1. Why are we encouraged to pray for the non-Ahmadi Muslims but not permitted to participate in their funeral prayers?
Question-and-answer session, 14 August 1985
Automatic transcript of the audio recording, checked against the recording and corrected with AI. Please check the wording in the recording.
Question: Why are we encouraged to pray for the non-Ahmadi Muslims but not permitted to participate in their funeral prayers?
In the Friday sermons, you asked us to pray for the non-Ahmadis, so why can't we say funeral prayers for the non-Ahmadis? What? What? In the Friday sermons, you asked... I said I asked you to pray for non-Ahmadis as well, yes? Yes, so why can't we say funeral prayers for them?
Ah, that is different. That is, in fact, I'll tell you what, the funeral prayer and the pray, ordinary prayer, are two different things, because the funeral prayer is called a part or a type of worship. It's included, it's called Salat. So the Holy Qur’an does not prohibit you for saying ordinary prayers for non-Muslims or even the people who hold differences within your own class. But the Holy Qur’an makes a distinction in saying your prayer behind others or saying Salat of those who do not belong to you.
An-Hazrat (saw), for instance, himself refused to say the Janaza prayer of such Muslims who had believed in him, who accepted all his claims, yet they had some faults, like they were bad in their financial dealings. There were some who borrowed money from others and wouldn't return. Right? So there are positive traditions definitely relating this case, that An-Hazrat (saw) refused to say the Janaza prayer of those people. So that was within Islam.
So if the non-Ahmadi Muslims refuse to believe in the person who was sent or who was raised by Allah Himself as Imam Mahdi or Messiah, this is a much bigger crime than just borrowing money and not returning, isn't that? So the Sunnah, the tradition of An-Hazrat (saw), establishes this: that you cannot, you can refuse to say the Janaza prayer of even your brothers for certain reasons. But as such, the whole community cannot refuse to say the Janaza prayer of a single person. They are two different things, and you will not understand it because—I mean ordinarily you shouldn't be able to understand, because these are the terminologies of Muslim jurisprudence.
Anyway, I'll try to explain. According to Muslim jurisprudence, there are certain acts which are binding on each individual, like saying prayer, ordinary prayer, not Janaza prayer. So you can't, if you are a Muslim, you can't do without praying. I mean, without saying regular prayer, you won't be any more longer a real Muslim.
But there are certain acts which are called Farz-e-Kifaya, which means although they are binding on the body of Muslims as such, but not binding on each Muslim. So even if a few Muslims say the prayer of a deceased, Janazah prayer of a deceased, that obligation would be fulfilled. They would have discharged their obligation as a body of Muslims. But if none among them says the Janazah prayer of a deceased brother, then the entire body would be held responsible for not acting according to the dictates of Allah. So this is what is called Farz-e-Kifaya. Janazah falls into that category.
So if we do not say the Janazah prayer of some non-Ahmadi Muslim and the other Muslims following that sect, for instance, say the Janazah prayer of those Muslims, as a representative of the Muslim body, they have done the act and all the Muslims are absolved of this responsibility. But if none says, in that case, in certain instances we are permitted to say the Janazah.
For instance, once a matter, a case was referred to Hazrat Khalifatul Masih As-Salis, my predecessor, about the body of a Muslim found in a crash in some Scandinavian country. An air crash took place, a body of a Muslim was found, and there was no other Muslim except the Ahmadiyya community available for saying the prayer. When they referred to Hazrat Khalifatul Masih As-Salis the case of that Muslim, the reply was that whoever belongs to the Ummah of Hazrat Muhammad Mustafa (saw) has this fundamental right that when he dies his Janazah prayer would be performed. So in case no other Muslim is available, then Ahmadis would say the Janazah prayer and an exception would be made.
So this is what I mean by Farz-e-Kifaya. And we are prohibited because they have committed the crime of refusing to believe in the Imam appointed by Allah. It's a very big crime. Because they don't believe in him, well, it's Allah who is to decide whether they are right or we are right. But in principle, if they had deviated from the path to that extent, we have a right to refuse to say their prayer.