10. What are the origins of Fiqa Hanifa and Fiqa Jafria and what are some of the differences between them?

Question-and-answer session, 19 April 1985

Automatic transcript of the audio recording, checked against the recording and corrected with AI. Please check the wording in the recording.

Question: What are the origins of Fiqh Hanafi and Fiqh Ja'fari and what are some of the differences between them?

Well, the origins of every fiqh are the same. There is absolutely no difference. They are accepted principles of the world of Islam, that is, their scholars, that the fundamentals of Islam are the same without doubt. But how you believe that this belongs to the fundamental or this does not belong to the—how how can differentiate between fundamentals, there the criteria differ.

Hazrat Imam Abu Hanifa, Imam Shafi'i, Imam Malik and all other and the rest, they believe that it has to be a direct line of tradition, after the Holy Qur’an I mean, which should lead to Hazrat Muhammad Mustafa (saw), and all the various links between the person who receives a tradition and An-Hazrat (saw), all these links should be solid and a full investigation should be made as to their character and credibility and all that. After everything done, you still and you you are left without any doubt that this particular tradition belongs to An-Hazrat (saw), then you should rely your judgment on that tradition and infer from that regarding the jurisprudence of Islam.

This is the generally accepted principle of the Sunni world, yet the standards differ, of course. Some A'immah have taken some very weak traditions—weak in the sense as it is used, da'if—and they base their judgment on some da'if ahadith as well, but only because they because there is a paucity of traditions on that subject, and they cannot lay their hands onto a more believable, more powerful tradition. So, the choice to them is just either to accept a weak tradition and base their judgment on that, or just to make give an opinion from themselves. So, in in these two cases, lesser evil is adopted, and instead of giving their own opinion on a subject, they would rather accept a weak tradition as well. So, the principle is not violated; the principle is adhered to. As long as they can have access to some powerful, reliable tradition, they would always do that. Otherwise, because there is nothing else in the field, the only available tradition would be accepted. This is the general happening in the world of non-Shia Islam.

The Shias have a different way of judging the credibility of a tradition. They say, what because our A'immah are ma'sum 'an il-khata—they cannot commit error and they are so truthful that it's impossible for them to relate anything to An-Hazrat (saw) which he never had said—so their criterion is this: that whatever an accepted Imam has related to An-Hazrat (saw), whether he discloses the links between them or not, whether that saying is traceable in the rest of the Islamic world or not.

Regardless of this, whatever the Imam says, or attributes to An-Hazrat (saw), that should be accepted in toto without question. So, their jurisprudence is based or is supposed to be based again on the same principles, but as far as the actual material is concerned, that differs widely because there is always a possibility that an Imam was told of something by some weak person who was not reliable, and because the thing itself was not objectionable, he might have accepted it. Well, this is what how we see.

And the but the Shias won't accept this position. They say the A'immah are ma'sum, they could not have related anything unless they were quite certain that Hazrat Muhammad Mustafa (saw) had really said it. So this is the major difference; otherwise, the principles remain the same.

10 of 10 left today