4. What is the meaning of the Arabic phrase "Khataman Nabiyeen?"
Question-and-answer session, 14 August 1985
Automatic transcript of the audio recording, checked against the recording and corrected with AI. Please check the wording in the recording.
Question: What is the meaning of the Arabic phrase "Khataman Nabiyeen?"
I have some Muslim friends, but they're not Ahmadis, and they have asked me to um find out from you what the word Khatamun Nabiyyin means. Yes. Well, I know myself, but I don't know how to explain myself, so if possible, could you?
Well, this is a question which requires a very wide and widely covering answer, and it the question should be treated in depth. In fact, I have spoken for nearly five hours on this subject at Jalsa Salana, and still I couldn't exhaust myself, I mean exhaust the subject. And I have spoken elsewhere on different angles of the same subject. So how can you require me to do justice to this quest- this important question in a matter of a few minutes?
But if you want just the bare facts, the bare facts are that we believe, in Ahmadis, in all the possible meanings of the word Khatam.
It should be remembered that the word Khatam has a Zabar inflection on the Te part, the word Te. There are three deflection- inflection- deflec- inflections in Arabic: a Zabar, a Zer, and a Pesh. Like the English vowel system, this is a vowel system in Arabic. If it is Zabar, it is read Khatam. If it is Zer, it is read Khatim. If it is Pesh, it would be read Khatum, but Khatum is no word. So either it could be Khatam or Khatim, and they both have different meanings.
Khatim has the measure of Ism Fa'il, which is like Qatil. Qatil means the one who murders; Fa'il, which means one who does a thing; and Hamil, the one who bears a thing; and Shamil, who shares a thing; and Sha'ir, who says poems, verses, sher, and so on and so forth. The measure is exactly the same, and each word which you pronounce like this in this style bears the same meaning of somebody who does a thing. So Khatim, if it were a Khat- the word Khatim in the Holy Qur’an, it would mean the one who finishes: Khatama, Yakhtimu, Khatimun. But the word Khatam with a Zabar, that is a positive inflection on it, does not mean Ism Fa'il. It means a different thing. And the Arabic, all the Arabic dictionaries give this, support this view, that the word Khatam means a ring, a signet ring, in fact.
Like the one I'm wearing. This is the true meaning. Khatam is the signet ring which carries some inscriptions on the one side, the flat side. So because the Arabs, or the people in that age, used to stamp their letters with their signet ring, which was inscribed something on it, so that was used as a seal. So the derived meaning of the word Khatam is the seal. So the second meaning, and in fact the meaning of the word as it is used in the Holy Qur’an, is seal.
So what would be the meaning of Seal of Prophets? Now this is to be understood. Anhazrat (saw) was not a thing like a, I mean a dead thing like a ring, so it must have its significance, and it must derive its significance from the usage of the ring, which is signet ring. So that means he is the Seal of Prophets or certifier of all prophets, without whose seal a prophet would not be called a prophet. That is the one most important, fundamental meaning.
That is to say, if you want to measure the truth of a prophet and he is proved good and true according to the standards laid down by Hazrat Muhammad Mustafa (saw), then and only then that prophet should be believed in. But if he does not bear the testimony of Anhazrat (saw) and of the Holy Qur’an, that prophet will be without the seal mark of Anhazrat (saw), so he will not be a prophet at all. That is one meaning.
Another meaning derived from the same word, as extensively used in the Arab world, are to be the best. The word seal in Arabic is used to mean the best, and this should be remembered. And this meaning is true in not only in Arabic, but in every other language of the world. This is the most interesting thing. It is used both as Khatam or as Khatm, and in verb form as well, not only in the noun form. For instance, in Urdu we say, “Us par sha’iri khatm hai, us par hikmat khatm hai.” In English we say, “He is the last of things,” “He is the last word.” Both these have the same connotation. It means that he is the very best among his class, among his class. When you say somebody is Khatam-ush-Shu'ara in Arabic, that also means exactly the same thing. For instance, Mutanabbi, a great Arabic poet, is called Khatam-ash-Shu'ara, exactly like Khatam-an-Nabiyyin mentioned in the Holy Qur’an.
