8. [Beginning of the question not preserved in the recording] … Prophets too have powers that Allah the Exalted grants them. What is the difference between the two [the powers of magicians/conjurers and those of the Prophets]?
Urdu question-and-answer session, 19 December 1984
AI-translated (from Urdu)
Question: [Beginning of the question not preserved in the recording] … Prophets too have powers that Allah the Exalted grants them. What is the difference between the two [the powers of magicians/conjurers and those of the Prophets]?
There are several kinds of differences which Hazrat Masih-e-Mau’ud (as) has explained. One difference, the most important and fundamental, is this: those who receive power from Allah the Exalted are given the sign of dominance (victory). They do not merely show some spectacle; rather heavenly support is with them, and whoever clashes with them is broken, and God makes them prevail. This sign is not given to any showman. Conjurers will turn earth into banknotes, leaves into banknotes, and when the show is over they will ask you for money because they are hungry. This means there is no dominance with them whatsoever. Allah the Exalted treats His servants in such a way that He raises them beyond the reach of others. When they confront even great powers, the great powers break and they prevail. No conjurer has this power. There have been very astonishing conjurers, but before Pharaoh they kept bowing and humbling themselves. If magic had such power that could turn a person into something else entirely, why would they have needed to bow? These people always remained courtiers. Therefore this is the clear, the real difference between these two things.
The second difference is that those people acquire a knowledge. And it is well known what they worked at: even hypnotists learn a knowledge, or attain some power through long practice, such that even if they give it up something still remains with them. They spend their lives acquiring these sciences. The past of the Prophets, however, is before the people like an open book: they never acquired that knowledge, nor did such things ever appear from them. It is simply impossible that a man learns a knowledge from childhood and keeps it hidden, to gather it and show it after forty years and then claim prophethood. As soon as someone starts learning these sciences, at that very time he begins to perform: ‘I have gained this power, I have gained that power, I will show you this trick.’ When two or four tricks are put together, a person goes around looking for a stage so that some people gather; and if none are there, he gathers the children at home and starts. So with regard to Prophets it is utterly against reason that they learned and acquired these tricks themselves, remained unaware of them themselves and also kept the people unaware – this is against human nature. That is why God the Exalted presents their pure life as testimony.
And then when these worldly trick-performers come before them – every worldly conjurer is a trained master in his own line, every worldly fraud or deceiver has his own methods and styles – how does this coincidence arise that every time this world clashes with the Prophet, the worldly one is overcome? And these are unforeseen things of which they had no knowledge; the choice was not theirs. When the conjurers contended with Hazrat Moses (as), he gave them the choice – this shows the greatness of Hazrat Moses. He said, leaving the choice to them: ‘Will you show first, or shall we show?’ And Moses actually had nothing to show, except that he knew Allah was with him. He said: ‘No, I have nothing to show, you show. When you show, then my sign will be manifested.’ He gave them the choice to show whatever they wanted. Hazrat Moses knew that whatever they brought, my God would destroy it. This event happens in the same way in the life of every Prophet: attackers come against the Prophet from different directions, and each chooses his weapon himself, and Allah the Exalted breaks every weapon – which is not within the Prophet’s power. So the fundamental miracle is his dominance, in whatever form, whether at the time of individual small fights or whether his dominance becomes manifest overall. And when he shows a miracle, his miracle is never broken in a contest, whereas the miracles of the world break.
[Interjection from the audience:] What is his name? – Dr. Ryzl, a parapsychologist from Czechoslovakia who has now emigrated, to America, probably to San José. – Do you know it? It is in the south of California [as heard]. – He has emigrated there. He has carried out very interesting experiments on this knowledge of man, on this power, that he immerses himself in his inner self, concentrates on certain future events and those events then happen that way. Now these are not fairy tales, because these experiments were done in scientific laboratories. They have their limitations, fine, but the events are very reliable. Likewise there is a woman in an East European country, Vanga; she is also blind. A lot of research has been done about her too, teams of Russian scientists have also gone there, she has been observed and all records have been kept. About her too it emerged that she has the ability to foretell the unseen. But after studying all of them one thing is proven conclusively: when they are told something of the unseen that is against them, when an event has been foretold that it will happen, they cannot avert it; they have no power that could avert it. But the Prophets, when they give news, do not only give news; they also show the way: if you do this, it will be averted. Whoever does it, for him it is averted; whoever does not, perishes. Either way it is fulfilled.
In this respect, the prophecy that the non-Ahmadis [probable reading] attack the most is the most magnificent prophecy: that concerning Muhammadi Begum. Because if an event is supposed to happen and is averted, people will say: it was never going to happen anyway. And if it happens and is not averted at all, people will say: you too are just a soothsayer, you have no remedy to avert this event. But God has the power: He who can warn can also give glad tidings; both powers must be there. So in my view this one prophecy, in which both these aspects have come together, is an astonishingly magnificent prophecy. You will find such another prophecy only very rarely, if at all. Thus Mirza Ahmad Beg became a sign of the fact that he resisted and, in accordance with the prophecy, died within the appointed time. And Mirza Sultan Beg did not resist but showed humility and meekness, and the women of Mirza Ahmad Beg’s family repented and became Ahmadis. Our Aunt Inayat – I have seen her too – was also from their family, [daughter] of Mirza Ahmad Beg’s sister or half-sister; they called her Aunt Inayat. Many of their family became Ahmadis. And there was also the revelation ‘Tubi, tubi …’ [unclear]; the women in particular repented. And Mirza Sultan Beg too was convinced of the prayers of the Masih-e-Mau’ud (as) [unclear] … that was the warning. These two things have come together here, and in the predictions of the world this does not happen. Either they turn out false – not that they show a way: ‘if you do this it will be averted, repent, do this’ – they just babble, a chance remark, and it turns out completely false. Some who are more gifted, or in a special state, say something that also comes about and is fully fulfilled, but they have no arrangement, no power to avert it. For in the examples I have mentioned there are such events: Vanga prophesied about a girl, about a woman: ‘You will have a daughter, and when she is two and a half years old, such-and-such neighbour will kill her.’ And it is said this was on record and was known, it was told beforehand, it is in the police records. But after two and a half years she is killed, she was killed [in that way], and nobody could stop it, and he was also caught in that way. These records I have [as heard:] checked; it will be written in those records. She told a man: you will have an accident at such-and-such place, at such-and-such bend; and at that very bend he had an accident and died there. Despite knowing it, despite it being preserved in memory, it could not be averted. The fact that the Prophets, when they warn and prophesy, at the same time also state the means to avert it, and, having received knowledge from God, can also say that it will be averted – this is a great, clear difference. Thus one realises that the Master of destiny is speaking; whoever tells it can also remove it. Here, however, is a phenomenon that has no connection with the Master of destiny; it is only knowledge, nothing more. [Remainder unintelligible]