9. Why is Hassan not mentioned in our Islamic history books as part of the "Pious Caliphate" although he was a Caliph for six months?
Question-and-answer session, 19 April 1985
Automatic transcript of the audio recording, checked against the recording and corrected with AI. Please check the wording in the recording.
Question: Why is Hassan not mentioned in our Islamic history books as part of the "Pious Caliphate" although he was a Caliph for six months?
Had he been one of Khulafa-e-Rashidin, he could never have abandoned his Khilafat.
"But that was a reason for him."
No, no, no reason whatsoever.
"Because our Holy Prophet, peace and blessings of God be upon him, prophesied that after me the Khilafat will remain for thirty years, and after six months of his Khilafat, this thirty years was completed."
That is all right. But what I mean to say is, had he been Khalifa-e-Rashid in the sense we take it to be, he could not live beyond Khilafat. That is the point. So, Khalifa does never live beyond Khilafat because he is the subordinate of the Prophet, who does not live beyond his life in his capacity of office-holder. So, they exactly tally with each other.
Now, here we see something very different. So, that shows that he occupies an exceptional transition period. Now, when it is a transition period, he belongs to two different categories at the same time. So, we can't quote him as a clear case. So, better not opine on him, because by mistake you may attract Allah's wrath. So, things on which you are not very sure what happened, which are enigmatic and perhaps will remain enigmatic, on that better not to open your mouth at all.
Yes. Okay. All right, Huzoor. Jazakumullah.