So in this sense, Khatam means the very best, not the last in time, but last in status, the highest in his class, the very end of things in the meaning of that in in this in sense, not in in time.
So when we say aap par khitabat khatm hai, aap par hikmat khatm hai, aap par sha'iri khatm hai, or you are last word in this and you are last word in that, it always means you are the very best. So we also agree that this is the true meaning, and in fact this is the most fundamental meaning of the word Khatam. And in this sense, the word Khatam is used by Anhazrat (saw) himself as applied to Hazrat Ali, the fourth Caliph of Islam. Once he addressed Hazrat Ali and told him that: Anta Khatamal-Auliya'e wa ana Khataman-Nabiyyi- Khatamal-Ambiya—"O Ali, you are the Khatam of the saints, or saintly people, as I am the Khatam of the Prophets."
So we quote this tradition extensively in favor of our interpretation of Khatamun-Nabiyyin, as against the interpretation attributed to this idiom by our non-Ahmadi ulema who are very hostile to us on this regard, in this regard. They say the word Khatam should be meant, should be translated only as last in time, after which there is none. And they insist the that the Arabs only use it to indicate finality in time, not in status. This is the debate going on between us and the non-Ahmadis.
So we quote no less an authority than Anhazrat (saw) himself, who knew Arabic far more, much, much more than all the combined Arabs of today. And even his enemies admit that the his knowledge of Arabic and his style of Arabic and his class of Arabic was second only to the Holy Qur’an. They say, Afsahal-Arabe ba'da Kitabillah—after the Holy Qur’an, the most beautiful speaker or writer a speaker of Arabic was Hazrat Muhammad Mustafa (saw). So if he uses the word Khatam in some sense, there is no man on earth who can deny that usage to be the correct usage. These are argument.
So we find him addressing Hazrat Ali and telling him, "You are the Khatam of saintly people, of Auliya, as I am the Khatam of all the prophets." So we generally ask our adversaries, the hostile ulema, to translate this tradition as they please, and then they will find themselves in great difficulty. They can't get out of this mess. If they translate it as final in time, after which there is none of that class to appear, then they will have to translate it in application to Hazrat Ali as well, because the same word, the same idiom, and said by the same person in the same breath; in one single sentence both these words are combined. So if you translate it and try your hand at it, you'll you'll be surprised that it's impossible.
If the word Khatam really means final in time, the last in in the sense of time, so that none can appear after him of belonging to that class, then you know what Anhazrat (saw) has told Hazrat Ali? Of course you know then, because I have just quoted the Hadith. He said, you are the Khatam of Auliya, that is saintly people, as I am Khatam of Prophets. So that would mean that, "O Ali, you are the last of saintly people to be seen in Islam as I am the last of prophets to be seen in this world. After you, no saint will ever be born in Islam, no pious person will ever appear in Islam. You are the last. Whoever wants to set his eyes on a saintly person, he should set his eyes upon you, like after my death the world will never see a prophet again."
Is that a right meaning? If that is the meaning, then Islam is devoid not only of prophethood, but of every good quality, because saintliness is the ultimate of every religion. If you can't gain saintliness from any religion, then what is left there? Nothing.
So we quote not only Anhazrat (saw)—we begin with him because he is the first and last of course—but we quote other Arabs in support of our usage. We say we say Mutanabbi, for instance, as I have just quoted, is called Khatam-ush-Shu'ara. And not only that, we quote that Bu Ali Sina is called and still it is written on on his Al-Qanun, the Canon, you know, that is a famous book on medical on on on medicine, and it is held in very high respect by by the all of the world. And Canon is a byword now in the history of medicine, and Bu Ali Sina is supposed to be a legendary figure, a classical person in the art of healing. So his all the doctors, all the people worth the song here in attached to this profession know Bu Ali Sina, what what he is and how big a physician he was. So on his book on the art of healing, whose name is Al-Qanun—it is said it is read in English Canon—of Bu Ali Sina, it is written that he was Khatamal-Atibba, like Anhazrat (saw) is declared Khatamun-Nabiyyin in the Holy Qur’an.
