5. For how long are women considered religiously unclean after giving birth to a child?

Question-and-answer session, 9 August 1985

Automatic transcript of the audio recording, checked against the recording and corrected with AI. Please check the wording in the recording.

Question: For how long are women considered religiously unclean after giving birth to a child?

May I ask how you would answer one accusation which is sometimes made against Islam? One of the forms I've heard it in is: are women religiously unclean after having given birth to a child, or for how long?

Pardon? Pardon, just would you repeat that last bit?

It is said by some that in certain periods women are religiously unclean according to Islam.

During periods?

Yeah.

During menstruation? Or otherwise?

I've had the question: for how long are they unclean after giving birth to a child?

After giving birth to a child? No, this word "unclean" is a very uncouth word, which I don't like at all. There is nothing unclean about the ladies who are truly Muslims and who lead a pious life.

Ahazrat (saw) has himself described this aspect: najas, which is unclean—najas is the right word which can be translated as unclean—and a Muslim can never be najas. So unfortunately, perhaps this word has been so wrongly translated that the Western world has created a different picture from from what it is in reality.

To stop someone from saying prayer could have other reasons, and it is not the uncleanliness at all. It's a physical indisposition, and when you translate this as such, then there is no objection whatsoever. Then this is exactly the reality.

The Holy Qur’an itself has explained this. The Holy Qur’an mentions that they ask you about the periods, the menstruation of ladies; tell them huwa aza. It is an indisposition, it's a sort of illness or indisposition. And the answer is not that it is najas. So after that, for a Muslim or for a non-Muslim to conceive of these special phases of ladies' life to be phases of uncleanliness is totally wrong. It has no ground in Islam.

10 of 10 left today