2. Which prayer should one offer first if one arrives late for Zuhr and Asr prayers, but one is uncertain as to what prayer the congregation is currently offering?
Question-and-answer session, 13 August 1985
Automatic transcript of the audio recording, checked against the recording and corrected with AI. Please check the wording in the recording.
Question: Which prayer should one offer first if one arrives late for Zuhr and Asr prayers, but one is uncertain as to what prayer the congregation is currently offering?
She's asked that if you have missed Zuhr prayer, for instance, you are on a journey, or for some other reason you have missed the Zuhr prayer, and you reach the mosque when the Asr prayer is being said.
مجھے پتہ ہے، میں باقیوں کو تو بتانا چاہیے نا، جو مین ہے۔
Um, if we say the Asr, reach the mosque during the Asr prayer, what should we do? Shall we say our Zuhr prayer, which is the earlier prayer, before our Asr prayer, or shall we say the Asr prayer with the Jama'at and say the Zuhr afterwards? Is that the question? یہی سوال ہے نا آپ کا؟ کہ ظہر پہلے پڑھنی ہے یا عصر پہلے پڑھنی ہے؟ جی۔ آل رائٹ۔
ظہر پہلے پڑھنی ہے، اگر آپ کو پتہ ہو کہ عصر ہو رہی ہے، اور عصر میں بعد میں شامل ہونا ہے۔ اور اگر پتہ نہ ہو اور آپ شامل ہو جائیں، تو پھر عصر آپ کی ہو جائے گی، ظہر اس کے بعد پڑھ لیں۔
Now, if you know that there is Asr prayer being said by the Imam, then it is your duty first to say your Zuhr prayer, which is the earlier prayer, by yourself. Having finished that, then you should join the Asr prayer being said in congregation. But if, for instance, the Imam is bringing the Zuhr and saying Asr and Zuhr together, Jam'a, and you don't know whether Asr is being said or Zuhr is being said, you join the Imam, and later on it turns out that he was saying the Asr prayer, not the Zuhr. In that case, your prayer, despite your own intention to say the Zuhr prayer, would be the prayer of the Imam, not yours.
Now, this is the principle which I want to establish and which you should always remember: an individual's intention is always, as a rule, overridden by the intention of the Imam. So if the Imam is saying Asr prayer and you are saying erroneously, under mistake, Zuhr prayer behind him, your Zuhr will be nullified and it will be turned into Asr, because Imam's intention is overriding the intention of those who follow. This is one of the most important principles in Islam. So, your Asr—if you join the Asr prayer as Zuhr, your Asr will be said and Zuhr will remain unsaid. So, say it after the Asr.
اگر آپ نے ظہر سمجھ کے عصر کی میں امام کے ساتھ امام کے ساتھ شامل ہو گئی ہوں نا، تو آپ کی پھر بھی ظہر نہیں ہو گی۔ جو امام کی نماز وہی آپ کی۔ آپ کو پھر ظہر بعد میں کہنی پڑے گی۔ ٹھیک ہے؟