13. What recourse does one have who, despite his attempts at reconciliation, continues to be insulted and wronged by another party?

Question-and-answer session, 6 August 1985

Automatic transcript of the audio recording, checked against the recording and corrected with AI. Please check the wording in the recording.

Question: What recourse does one have who, despite his attempts at reconciliation, continues to be insulted and wronged by another party?

Dear Huzoor, if one family says rude things against another family, if one family says bad things after having an argument, we are told we should be kind and try to make friends, sulah with them. But if they do not agree and keep on insulting this family, what actions can we take against them?

Well, the best action, as advised in the Holy Qur’an, is a serious attempt to reform things. And if you cannot reform, and if you are not given enough strength by Allah to hold your temperament, then if you kick back only to the extent that you are wronged, that will not be considered a crime by Allah.

The Holy Qur’an, describing such situations, says: *Lā yuḥibbullāhul-jahra bis-sū’*. Allah does not like foul language, loudly spoken foul language. Yet those who have been wronged, if they take their revenge only to the degree that they have been wronged, they are within their rights. Allah will not stop them, because Allah is so just. But Allah advises you that to avoid such situations. And the best way He has expressed His will, His wish to us, is by saying: *Lā yuḥibbullāhul-jahra bis-sū’*. As far as Allah goes, Allah doesn't like it. So permission given to you is not because He likes this, because if you must insist demanding your right, then Allah will give you your demand, your right. But Allah wouldn't like it, still.

JazakAllah, shukriya.

But in certain situations, this is made incumbent upon prophets to indulge in strong language to give a taste to the opponents that this is how it hurts. Like the Holy Qur’an, for instance, has used strong language in some places: *‘Utullim ba‘da zālika zanīm*. That would not be considered—I mean, that would not be categorized with what, with your question, so keep this very clear in your mind.

10 of 10 left today