5. Are Muslims permitted to keep dogs?
Question-and-answer session, 22 February 1985
Automatic transcript of the audio recording, checked against the recording and corrected with AI. Please check the wording in the recording.
Question: Are Muslims permitted to keep dogs?
Why not? Because the Holy Qur’an says you are permitted to... How do you say? Dog... hunting with dogs? Is there a particular term used in English for this? Game hunting with dogs is permitted in the Holy Qur’an, you know. So, I'm asking anyone who knows, is there a particular term in English used for this catching birds or things?
No, no, but there are two different things. The dogs here, which are used for hunting, they are just assistants to retrieve the birds, which are killed not by dogs themselves, but by guns and things. Except, eh? No, no, I'm not... except perhaps I think these rabbits are caught by dogs. But anyway, it is permitted in Islam. So if it is permitted, why shouldn't you keep dogs? How can you train them and how can you use them for hunting game while you are not keeping them?
What is bothering you is another tradition which says, if it is correct, it says that An-Hazrat (saw) discouraged people having dogs in their houses and said wherever there are dogs in the houses, the angels do not visit. Now this tradition cannot be translated in any manner as to contradict the clear injunctions of the Holy Qur’an. So obviously, people have misunderstood the meaning and significance of this instruction.
The fact is that if the dogs are not trained and if they are let loose in the houses, all the gentle people, all the gentlemanly people would think not only twice but many times before visiting that house, because nobody wants to be bitten by dogs or chased by dogs. Now, this is something which is completely alien to the Western society of today. Nowadays, in most of the Western countries, dogs are so well trained and they are legal—I mean, there are certain legal responsibilities of the owner of the dog, that if a dog bites some visitor or someone, he has to pay the damages which may amount to even 100,000 or more in America, for instance. So, it is very rare you would find any dog biting here in these countries. So these people cannot understand this tradition because they don't know the atmosphere of the East. We know that most dogs as kept in our country or other countries are more likely to bite the visitors than not.
So people cease to visit such places. I know some houses myself where I don't pay any visit or have not been paying visits, and when they reproached me for this, I said, "First you bind your dog, or, you know, make him behave, otherwise I can't come. I'm not fond of being bitten by dogs or chased by them." So that is what it means, number one, that where unruly dogs are kept purposelessly, or violent dogs, ferocious dogs, there angels don't visit. And by angels here is meant angelic people.
Secondly, according to some scholars, this could have been used not in literal terms, but in spiritual terms—dogs spiritually—because the Holy Qur’an also mentions dog as an example, and mentions that some people are like dogs. For instance, where Bal'am Ba'ur is mentioned in the Holy Qur’an, the example of a dog is given, and he is painted as one like a dog. That is the reason why that dog is mentioned when Bal'am Ba'ur is mentioned. So that shows that some people are like dogs, and they are injurious to peace. They are a hazard to peace. And wherever, in whichever houses such people are found, angels won't visit—angels in both senses here: the angels in the form of human beings as well as the angels in the form of those messengers which Allah uses to send His word to man.
So such houses are obviously out of bounds for angels where dogs are kept in these two respects: either the real dogs which are not trained and properly chained, or the human dogs. Either way, the angels won't visit that house.
But it's impossible to translate this tradition in any way where it contradicts the Holy Qur’an, as I have mentioned. When the Holy Qur’an permits you to keep dogs and to train them and to go game hunting with them, how can a tradition of the Holy Prophet reject that clear injunction of the Holy Qur’an?