6. How could Muhammad (saw) have been taken to God during his experience known as the Miraj if God is everywhere?

Question-and-answer session, 26 October 1984

Automatic transcript of the audio recording, checked against the recording and corrected with AI. Please check the wording in the recording.

Question: How could Muhammad have been taken to God during his experience known as the Mi'raj if God is everywhere?

There are so many things to this question which make it impossible for it to happen, because the Holy Qur’an gives us a concept of Allah with which this belief is in direct clash. That is the type of impossibility which makes it difficult for us to believe in this.

There are two types of possibilities. One possibility, one difficulty is—and that is impossibility—that we say, for instance, you are powerless to make a jump to that roof. So if you claim, we will not believe. That is one way of rejecting a thing. And the other is that it is possible for you to make that high a jump, but it is not possible for you to make that high a jump and, instead of being on the top of the roof, being underneath the earth at the same time. You understand this point? This is called paradox. This is not called impossibility.

So the question which applies to the Mi'raj, as we understand it, is that of paradox. Allah's attributes are put against Allah's attributes. In the one instance it is said that Allah is everywhere, and in the second instance it is said that Hazrat Muhammad Mustafa (saw) travelled from somewhere towards God, physically, as if God was not here and God was there, while Allah says, "We took him along." The word used by Allah in the Holy Qur’an say that We took Our servant along with Us: *asrā*, or He took, that is Allah, *asrā bi-‘abdihī*. He was all the time with him. So this is the paradox. This is not impossibility.

So there are other objections again which are of this nature, which we have against their concept. But of that I have spoken in quite some detail elsewhere in Urdu, and you can understand Urdu well. So you better listen to those tapes.

10 of 10 left today