7. How should one respond to a Christian who says he does not want to consider the Holy Qur’an because he believes that the Bible is the final Word of God?

Question-and-answer session, 22 June 1985

Automatic transcript of the audio recording, checked against the recording and corrected with AI. Please check the wording in the recording.

Question: How should one respond to a Christian who says he does not want to consider the Holy Qur’an because he believes that the Bible is the final Word of God?

Assalamu alaykum, Huzoor. This is a question from a Christian friend of mine who says that God created all the prophets who brought different religions to this world, and every prophet brought his own religion and his own book, till Hazrat Muhammad (saw) brought Qur’an and that was the end. We Muslims and Ahmadis, we believe that the Holy Qur’an is the last book and Muhammad (saw) was the last prophet. But a Christian who is believes in Bible says that whatever the Bible taught me, what Jesus Christ's teachings was, I believe in it. But why should I believe in Qur’an when God told me, through Jesus Christ, to believe in Bible? Then why should I believe in your Qur’an? Na’udhubillah, I had doubt about about the God that why He is changing His mind? Every time He sends a new prophet and says: "Believe in this." And now at last He says... Right. This is the question. So what should be the answer to this question?

Have you thought of some answers yourself? Have you ever attempted to answer these questions?

The answer should be very simple and straightforward. Why do why do not they still believe in the superstitions which were which were called science at the earlier ages and reject the discoveries, modern discoveries? Why have they changed their concepts about nature? Because they find the earlier concepts to be incorrect and the modern concepts to be correct. That is the simple way why people change.

So, the the answer is that you should compare the teachings of the Holy Qur’an and the observations it has made on various aspects of nature and compare them with the Bible and their observation and the observations made in various books of the Bible. And you will find that they are such hocus-pocus as compared to the declarations of the Holy Qur’an, and so faulty and so contradictory to its own statements that it's no longer a book to be reliable to be considered reliable. So unless you make a comparative study of the Holy Qur’an and the Bible and know for yourself, you'll not be able to cope with such a questioner.

But even the non-Muslims have started pointing out these facts. There is a book written by a French scholar who has compared the scientifically the observations made by the Holy Qur’an on certain aspects of nature and the observations made by the Bible on the same aspects of nature.

And he points out categorically, repeatedly, and proves his point by quoting the latest scientific authorities as well, that each time the Holy Qur’an is correct. And each time the Bible is either totally incorrect or mostly incorrect.

No, that's just a minute. Let me finish first.

And then he points out that the strange thing is that it's not that in the majority of cases the Holy Qur’an is correct. Without exception, every time, without fail, the Holy Qur’an is correct. And even on those subjects on which Bible is completely silent, it speaks of such knowledge as was completely unavailable to the time of Hazrat Muhammad Mustafa (saw) and which was gradually being revealed to mankind through their studies for the next 1300 or 1400 years. And yet that knowledge was available to him. He said, this is absolutely fantastic. Nobody can believe in it to have originated from human beings.

So what's the point now? Now, the point he makes is that, as you said, Huzoor, that comparing Qur’an and Bible, we find that the Bible is wrong, or, you know, it's hocus-pocus, you know. But he says that then God did provide the Bible.

No, no, no, no. This is not the attitude of the Holy Qur’an. This is again a very illogical attitude attitude adopted by these people. You have to teach them like children.

The fact is that the Holy Qur’an does not reject the earlier books, but with one modification in its statements: that the earlier books were originally revealed by God, and they contained truth and nothing but the truth, though not the whole truth—that's another difference between them and the Holy Qur’an—but they were later on interpolated by human beings, and it were they who added falsehood to the truth, and now you find them as ruins.

You can study the general plan and understand that originally they were of of a high order and they belonged to the region of truth, the area of truth. But no longer so. For instance, if you go to a ruin of a great palace, from the ruin you can understand that originally it was built for a very useful purpose and it served the purpose while it it stood intact.

But you no longer can be protected even from rain, not to mention great armies, today as you find them. So the Holy Qur’an does not say that the these books were not revealed by God. It says they were revealed by God, all right, but they were changed by human beings, not by God. So, what is the answer to this attitude?

That was my answer to him, that...

That was a very correct answer. So, what was the answer, his answer to you as a rebuttal to this?

Quietness. He went quiet, you know, “I don't have an answer to that.”

So, when you have already done all that, why were you asking?

No, Huzoor, no, no, no. Because the details what you mentioned is now. Yes, yes.

Very well. Jazakumullah.

10 of 10 left today