5. I have a German friend; he has become somewhat irreligious, i.e. he belongs to no religion – this trend exists in Germany nowadays. His question is: how is He merciful? If He is merciful, why does He not help those people, like in India where there is hunger – He should help them – or in Ethiopia, or these earthquakes – why does He not stop them? … According to them, He brings punishment at times. They also say: when a child is born and someone has no leg, no ear, is lame or disabled …
Urdu question-and-answer session, 19 December 1984
AI-translated (from Urdu)
Question: I have a German friend; he has become somewhat irreligious, i.e. he belongs to no religion – this trend exists in Germany nowadays. His question is: how is He merciful? If He is merciful, why does He not help those people, like in India where there is hunger – He should help them – or in Ethiopia, or these earthquakes – why does He not stop them? … According to them, He brings punishment at times. They also say: when a child is born and someone has no leg, no ear, is lame or disabled …
You probably came here only yesterday, because this question was asked there, in Hamburg; in Hamburg it has already been clarified, we answered it. A cassette came from there, it has arrived, with German translation as well. … This is the same question asked earlier in a different form; its answer has been given, listen to it. I answered it in great detail on two occasions in England, and in Germany, in Hamburg, also to some extent. – (Questioner: The earlier question was about adults; I also included children, the newborn and those in the mother’s womb.)