8. Why do Muslim pilgrims staying in Mecca have to leave the city to perform ehram and then re-enter Mecca for Umra?
Question-and-answer session, 13 August 1985
Automatic transcript of the audio recording, checked against the recording and corrected with AI. Please check the wording in the recording.
Question: Why do Muslim pilgrims staying in Mecca have to leave the city to perform Ihram and then re-enter Mecca for Umrah?
Huzoor, when Muslims go to Mecca for Umrah and they are staying at a hotel or at someone's house—in other words, they're not residents of Mecca—they have to go out of Mecca to put on their Ihram and then come back into Mecca to do their Umrah. I want to know, why is this? Why do they have to go out and then come back in?
Because with Ihram you have certain responsibilities and certain restrictions imposed on you. So those who dwell in the area of Ihram, if they are supposed to be in Ihram all the time, the life would be extremely difficult for them. So they are supposed to be within that area and yet not in the position of Ihram. So this is an allowance given to them from Allah. So if they have to adopt—I mean, go into the state of Ihram—naturally they'll have to go out and start their Ihram and enter that region as a Muhrim from then on.
You know, let's see, this is a circle in which the people live. If everybody who lives in that circle automatically is considered to be in a state of Ihram, then the life for these people who are living there would be made very difficult, because those living in Ihram have great restrictions imposed on them. They have a certain type of clothing—I mean, no sewn clothes can be worn by them—and the whole attitude to life is so difficult. You can live that sort of life for a few days, but not all the time.
So despite the fact that they live in a physical area which is known the area of Ihram, they are permitted not to live as if they have taken Ihram. So when they want to become a Muhrim in that sense—they want to adopt Ihram—naturally they will have to go out and behave as if they are coming there for that short period from elsewhere. And they enter that region, and the moment then, with that intention, they take one step into the region, all the responsibilities fall on their shoulders like others.
Can I extend the question? Why doesn't that rule then apply to the residents of Mecca?
Because this is what I am telling you: the physical state or geographical state by itself does not impose anything. It is the will of Allah which imposes things upon people.
By itself, what is important in that region? Nothing. It is just the geographical tract as other world's tracts are. Now, this is the beauty of Islamic order or Islamic injunctions. All the sanctity that is given to a certain state is only given through Allah's orders, not directly. Any place made of earth and bricks doesn't become sanctified, doesn't become noble by itself. Only if Allah considers it noble and sanctified, then it becomes noble and sanctified.
So that region in itself has nothing; only it is turned into a sacred place when Allah declares it to be sacred. So when Allah has permitted them to live in the area of Ihram without Ihram, this is—they have every right to live their life without Ihram, because the area in itself doesn't automatically make a people Muhrim. It's not like a piece of magnet turning every piece of iron which comes into contact with it into a magnet. I mean, it's not a scientific phenomenon like that which has a direct bearing.
So that region in itself has no quality of turning people into Muhrims, that is sending them into a state of Ihram. For that, it is only Allah's orders, and Allah has told you the way you should do it. Only through, by adopting that way you can become a Muhrim, not otherwise.