4. What is Islamic Law and how much has Ahmadiyyat done in regards to it?
Question-and-answer session, 13 April 1985
Automatic transcript of the audio recording, checked against the recording and corrected with AI. Please check the wording in the recording.
Question: What is Islamic Law and how much has Ahmadiyyat done in regards to it?
Islamic law is a very wide term applied to almost the entire human activity. Man-to-man relationship are all covered by Islamic laws, and also part of the Islamic laws cover man-to-God relationship. It's a very, very, I mean, lengthy answer that you that would be required by this question. It I won't be if I I'm prepared, first of all, I am not prepared to give all the details of Islamic law, but even if I were prepared, it would take a month or so to describe it in detail. But the fundamentals, I can tell you.
Islamic law is understood to have to have been based on four fundamentals.
Number one, the word of God, Who in Islamic terminology is called Shari', the One Who revealed the Shariah. Now, I am I'm telling you this because so many people, even scholars of today, misuse this word, and they say Shari' (as), which is totally wrong. This is supporting supporting the allegations of the Westerners, the Orientalists, that the law was invented by Hazrat Muhammad Mustafa (saw). While he was not the source of law in this sense; not a single jot of the law was invented by him. He was only a demonstrator, the one who understood the law because it was revealed to him, to give us the philosophy of law, to teach us how to do do it, or to how to practice it. So the first source of Islamic law and the fundamental source of Islamic law is Allah.
The second source is Hazrat Muhammad Mustafa (saw), because it is his interpretation which is to be trusted, to be followed in complete in every detail, in totality, and you can't doubt doubt his word. So although he is not a source, but he is an interpreter and a demonstrator.
The third source of Islamic law is Qiyas.
Now, the Sunnah, as I have said, covers both the tradition and his act. The word Sunnah is sometimes differentiated, is is is taken to mean only the practice of Aan Hazrat (saw), and according to the tradition the terminology of Ahl-e-Hadith, of Muhadditheen, the word Sunnah is the tradition of Hazrat Muhammad Mustafa (saw) as spoken word. But in reality it covers both: the spoken word and the practice. So when I say the source, as source, Aan Hazrat (saw) is to be included, I mean both his word and his practice.
The third is Qiyas or Ijma. By Ijma, this they mean that if the entire Ummah, that is the the entire Muslim population of the world agrees to a principle, that must be true. It's impossible for the whole of the followers of Hazrat Muhammad Mustafa (saw) to go wrong. So this is a a source in theory. In practice, we do not find any evidence that it ever happened or can happen, except on the occasion of the first Bai'at of Hazrat Abu Bakr Siddiq (ra). Nobody differed and everybody agreed. So that was the only Ijtima known to our knowledge in that respect, and another Ijtima which has been pointed out by Hazrat Ijma, by Hazrat Masih Maud (as), which is which which relates the incident where Hazrat Abu Bakr went to Masjid-e-Nabawi and recited the verse about Aan Hazrat (saw)'s demise: wa ma Muhammadun illa rasul qad khalat min qablihir-rusul, inferring thereby that Aan Hazrat (saw) has died because every prophet before him has died. So, Hazrat Masih Maud (as) pointed out that because nobody objected to this, not a single person did, so that is also an Ijma. So, two Ijma took place at the time of Hazrat Rasul-e-Kareem (saw)'s demise. After that, the whole Ummah went into a process of schism and division. The result was, it was impossible, practically impossible, for the Ummah to have Ijma on anything, except for Kalimah Tayyibah, but unfortunately, the Kalimah Shahadah now cannot be quoted as a point of Ijma for the Ummah, because there are divisions about the Kalimah as well now. We have evidence according to Shia books that they some some sects of the Shias believe that Ali Safiullah or Ali Safiullah should also be added in this. Is it Safiullah or? No, Wasiullah, I'm sorry, yes, yes, Wasiullah... Wasi-ur-Rasool... Wasi-ur-Rasool, Wasiullah nahin, haan. Ali Wasi-ur-Rasool is a part of Kalimah and is the fundamental article of faith. So, even if they be very few, but they, of course, believe in Hazrat Muhammad Mustafa (saw) and are a part and parcel of the Ummah. So the Ijma would go overboard. In our case, for instance, they also used this handle. They said, according to the Ijma of Ummah, your explanation, your interpretation of Khatam-un-Nabiyyeen is wrong, but how can this be called an Ijma? Because
