5. Why was it considered a sin for Iblis not to bow to Adam, as the angels were commanded to do, since he was not an angel?

Question-and-answer session, 20 April 1985

Automatic transcript of the audio recording, checked against the recording and corrected with AI. Please check the wording in the recording.

Question: Why was it considered a sin for Iblis not to bow to Adam, as the angels were commanded to do, since he was not an angel?

It's written in the Holy Qur’an that all the angels were commanded to bow before God, to bow for Adam—yes, that's right, *illā Iblīs*—but Iblis was no angel, but why was it a sin for him not to bow?

I'll explain. It's very simple. Please sit down.

The word *illā* in Arabic is used to cover not only people belonging to one species, but also things belonging or animals belonging to different species. For instance, it says, *jā’al-qawmu illal-ḥimār*: all the people came, *illal-ḥimār*, except the donkey. So, the donkey does not belong to the to human beings. Yet, the word *illā* makes an exception for the donkey, while he shouldn't be covered by the word "people". So, this is the Arabic way of of saying things.

So, although Iblis was not of the angels, yet when the order was given to the angels, he was below them. And as I have mentioned, the Arabic idiom, a higher species is mentioned sometimes which covers all the species below. And the exception does not mean that the lower species, which is covered by that order, is of the higher species.

10 of 10 left today