3. Can people who are not prophets, such as Nostradamus, make true prophecies?

Question-and-answer session, 11 November 1984

Automatic transcript of the audio recording, checked against the recording and corrected with AI. Please check the wording in the recording.

Question: Can people who are not prophets, such as Nostradamus, make true prophecies?

Have you read any of his books? No. I know Cayce. And I know the woman, the most famous in America, Mrs. Dixon, the crystal ball lady. And I have read her books as well. And I know positively that she is wrong, because the time already has passed when she had prophesied about some events in 1981 and 82. And the 1981 and 82 have passed, and no such event took place.

And one of her followers met me in America in 1978. And I said, "I don't have much time for reading all about her or by her, but better bring one book and we'll pinpoint certain prophecies and see what happens." So, in the first instance, one of the prophecies was obviously totally wrong. She said that Christianity would then spread all over the world. So I said, "If this is the limit of her prophecies, or the quality of her prophecies, I know what she is and I know her very well now." Later on, one of those prophecies you can mention, that I had pointed particularly, that "I hope we both live to see that she'll be proved wrong there", and she is proved wrong.

However, this person, he made thousands of prophecies in his own time and for the near future and also for the future ahead. And he came before Hazrat Ghulam Ahmad (as). And, you know what, the fundamental point is to study the book and find out for yourself. That's very important, because it's not necessary that all the prophecies be fulfilled in exactly the same manner as they are predicted. And it's not always necessary that a person who is making the prophecy, who is making prophecies is a false man, or a fraud. All about that person has to be first understood and analyzed before we give a verdict. It's very important, and comparisons cannot be made unless you know both the persons and their claims and their environment before making such comparisons.

So prophecies can be based on scientific knowledge. And such people who make prophecy on scientific knowledge, they never claim to be prophets. And if those prophecies come to be fulfilled, there is no harm whatsoever, because we know there are signs in the creation to which the Holy Qur’an repeatedly refers: "Why don't you read the signs? Why don't you read the writings on nature?"

So, those signs can be interpreted by some, both in relationship to the past and in relationship to the future. So, if somebody bases his prophecies on such knowledge, there is absolutely no harm, and no comparison should be drawn between such a person and a prophet, because the nature of prophecies made by the prophet are, number one, fundamentally different in character. Number two, they are not just wild jumps of imagination. They have a certain message, a certain philosophy and a certain direction. Thirdly, as Hazrat Masih Maud (as) has very fairly pointed out, that a prophet's prophecies always bear the character of Allah's aid for that particular prophet, and His support to that particular prophet.

An ordinary soothsayer has no such character to her or his prophecies. There is no element of her victory or his victory. They are unrelated events to him or her personally which are being told. So, the comparison does not—I mean, there is no comparison to be made. In fact, they are two different things, in fact comparing a human being with a monkey or even a lower placed animal.

So, sometimes if somebody has made a prophecy and it is fulfilled, and he says, "I heard that from Allah," there is no harm in that either. The harm would be only when he makes a prophecy and declares to the world that Allah has authorized me to speak on His behalf to you, and to make you follow me on the authority of my Lord. That is the sort of prophecy which is never tolerated by Allah, and such a person and his following are destroyed totally.

So, you should not be confused about the nature and the character of prophecy. Otherwise, you may begin to draw wrong conclusions. Sometimes a pious man, even if he is not a Muslim, but basically he is sound and pious, he can be shown good dreams. And we know in the world, many Christians are being shown dreams which come to fulfill. And many atheists as well receive specimen information from Allah, so that Allah makes the whole world aware of the fact that a phenomenon of this nature continues, goes on, so that they have evidence in every religion and in every people that something like this does happen.

So when a prophet speaks to them, it should not be a completely strange phenomenon. So this specimen which continues to happen, but it's not a sign of somebody's truth. That is different. There are so many other things which pop up and which come into picture before you begin to judge someone. Once traveling in a train, I was speaking to some officers from the from Air Force, traveling along with me. And we started discussions and I was speaking to them. And they were quite intelligent and logical in the Air Force. So, naturally, they were influenced by Ahmadiyya because Ahmadiyya is very logical. And there was one person sitting who was becoming more and more restive as we got into it. So, you know, you could see agony on his face. So, when he couldn't put in a word because he knew that he would not be able to undo the influence, so he thought of a clever device. At that time, during that at that time, we were discussing some prophecies of Hazrat Masih Maud (as), their nature, and how they were to be fulfilled, and the prophecies belonging to future in particular. And some I mentioned which had already been fulfilled. So he suddenly said, "Can I say a word?" I said, "Of course, why not? Say on." He said there is a pir in Mirpur, whom I know personally. He made such and such prophecy. And it was fulfilled exactly like this, despite the fact that so and so judge had declared that case to be, had been declared the case against some party, and this pir said, "No, you are ultimately going to win. Nothing will happen to you." And despite the fact that odds were against that party, he ultimately won, and so he quoted one or two incidents. After he had finished, I said, "After all that, can you call that pir a liar?" He said, "No." I said, "This is exactly my claim, that if such such thing happens to someone, you can't call him a liar. If he also claims that Allah has made him a prophet, you have to accept him. In the case of Hazrat Mirza Sahib, he has made that claim, and in case of that pir, no claim is made. So you treat him as a pir and believe in him as the messenger of Allah?" So, prophecies are just by themselves nothing. What they are about, what is the nature of the subject we mean? And what is the message? That is what differentiates the prophecy of a prophet from the rest of such prophecies.

10 of 10 left today