prior to our expulsion from the Ummah, we were also a part of the Ummah, which they turned out. So, we were not a party to that Ijma at all. So Ijma is, unfortunately, a term of Fiqh which has been most misused, and very unfortunately. But there are great scholars, Muslim scholars, who positively say that this is just a theoretical thing, it can never exist, it's impossible for Ijma to take place. Moreover, they say that the concept of Ijma is rejected by the Holy Qur’an repeatedly, because in the sense the mullah takes it, because the Holy Qur’an repeatedly says that most often it is the minority which is in the right and the majority is in the wrong. For instance, at the time of the claim of Hazrat Muhammad Mustafa (saw), he was one against the Ijma of the entire Arab. And the Ijma of the entire Arab was wrong, and that one vote of Hazrat Muhammad Mustafa (saw) was right. His decision, I mean his faith was right, and the faith of the opponents was wrong. But there was an Ijma against him that you are you are Na'udhu Billahi min dhalik, you are a fabricator, and you are a liar, and you have nothing to do with truth. But not to mention Arab, if the entire world—because he was a prophet for the entire world—had gathered together like one being and declared him to be wrong, what would you think? What would be the value of that Ijma? So examples like this have been quoted by great Muslim scholars to prove their case that Ijma is just a hypothetical thing which never exists, and if it did, against a minority, it wouldn't prove anything. Well, anyway, this is supposed to be, in strict jurisprudence terms, a source of Islamic law. And the fourth is Qiyas. Qiyas also is based on the Holy Qur’an and on the Sunnah, but not directly. The spirit of Qiyas is not the literally it means guess, or to judge something based on something. But in this term, Qiyas only means that if you have no positive evidence of what should be done in a specific situation, conceive of a similar situation, and in the light of the Holy Qur’an and the tradition project yourself into that situation and see what you think Holy Qur’an would give would decide on that issue, or the Rasul-e-Kareem (saw), had he been alive, what would be his verdict on this. This projection of mind into a situation of the Holy Qur’an or of the Sunnah of Aan Hazrat (saw) is called Qiyas. So, the Ulema quote one example at the time of Aan Hazrat (saw): one companion of Huzoor-e-Akram (saw) faced a situation while he was away from Medina and he had to give a judgment on something.
So, he projected himself into Aan Hazrat (saw)'s mind and thinking, knowing his his views so much, seeing him practice Islam so often, he could judge that perhaps Aan Hazrat (saw) could do that, would do that. And just based on this projection, he gave a verdict. When he returned home, he was told that Aan Hazrat (saw) had exactly given the same verdict in the same situation, which he didn't know. And he tells us that that was by far the happiest day of my whole life. He said, "I was so happy, no words can describe, that I tried to think like Muhammadur Rasulullah (saw), I did think like Hazrat Muhammad Mustafa (saw)." So, that is Qiyas. Now, these four are the sources of Islamic law. The other A'immah, which are so often quoted, are like Imam Abu Hanifa, Imam Shafi'i, Imam Malik, and Imam Hanbal, Ahmad ibn Hanbal. They are all great scholars, of course; we revere them and respect them very highly, but they are not a source. They they saw the sources and gave their verdicts. So, Hanafism is like seeing Islam through the eyes of Hazrat Imam Abu Hanifa. Shafi'ism is seeing Islam through the eyes of Hazrat Imam Shafi'i, and so on and so forth. But if you have a direct source of light looking at Islam, there is no point in seeing through the light of Hazrat Imam Shafi'i, the sight of Imam Shafi'i, and shutting your own eyes to the direct source—that would be criminal. So, this is exactly the verdict of Hazrat Masih Maud (as) about the Ahmadiyya jurisprudence. He says, normally you may follow Imam Abu Hanifa, because most often than not his judgment is correct. But if you have a direct evidence based on the Holy Qur’an or the tradition of Hazrat Muhammad Mustafa (saw), or his practice, then reject Abu Hanifa and follow that. And if you have my word, positive, then because I'm I speak from from heavenly light, from Allah's guidance, so my word will never be against the Holy Qur’an or Hazrat Muhammad Mustafa (saw). So, if you have my direct word against any Imam, leave that Imam and follow me, because I am Imam Mahdi and the the leader which has been appointed by Allah Himself. So, this is the principle of Islamic jurisdiction, with this addition which I have made in the end. This is how we look at the Islamic jurisprudence. And a committee has been formed. It has worked, not entirely to completion, but partly it has worked and prepared some books on some chapters.