4. If Muhammad (saw) was perfect, then why does God exhort Muhammad (saw) to come into His protection (Heiliger Qur’an, 33:2)?
Question-and-answer session, 18 November 1984
Automatic transcript of the audio recording, checked against the recording and corrected with AI. Please check the wording in the recording.
Question: If Muhammad was perfect, then why does God exhort Muhammad to come into His protection (Heiliger Qur’an, 33:2)?
In Surah Al-Ahzab, sir, Allah Ta'ala has said, *Yā ayyuhan-Nabiyyu-ttaqillāh*. I mean, the Prophet was almost perfect, you know, why to say—
Why do you say almost perfect?
Well—
What do you mean by almost perfect, please?
Well, sir, he was *Afzal-ur-Rusul*.
What?
He was *Afzal-ur-Rusul*.
Why do you say almost? Why don't you say he was perfect?
Yes, sir, perfect, yes.
Why did you say almost?
Well, I said that because to err is human, you know. To err is human, you see, everybody can—
So, because he was not God, that is what you meant when you said almost perfect.
So, God is infinite and man is finite, and perfection, when we speak of it with reference to man, is imperfection with reference to Allah. So, travelling towards Allah has no end.
So when a Nabi is said *Ittaqillāh*, this *ittaqū* means quite a different thing from when an ordinary person is said, is being told *Ittaqillāh*. For you, *taqwa* has a different meaning, and for a perfect man, like Hazrat Muhammad Mustafa (saw) was, *taqwa* had a different meaning. It meant: come further closer to Me, come under My protection more and more. And that perfection, that protection knows no end, because Allah has no end.
So when you said almost perfect, in fact you answered yourself: almost with reference to Allah.