I did, I won't tell lies to you." This is the common way of saying it in the Punjab, you know? "Thoade samne jhoot nahi bolna."

So I said, "No, you shouldn't tell lies before anyone, but I know from your, the way you are speaking, you will be honest. Tell me, do you accept bribes? Why do you have to?"

He said, "Yes, I do. And I am going to tell you why do I have to. If you tell me a way out, I promise, I'll I'll adopt that."

He told me that here the system of bribery has become almost a common taxation system. He says, "Everything which which is produced in this land, that is cotton and wheat, etc., has to be exported because there is no market. So, there is no manner of exp- carrying it to other places because there are no roads available, there is only train. So, we make the rule and we dictate the terms to all these farmers. Because otherwise their produce will rot. So, we say that if there is one rupee for for the carriage of one maund, we say you must pay three rupees, you see, instead of one rupee. And that is a rule. And with this money, which extra- this extra money is shared right from the lowest orderly in the in the organization up to the general manager. And this system is so perfect that you have to provide the money to your bosses and to your your your your subordinates as well. So he says, "Okay, you know the out- the outturn of this station run runs into lakhs, and if I do not pay them their shares, they will say that I am I have been dishonest to them, both to the my bosses and to my subordinates. So I'll be eaten up alive. And if I pay it from my pocket, I can't pay even for an hour's income of bribery, with what I get in one month or even six months, you see. That is the ratio."

He said, "Tell me a way out, how can I do it? All that I can do," he said, "was that I accept the bribe and I do not accept my share. Here, your question comes in, that should that share, that very small share, be diverted to Allah or not? Well, I am rather hesitant in doing that."

What I told him was that, all right, you don't accept your share and tell them to short-circuit you. This is the best way. Apologize and say, all right, you accept this money, my bosses and my juniors, and I am not going to do it. So don't give me anything. So he said, "I I'll try that, but I don't think they will agree to this."

After a year or so, I met him again. I asked him, did you find a solution? He said, yes. I said, what the solution was? He said, I have quitted the railways. And I am doing my some business. I prayed for him, that Allah bless him with flourishing business. So that is the answer in fact. Is there another...

10 of 10 left today