12. Is it possible that some dreams can be the product of what a person experiences during the day?
Question-and-answer session, 22 February 1985
Automatic transcript of the audio recording, checked against the recording and corrected with AI. Please check the wording in the recording.
Question: Is it possible that some dreams can be the product of what a person experiences during the day?
That can be true. That is possible. Dreams have been described by the Holy Qur’an, as well as by Aan Hazrat (saw), to belong to different categories. There are false dreams shown by Satan to misguide people. There are dreams of one's own thinking, wishful or otherwise, a fear, repressions, psychological phenomena working from within. And there are dreams, of course, which are positively shown by Allah.
So this is possible, that what you think you may see in dreams. But the scientists are working on this subject, and this science is getting more and more developed now. Previously, they were just conjectures, what dreams are. Now they have further investigated and broken some ground on this subject. And now we see that dreams are not just the imagination of the day; they are a very complex affair.
In fact, some psychologists who have worked on dreams claim that it is not possible for you to think of something and make it appear in your dream. It is not possible for you. The phenomenon is totally involuntary. Whatever occurs to you, it may have happened during the day and may not have, but your wishfulness has no part to play in your dreams. That has been rejected by knowledgeable people. Yet they claim, and they admit, that what you see during the daytime may have its influence on your dreams, or what you may have seen or witnessed or experienced even forty years ago, if you are that old, even that can reappear in dreams.
So that is very complex, but still the machinery is provided to you for seeing dreams. That machinery can be fed from many directions and many different materials can be fed into it. So that does not mean that the direction of this machinery which is heavenly-wards is to be rejected.
What the scientists say, what is bothering perhaps your mind is this: that because psychological factors are responsible for dreams, so we must reject the possibility of Allah revealing anybody a dream. This is a false way of approach. I mean, this is totally rejectable. This is insensible—no, no, this is nonsensical, because a machine can be used by various operators. It can be used in various ways. If Allah created man with a purpose, with the ultimate aim to come into contact with him through various ways, it would be a very unwise Allah to have made that purpose and not provided man with that machinery.
So, if man is provided with that machinery and it is activated occasionally by other factors, that doesn't gainsay the possibility of Allah using that machinery. This is our approach.
Now, how that can be differentiated, for that there is a long answer. I can't answer you in this sitting, but both you brothers appear to be very intelligent boys. So, I think you can read Haqiqat-ul-Wahi and understand it because mentally you seem to be mature, with the grace of Allah. So, you better, if you're interested in this subject and how to differentiate between a good dream and a bad dream, between a psychological dream and a satanic dream and a dream by Allah, this subject has been discussed in detail, in depth, by Hazrat Masih Maud (as) in Haqiqat-ul-Wahi.