5. Throughout history, was there any opposition to the Ulema when they would declare various Muslim groups as non-believers?

Question-and-answer session, 17 May 1985

Automatic transcript of the audio recording, checked against the recording and corrected with AI. Please check the wording in the recording.

Question: Throughout history, was there any opposition to the ulema when they would declare various Muslim groups as non-believers? As Huzoor had mentioned in several occasions that the ulema had issued fatwas declaring kafir, non-believers, those of the Muslims who did not agree with their views on certain teachings of Islam, would Huzoor kindly guide us whether there were some among the Muslim leaders who raised their voice against these ulema for issuing such fatwas and dividing the Ummat-e-Muslimah, the followers of Islam, in different groups?

Yes, from time to time there have been many voices raised, but to no effect, because those voices were also stilled by the louder voices of the ulema, declaring them, themselves, kafirs. Allama Iqbal himself raised voice against it, but deen-e-mulla fi sabilillah fasad, this is his, his verse, but he himself was declared a kafir. Syed, Sir Sayyid Ahmad raised voice. Many other intelligentsia of of the Muslim society at various times tried to do it, but their voices were stilled, as I have said, by the louder and coarser voices of the mullah, declaring themselves to be, them, them to be kafirs, themselves. So this has been going on and on.

10 of 10 left today