Like Hazrat Ali is called Khatamul-Auliya, like Mutanabbi is called Khatam-ush-Shu'ara. Now, would you attempt to translate it in the way the Muslim ulema opposed to us would have us translate word Khatamun-Nabiyyin? Try your hand, and then you'll see how difficult, how impossible it becomes for you to do that. Because if the word Khatam, as they insist, has no other meaning but the finality in time, then you know what all this means? That means Bu Ali Sina was the last of the physicians that the world was ever to set its eyes upon, and after that, no physician would ever appear on earth. Mutanabbi was last of the prophets- last of his class, last of of of poets, last of his class, and after Mutanabbi's death the world would be completely devoid of poetry and no poet would ever be witnessed, never be seen on this earth again. And that means that Hazrat Ali, as I have just told you, was the last of saints. So the whole world of Arabic expressions goes awry, topsy-turvy; you find disorder in the world of meaning. So this could not be true.
But the meaning which we insist are the true meaning of the word Khatam are applicable in every position, every situation, and there is not the slightest objection against those meanings. You apply those meanings to any situation you can conceive, and the answer will always be correct. That is the very best.
So, the Holy Qur’an tells us, of all the prophets, Hazrat Muhammad Mustafa (saw) stands supreme beyond a peer, beyond an equal. He is the very best and the very highest of all the prophets, and this is true. And Anhazrat (saw) tells us that Hazrat Ali, karramallahu wajhahu, was the best of saintly people who were ever to appear in his ummah. He was the greatest of saints. And he is held in this position, although among khulafa, Hazrat Abu Bakr is held to be the first, but the Sufis have their origin from Hazrat Ali. And there is a special, you know, term: saint, wali, and Hazrat Ali seems to be, or is accepted to be, the very best of the Auliya of the ummah. In that class, I mean. Among the poets, the Arabs still say Mutanabbi is the best. Among the healers, it is still held that Bu Ali Sina was the topmost, although he belonged to a very old age, but his works are classical and so original that the West had to borrow from him.
And yet he is held in the highest esteem, like Aristotle is you know in his own region, like Plato in in philosophy and so on. So this is the true meaning: Khatam, to be the very best, the topmost.
And the third meaning, which is also established, is the the beauty, the the the adornment. Because ring to a finger is a source of adornment in beauty, like all ornaments are to ladies. So the ornament of a finger is a ring. If you wear a ring and you remove it from the finger, the finger looks without, you know, that slightly something, without some important thing. It is in in ladies, in a in a in a in bride's hand, in a in a bride's little finger, you can see you can imagine how beautiful the ring appears. And without the ring, the finger is seems to be devoid of some charming element.
So, in that regard, the word Khatam is used also by the Arabs extensively. If somebody is the source of charm and beauty among some people, the very the most beautiful among a a gathering, the very first in beauty and charm, as if he or she were responsible for all the beautiful beauty of that atmosphere, then that person is called Khatam as well. For instance, you know, there are some people, when they leave the session, you feel as if all the charm has left; when they come, as if they have brought all the charm with them. So in that sense, the word Khatam is also applicable to Hazrat Aqdas Muhammad Mustafa (saw), and it means that he is the very charm, the spirit, the the the very essence of prophets. If he were not there, the session of prophets was without would be without charm, without attraction, without beauty. He has brought beauty to the prophethood. He has brought excellence and charm and all that is adorable to the Anjuman, to to the class of prophets. So, we also believe in that.
So, whatever is authentic, we believe. Not only that, we extend this concession to the adversaries of Ahmadiyyat that, 'All right, you translate it as you please. Whether it is authentic or not authentic, we accept. But we are going to prove it that you do not believe in that, and we we believe in your meaning as well.' So, they say, 'All right, as as Khatim, the one who finishes.' Khatama means he finished. Khatim, if it is read with with a with a Zer inflection—instead of Khatam you read it Khatim—then it would mean the one who finishes prophets.
