9. Why is the title "Ameer-e-Shariat" associated with Ataullah Shah Bukhari and not Muhammad (saw)?

Question-and-answer session, 28 October 1984

Automatic transcript of the audio recording, checked against the recording and corrected with AI. Please check the wording in the recording.

Question: Why is the title "Ameer-e-Shariat" associated with Ataullah Shah Bukhari and not Muhammad?

Assalamu alaikum. Huzoor, I wanted to know for the benefit of others the meaning of Ameer-e-Shariat, because this title was acquired by the Hazrat, our Maulana Maududi Sahib, and to to me… Ataullah Shah Bukhari. Also Ataullah Shah Bukhari. And this title to some is really very great. It is only reserved for the holy reserved for the Holy Prophet (saw). No, not even that. There is no Amir of a Shariat. There is Amir of a people. Amir is Sahib-e-Amr. Now I'll speak on this subject. This this, the very construction is wrong and meaningless. You know, when the scholarly deeper people of Islam, the earliest people um of the centuries much closer to Huzoor-e-Akram (saw), spoke of Shari, Sahib-e-Shariat, they never referred this to mean Hazrat Muhammad Mustafa (saw). Shari always meant Allah Ta'ala, because it is the enemies of An-Huzoor (saw) which make people believe that Shariat-e-Muhammadiyya, peace be upon him, was invented by An-Huzoor (saw) himself, while the reality is that not a single word of this Shariat, or this law, was made by Huzoor (saw). So the Shari is not the person to whom the law has been revealed. The sha- the Shari is the person who has revealed the law. So Shari is only Allah who has revealed the law, the Word. And the recipient of the Word is only the recipient of that Sharia, and he is warden of that Sharia. So the word Amir in in reference to Sharia has neither ever been used in the Holy Qur’an, nor in the tradition, nor in the earlier terminology of Muslim scholars. In the first few centuries, you will never find this mention even remotely, even a shadow of this sort as applicable to any saintly person, any scholarly person, or even to Hazrat Muhammad Mustafa (saw). They always said Shari is Allah, and An-Hazrat Muhammad Mustafa (saw) is a model for us of that Sharia. So Amir means Sahib-e-Amr, and Sahib-e-Amr in Sharia is only God. And others are demonstrators of Amr, explainers of Amr. And when Amir is used with reference to men, then men become Sahib-e-Amr, of course—"Ulil-Amri minkum", for instance, in the Holy Qur’an. So there is there can be an Amir of Mumineen, of course, but never never Amir of Holy Qur’an. And what is Sharia? That is Holy Qur’an. So how could a person be Amir of Sharia? Amir of followers of Sharia can understand- is understandable, of course. But Amir of the Holy Qur’an, na'udhu billah, ma'adhallah, that is none but Allah. So this is a idolatry, a term with idolatry stink in it. So Ahmadis don't accept this term as such at all in any sense, except for Allah, but the word Allah Amir is not used in connection with Allah either. So this combination is just meaningless, useless, and absolutely worthy of rejection.

10 of 10 left today