6. … which is fulfilled in the future; likewise a prophet says something which is fulfilled in the future. For example, I read about the guru Vyas, about whom much has been written, that he was very pious. After extreme concentration about the human soul and its evils – some things he did not understand – he taught his disciples that if a man becomes pious he cannot do any evil at all; he denied (the opposite). One night, when he was performing extreme austerity and a disciple was with him, the guru who had lived before him came and told him the matter was thus. As a witness that disciple was present; what that one said was right, what the guru thought was wrong. He told it to him as a prophecy. He also said: if a man performs such and such deeds (karma), by these karmas he can prophesy if he goes into extreme austerity – he could prophesy that in certain circumstances, for certain reasons, such and such will happen to you at a certain time, and it did happen. If one speaks of Hindu literature, it contains such astonishing absurdities … And Huzur, you said earlier that a person through concentration (hypnosis) can make others see things that do not exist. Then what is the difference between a prophet’s miracle and such people skilled in the art of concentration?

Urdu question-and-answer session, 19 December 1984

AI-translated (from Urdu)

Question: … which is fulfilled in the future; likewise a prophet says something which is fulfilled in the future. For example, I read about the guru Vyas, about whom much has been written, that he was very pious. After extreme concentration about the human soul and its evils – some things he did not understand – he taught his disciples that if a man becomes pious he cannot do any evil at all; he denied (the opposite). One night, when he was performing extreme austerity and a disciple was with him, the guru who had lived before him came and told him the matter was thus. As a witness that disciple was present; what that one said was right, what the guru thought was wrong. He told it to him as a prophecy. He also said: if a man performs such and such deeds (karma), by these karmas he can prophesy if he goes into extreme austerity – he could prophesy that in certain circumstances, for certain reasons, such and such will happen to you at a certain time, and it did happen. If one speaks of Hindu literature, it contains such astonishing absurdities … And Huzur, you said earlier that a person through concentration (hypnosis) can make others see things that do not exist. Then what is the difference between a prophet’s miracle and such people skilled in the art of concentration?

Go on, tell it; so far it is about the past – tell what he said about the future. … What did he prophesy after that? … You have become very much a believer! You keep believing these absurdities without thinking. I have had books obtained about them and about the mind: what chakras are, and what all a person claims to achieve by diving inward. If you accept all their claims, nothing will remain. They say, for instance, that after meditation an eye develops here at a centre, and through the light that comes from it the truths of the seven heavens become known to man, and information about the farthest stars is obtained instantly by the light of this eye. They only did not find out that the light of the farthest star needs billions of years to reach here, and that nothing can travel faster than the speed of light – that they did not find out; but they ‘found out’ that the torch of their spiritual eye reaches the farthest star. Then there are the tales written about gurus: a guru used to go into the water and disappear, and had said: do not call me back with noise and disturb me. By mistake his followers called him, because it took long and they got hungry. Then he stayed inside for a while, and after ten years came out, and when he sat (again) he said: by mistake this loss has occurred; I was to undergo … for a short while, now I had to undergo … for ten years. Do you believe all these tales? – (Questioner: No, Huzur, I do not believe it.) – Then why are you telling me? – (Questioner: I mentioned it as an example. Huzur said earlier …) – Are you trying to hypnotise me? – (No.) – Me? You are trying to convince me of something that does not exist! – (No, no, I am saying: if they really do it, what is the difference between a prophet’s miracle and such people skilled in concentration?) – I will tell you that, but do not ask such a long question. The real question is only: does a man also deceive people or not, and does he speak with more knowledge than people’s general knowledge or not – then what is the difference between that and a prophet’s miracle? That is the question, just that much. For that you need not have told the story.

10 of 10 left today