So they say, “Look here, now you have you have to agree that prophethood is finished. He has finished all the prophets.” We said, “Yes, but in what sense? I mean, you can finish a thing by eating it up or by killing someone. That is not what he has done. What does it mean he has finished?”
First of all, you concentrate and find out the meaning of this word as applicable to to the situation, then we will we will see what happens, what results from all this investigation.
Now, the prophets, if you say prophets are finished, that is a different thing. But if you say somebody has finished the prophets, what would what would it possibly mean? It can only mean two things: either that somebody has killed all the prophets, or that somebody has appeared at a time when no other prophet prior to him was alive, automatically as if he was had finished them. That is the physical meaning.
And the spiritual meaning, which are in fact more appropriate and apt for this situation—because prophets are have come for spiritual reasons, not for physical finishing people, finishing of the people; they come for the for the spiritual world—so the spiritual meaning of finishing in this context would be that a prophet has come who has finished other prophets in their spiritual benefit. That is to say, they will not anymore give their benefit to any people. All the benefit which is to be had now is to be had from the one who has finished the earlier prophets, and the benefit begins to flow from him now, not from the earlier prophets. This is the true meaning of the word Khatim, if if it is translated as the one who finishes.
In no other sense could Anhazrat (saw) finish all the prophets: either he happened to be born or to be raised at a time when all other prophets had died and there was no other prophet living, so as if he were the finisher of the all those prophets; or better so, he had finished them in their office, in the in the in the their missions. That is to say, they were no longer required; they were redundant. After the very best prophet had come, the smaller ones and the earlier ones whose missions had ended up anyway, they were just redundant; they were no not required. This is the meaning of true finishing, and this is exactly what we insist one should believe in.
But we believe in both these. I'll come to that.
In the first sense, we insist that we also believe in this meaning of the word Khatam, and our adversaries, who would tell the people on the beat of the drum that we do not believe in the word Khatam, themselves do not believe in it. Because according to our belief, all the prophets before Anhazrat (saw) had died a natural death before the appearance of Hazur. And nowhere on earth, search wherever you may please, would you find the mention of any living prophet at the time of Anhazrat (saw). So he was naturally the Khatam in this sense as well—the physical Khatam. When he appeared, there was no other prophet left.
But our non-Muslim ulema who oppose us, they believe that Jesus Christ, peace be upon him, was still alive. And he was a test case. If Anhazrat (saw) was to be taken as a physical ender of prophets, here was the test case: a prophet was living and he could not kill him. He could not finish him. The other way round happened, according to their belief. They still believe, and most insultingly to Anhazrat (saw), as we see it, that Jesus Christ remained alive during his lifetime. He saw Anhazrat (saw) die from the heaven, from above, and he still survived.
So, who is the last who is the last prophet then? The one who survives a prophet who is born in his presence and he dies a natural death after a few years and he still lives on and on, or the one who has died in his presence? I mean, who is the final one? So we believe that he is, Anhazrat (saw) is in this respect; they don't believe in him.
And the second meaning, which is the to real meaning, is the spiritual meaning: that when Anhazrat (saw) appeared, he made he rendered all other prophets unnecessary, meaningless. They were no longer required. Even if they had lived physically, they were not to be followed, because benefit was now to flow entirely and totally from Anhazrat (saw), who was raised for the benefit of the entire world. No other prophet in any other region would ever be required but Anhazrat (saw), and all the rest of the prophets were no longer needed.
Now, in this sense, we believe that he was the last of the prophets. Yet, our adversaries do not. Those who hold us responsible, I mean who declare that we deny in this meaning of the word Khatam, they themselves are in fact guilty of this denial. But first of all, let me further explain this meaning of Khatam.
When the night comes, when there is no sun, you need lights, artificial lights. But when the sun appears, are they any longer needed? Suppose you keep the the the lamps burning still; even if they are burning, they are not needed. They're useless, it is stupid, it is a madly act to keep the lights burning. It's a sheer very waste after the sun has risen.
