6. Did Muhammad (saw) have a physical "seal" on his back that represented his status as the "Seal of the Prophets"?

Question-and-answer session, 5 July 1985

Automatic transcript of the audio recording, checked against the recording and corrected with AI. Please check the wording in the recording.

Question: Did Muhammad have a physical "seal" on his back that represented his status as the "Seal of the Prophets"?

Assalamo Alaikum wa rahmatullah. Sometimes ago I read an article in a monthly magazine Ansarullah about how Hazrat Salman Farsi accepted Islam, and that he had heard a few characteristics about the Holy Prophet Muhammad (saw), and one was that Hazrat Muhammad Mustafa (saw) would have a seal of prophethood at his back. I wonder, could you please kindly elaborate this tradition?

Well, this aspect is for to be further investigated, because the Seal of Prophets has no material reality. The word "Seal of Prophet" cannot be expressed in material terms. It's the most excellent quality, even beyond one's imagination. So, not only there, but in many other traditions, one reads about this.

I think this started later on. People started thinking in of the Seal of Prophets in that material terms because of that age, which was, of course it was 13 1,400 years ago. The brilliance of Islam is because of the light which was shed around the Holy Qur’an and around the person of Hazrat Muhammad Mustafa (saw). So, when we study Islam in view of the revelation of the Holy Qur’an and the presence of Huzoor-e-Akram (saw), we think that that age was the most modern age, and we forget that the people living around were most backward people, and had Islam not shed, given them light, of course they were Ummiyyin of the worst order.

So these things started to creep into Islam when they reverted to their older views later on. This is my impression, because Seal of Prophet has a meaning which has complete, absolutely no bearing to a stamp on the body, and what was written on that stamp and how it was formed—I mean, this is all, I think, conjectures.

There might be some birthmark, it is possible, at the back of Aan-Hazrat (saw), and because this word was revealed, Khatam-an-Nabiyyin, so later on people might have started conjecturing and imagining that that seal which was mentioned in the Holy Qur’an, this was the seal. There is a possibility, and there is also a possibility for a symbol to appear—I mean, that cannot be ruled out—that there might have been some birthmark, and later on it may be considered to be the symbol, an apparent symbol of the Seal of Prophets, although it in itself was it was not a Seal of Prophets; Muhammad Rasulullah (saw) himself was Seal of Prophets.

This has to be borne in mind. So you, at the most, if you accept those traditions after full investigation and if you find them to be correct, the maximum license you can give it, the maximum, um, I mean, the most you can draw out of of of those traditions is this: that that was, if it was anything, it was just symbolic, something symbolic. Because Seal of Prophet is referred to Hazrat Muhammad Mustafa (saw) himself. It has never been said in the Holy Qur’an that he was given the Seal of Prophets. It is said he himself was the Seal of Prophets. So, if his so whole body—if it was a bodily seal—if his whole body was a seal, then what is the significance of that small seal to be attached somewhere?

So, if these traditions really survive the severe scrutiny, and if you go through all both all the lines, um, and study the character of various people involved at in the chain of tradition of of the of those who conveyed, related these traditions to us, you might find that some among them were not trustworthy. And also study from what is called the point of view of Dirayat.

In fact, there are two things. One is the report of tradition: who is reporting it, in how many steps it is reported, and the, and each person who is involved at each step, his character, whether he was trustworthy or not—all this is taken into account, and this system, this branch of knowledge, is called Ilm-e-Riwayat.

And through Ilm-e-Riwayat you can—there are very scholarly books written on this—you can go through all the various chains and find out if there are any weak links somewhere, and then you can judge the quality of that tradition.

And the second is Ilm-e-Dirayat, which is very seldom applied, unfortunately, in Islam, but in the early centuries it was applied, particularly during the time of the Khulafa-e-Rashideen it was applied, but later on scholars did not develop this system. But in the Western system, much more stress is given on Ilm-e-Dirayat, that is, the internal evidence: the story as it is related, the event as we observe—does it have—is it free from all internal contradictions? Does it agree with other such incidents related by some other people, or does it not clash with the fundamentals? And the—and the, does it hold water, rationally speaking, or not? All these things are called Ilm-e-Dirayat.

So, as far as this tradition is concerned to which the gentleman has referred, I should like to apply both these systems of scrutiny to these traditions and make a further research as to the, um, um, let's say, bona fides of this tradition, and then perhaps we'll be able to make up our mind as to the nature of what that seal was, if it was a seal at all.

10 of 10 left today