1. Did Mirza Ghulam Ahmad (as)'s essay, The Philosophy of the Teachings of Islam, place first at the conference as he had prophecied?
Question-and-answer session, 2 August 1985
Automatic transcript of the audio recording, checked against the recording and corrected with AI. Please check the wording in the recording.
Question: Did Mirza Ghulam Ahmad's essay, The Philosophy of the Teachings of Islam, place first at the conference as he had prophecied?
One of my friends to whom I gave The Philosophy of the Teachings of Islam, after a few days he read that and he asked me the question that the Promised Messiah did prophesy that, “This, my essay, will stand first and I will win the contest.”
Yes.
And he said, “But no mention of result is there. What was that?”
In the introduction, everything is said?
No, there is no mention of result, of what happened afterwards.
No, in the introduction is explained, everything is explained. In fact, there was no contest as such—not that a jury was to decide about which essay stood first and which second and so on. It was not a competition of essay writing of schoolchildren. It was an open invitation to the religious heads and their representatives, and that issue was to be decided by general acclaim of the people, their general reaction, natural reaction, and also by the comments of the newspapers.
So, from that point of view, it was so obvious that Hazrat Masih Maud (as)’s article stood first by all margins, beyond any shadow of doubt, that this has never been challenged. I mean, the beauty of this is that this book is being published with this introduction: that a prophecy was made, and then the public lecture was delivered, and it stood first from every point of view. This is being published and claimed by Jama'at Ahmadiyya for over a hundred years now—or nearly a hundred years, no, less than that. When was the lecture? 1896, so about 90 years. And no one has ever opposed this claim, rejected this claim, or challenged that, “This is wrong, you are making a false statement, this is not true.”
So, that is one way of looking at it. And the other is, which I once suggested to Nazarat Isha'at, and which has not been followed up, to publish the other articles presented by other representatives of religions. And that is the best proof, in fact. Then people will be able to compare the excellence of Hazrat Masih Maud (as)'s article as compared to those insignificant small things, totally meaningless and, in fact, not to be compared. So that would be one way of doing it.
But I wonder how big the book would become then. Those articles were not very long as compared to this. This was the longest, in fact. So, what do you think would be the size of those articles, and how many articles were really submitted and published by... At that time it was published, but it's not available? I see. Quite.
The original ones... Now, that has been mentioned in the introduction, hasn't it? The one I read, I had in Qadian. The introduction was quite lengthy and it... Exactly. So, that is not included in this. This is why this question has arisen. In fact, that introduction should be made a part of it, so that people who do not know the background of all this should be able to know it. That would that would suffice then. Otherwise, this would become a very bulky thing.
Han, but instead of just there, you should better either adopt the same introduction written earlier, or you can further improvise it and write a short introduction with all the proofs so that that can be made a part of the various renderings into other languages.