So this is the true meaning of word Khatam in this respect. The very sun of prophethood, Hazrat Muhammad Mustafa (saw), has risen now from the horizon. And he is the sun of the entire globe. There are no two suns for this one globe. He has appeared, and after him nor before him a sun would be required. The result is that all the earlier prophets have have been rendered meaningless and useless.
But even if when the sun sets, even when the sun disappears, you get benefit of his light, not of somebody else's light, reflected from the moon. And the full moon is that of the fourteenth, which reflects the maximum light from the sun. So when moon lights the earth, he does not stand as rival to the sun. He derives all its light from the sun and reflects this to the to the people of earth, or to the earth, taking it, borrowing it from the sun, not from himself. So he can't be counted as a rival to the sun.
But if some other star appears and says, "Well, in in presence of this sun, you follow my light, and you don't you don't need any more this sun," that is an insult to the sun.
So they, the non-Ahmadi opponents of Ahmadiyyat, they believe exactly in that situation, in that possibility—I mean that, what I should call, I mean that concept of prophethood. They believe that despite the fact that Anhazrat (saw) is the last of the prophets, the final, the one who has finished all other prophets, yet Jesus Christ, peace be upon him, would be able to give his benefit to the earth, to the earthly people, to even to the Muslims.
Benefit and favors would flow from Jesus Christ at the end of the time, in the last ages, to the Muslim world as well. That is to say that he is still required, he is still needed, despite the fact that the age of Anhazrat (saw) has started. So, they do not believe in the finality of Anhazrat (saw) in this sense. He has come, he has rendered all other prophets useless, but Jesus Christ, peace be upon him—to him he could not render useless. And the world would at the end, when Anhazrat (saw) would no longer be alive, would be forced to derive benefit from the presence of Jesus Christ when he redescends to the earth, when reappears on earth.
So who is the last? Anhazrat (saw) or Jesus Christ? Of course Jesus Christ, in this sense. But we don't believe in that. We believe he's dead. He's dead physically; he's dead spiritually, beneficially. And no other prophet is to be followed now but Anhazrat (saw). And all the benefit which the men would ever draw, would draw from Hazrat Rasul-e-Karim (saw).
So, as I said, I should like to be brief. In that short period, I have explained the various meanings of the word Khatam from the point of view of dictionary and the idiom used in the Arabs. And I have quoted some Arab authorities using the same word. I hope you will understand. And you know the Hadith you quote... Just a moment.
Will you be able to explain this to your friends now?
Yeah, I hope so.
Yes, please.
And you know the Hadith you quoted, um could you tell me what book it's in?
What?
The Hadith that you quoted today.
Hazrat Ali?
Yeah.
Yes. That is found in, um I'll tell you, Tafsir-e-Safi—that is a Shia Tafsir—in which this Hadith is quoted. But it is also quoted by Sunni authorities, I don't remember the reference, but under Shia Tafsir Shafi, in under that under ayah, verse Khatamun-Nabiyyin, you'll find this tradition quoted. And this tradition of Huzoor-e-Akram (saw) is also quoted by Sunni traditionists with a slight variation. The word Khatam is common in both, but instead of Khatamul-Auliya, they use Khatamul-Asfiya. Practically it is the same thing.
For our purpose it is the same thing, because the word Khatam is used with relation to Auliya or Asfiya, it's one and the same thing. Asfiya means the chosen ones of Allah, and Auliya means the saintly people. So, Sunni traditions tell us that Anhazrat (saw) addressed Hazrat Ali and told him, "You are Khatamul-Asfiya." You are the last, according to their meaning, the last of the chosen ones of Allah. After you, that is to say, as if Allah would never choose any person for righteousness. This is wrong, obviously.
So anyway, this is the the one authority is quite enough for you: Tafsir-e-Safi. Sharh Tafsir-e- Al-Kafi, I think, is the Sharh of Tafsir-e-Safi. And on the border on the on the border of this Tafsir, Sharh Tafsir-e-Safi, you'll find this tradition quoted under the word Khatamun-Nabiyyin.